Heritage Immigration Study Author: ‘I Have Not Examined The Whole Bill Yet’ [Video]

RobertRectorRobert Rector, the Heritage Foundation senior research fellow who co-authored the right-wing think tank’s heavily disputed study on immigration reform, admitted Tuesday that he hasn’t actually read the bill in question.

Rector made waves Monday with his report that the Senate “Gang of Eight” immigration reform bill would cost taxpayers a minimum of $6.3 trillion. That conclusion was immediately criticized by a wide range of Rector’s fellow conservatives such as Senator Marco Rubio (R-FL), Representative Paul Ryan (R-WI), and the Cato Institute, which called Rector’s methodology “fatally flawed.”

One of Cato’s chief complaints is that Rector ignored the historical evidence suggesting that immigrants’ wages would increase dramatically after they are legalized. Rector responded to that criticism at a Heritage Foundation event — after admitting that “I have not examined the whole bill yet.”

“One of the effects of immigration is to strongly drive down the wages of American workers…and in particular, what is happening with massive waves of illegal immigrants without a high school degree coming into the U.S., they have driven down the wages of the least skilled American workers,” Rector said.

“I have not examined the whole bill yet. I will, and if the bill looks like any other comprehensive bill that we’ve ever had, what this bill will have is a massive influx of even more unskilled immigrants,” he added.

Video of Rector’s comments is below, via Think Progress:

That Rector didn’t even read the bill that he is doing his best to kill sheds light on a broader problem with the Heritage Foundation under the leadership of former South Carolina senator and Tea Party hero Jim DeMint: by arming the right with either incomplete or completely false information, Heritage is actually undermining their ability to successfully argue against reform. As Matthew Yglesias put it in Slate:

As Republican members of Congress ponder what to do about immigration, having accurate information about its fiscal impact would be very useful to them. You actually want to have a team of people “on your side” who you can trust to do good work. Heritage is not that team.

To avoid making Rector’s mistake, you can read the full text of the Senate bill here.

Photo: The Heritage Foundation

Start your day with National Memo Newsletter

Know first.

The opinions that matter. Delivered to your inbox every morning

History And Terror In The Skies Over Israel

Anti-missile system operating against Iranian drones,seen near Ashkelon, Israel on April 13, 2024

Photo by Amir Cohen/REUTERS

Iran has launched a swarm of missile and drone strikes on Israel from Iranian territory, marking a significant military escalation between the two nations. Israel and Iran have been engaged in a so-called shadow war for decades, with Iranian proxies like Hezbollah rocketing Israel from Lebanon and Syria, and Israel retaliating by launching air strikes on Hezbollah missile sites. Israel has also launched strikes on Iranian targets in other countries, most recently an airstrike on part of the Iranian embassy in Damascus, Syria, which killed several top Iranian “advisers” to its military, including Mohammad Reza Zahedi, a senior officer in Iran’s Quds Force, an espionage and paramilitary arm of Iran’s army.

Keep reading...Show less
Whose Votes Does Biden Need To Win -- Hard Left Or Haley Republicans?

President Joe Biden

How A Dire Shortage Of Poll Workers Threatens Our Democracy

Barack Obama got it right. He refused to be held captive to his party's left wing. He adopted a strenuous policy of border enforcement, even as some Latino activists threatened to withhold their support for him. He had tense relations with Israeli leader Benjamin Netanyahu, but when anti-Israel protesters interrupted a Biden fundraiser over the Gaza conflict, Obama reprimanded them: "Here's the thing, you can't just talk and not listen." And the hall broke into applause.

Keep reading...Show less
{{ post.roar_specific_data.api_data.analytics }}