Smart. Sharp. Funny. Fearless.
Thursday, October 27, 2016

By Katy Murphy and Jessica Calefati, San Jose Mercury News

SACRAMENTO, California — A legislative push to permit California’s public universities to once again consider race and ethnicity in admissions appears to be on life support after an intense backlash from Asian-American parents who fear it will make it harder for their children to get into good schools.

A planned referendum sailed through the state Senate in January without fanfare on a party-line vote, but three Asian-American Democrats who initially backed the measure are now calling for it to be “tabled” before the state Assembly has a chance to vote on it — a highly unusual move. And it seems unlikely to get the two-thirds majority in the Assembly without the support of the five Asian-Americans in the lower house.

Over the last several weeks, the three senators who have had second thoughts about the referendum — Democrats Leland Yee, Ted Lieu, and Carol Lieu — said they have received thousands of calls and emails from fearful constituents who believe that any move to favor other ethnic groups could hurt Asian-Americans, who attend many of the state’s best schools in large numbers. A petition to kill the referendum now has more than 100,000 signatures, and email listservs for Chinese-American parents have been flooded with angry posts.

Three days ago, the senators sent a formal letter to Assembly Speaker John Perez urging him to stop the bill from advancing any further. “As lifelong advocates for the Asian-American and other communities, we would never support a policy that we believed would negatively impact our children,” the letter states.

Perez is reviewing the request, Will Shuck, a spokesman for the speaker, said Thursday. But even if he put the legislation up for a vote, support for the referendum will likely fall short of the votes needed to get it on the November ballot.

Five Assembly Democrats belong to the Asian and Pacific Islander Legislative Caucus, and if two or more of them vote “no,” the bill will fail. Caucus Chairman Paul Fong said Wednesday he has concerns about the proposal but would not say if he or other members of the caucus will vote against it.

“I believe every student should have equal access and opportunity to a quality and affordable education,” said Fong, a former teacher.

Since 1996, the year voters approved Proposition 209, state universities have been barred from “discriminating against or granting preferential treatment” to any racial or ethnic group in college admissions, hiring and contracting. Since then, admission offers to black students have plunged 49 percent at Univerrsity of California, Berkeley, and 16 percent at UCLA, the state system’s two most prestigious schools.

  • Hetero Lingo

    If we are free to respond to the fleeting circumstances we are constantly faced with, it will be impossible for another person to judge the merits of our choices and efforts correctly.

    • Paul Bass

      Hetero Lingo,
      Mixed speech? No kidding, this has NOTHING to do with the topic, and is a totally stupid unintelligible statement. Please go to bed…