Type to search

Justice Department Plans To End Use Of Private Prisons

Headlines Infrastructure National News US

Justice Department Plans To End Use Of Private Prisons

Justice Department

The Justice Department announced plans to cease using private prisons Thursday, a week after a highly critical report was released by the DOJ inspector general about the oversight and safety of private facilites. Currently, private prisons house 12 percent of federal inmates, and Deputy Attorney General Sally Yates said in the memo released Thursday that the goal was “reducing — and ultimately ending — our use of privately operated prisons.”

The memo instructs federal officials to not renew private prison contracts at their expiration or to reduce their scope.

According to Yates,“They simply do not provide the same level of correctional services, programs, and resources; they do not save substantially on costs; and as noted in a recent report by the Department’s Office of Inspector General, they do not maintain the same level of safety and security.”

The announcement and DOJ report come after a Mother Jones investigation revealed major deficiencies in a private prison in Louisiana and a Nation magazine investigation earlier this summer that highlighted many cases of prisoner deaths under questionable circumstances. The Mother Jones exposé detailed reporter Shane Bauer’s undercover experiences as a private prison guard and documented a serious lack of staffing, security and higher levels of violence. The DOJ’s report itself, as well, found that private prisons are generally more violent than federal prisons.  According to the Nation report, the Bureau of Prisons contracted with private facilities in order to cut costs. Because of this scheme, the companies running private prisons are permitted to operate under a looser set of rules than government-run facilities — which led directly to unnecessary prisoner fatalities.


After the news was released Thursday, there was an immediate drop in stock prices for two of the country’s largest private prison companies. Although the private prisons will not have their government contracts ended immediately, every contract is expected to come up for review within five years.

“We have to be realistic about the time it will take, but that really depends on the continuing decline of the federal prison population, and that’s really hard to accurately predict,” Yates said.

Yates also said that private prisons had been shown to be less effective than government-run facilities. The three major operators of private prisons are Corrections Corporation of America, GEO Group and Management and Training Corporation.

Yates will unsure about the cost of the closure of prisons and did not make a decisive judgment on whether government costs would escalate.

Democratic nominee Hillary Clinton has stated that she would like to end the use of private prisons. The cessation of private prisons by the Justice Department will likely see an uptick in costs, despite what Yates may be publicly stating at this time, but the “for-profit” prison industry has been under public scrutiny for many years. Ending the use of private prisons may be the first critical step in restructuring the justice system at large.

Photo: U.S. Deputy Attorney General Sally Quillian Yates testifies during a Senate Judiciary Committee hearing on “Going Dark: Encryption, Technology, and the Balance Between Public Safety and Privacy” in Washington July 8,  2015. REUTERS/Kevin Lamarque  



  1. drdroad August 19, 2016

    About time. And I’ve read lots of articles about them also being too expensive. Privatization doesn’t mean much if we’re paying more.

    1. idamag August 19, 2016

      And, from our state’s experience, getting less.

  2. plc97477 August 19, 2016

    Good riddance.

  3. Jon August 19, 2016

    Every politician who supported privatization of prisons should be locked up in one of them. They were and are a severe disservice to the criminal justice system and taxpayers. The only people who have benefitted from them are the heads of companies earning unfair profits from them. Justice, rehabilitation, punishment, or any other goal of the criminal justice system was never in their lexicon and I was outraged when I saw politicians willing to enrich friends who sold this patently unfair system. The only word they knew was “PROFIT.” A betrayal of trust and shirking of responsibility for political favors was all privatization was from the start. I am glad to see the death sentence administered to it.

    1. CrankyToo August 19, 2016

      You nailed it, Bro.

  4. idamag August 19, 2016

    Idaho had experience with a private prison. The guards started something called the gladiators where they made two prisoners fight until one of them was out. There was a greater number of staff checked in than showed up at the prison. The state was paying for a better quality of food than the prisoners were getting. They found hardly anyone on the midnight shift. When the reports came out and an investigation was asked for, the governor said no. At last, the reports became a public scandal and the Attorney General demanded an investigation. There must be a whole lot of corporations, out there, salivating for the time when everything — schools, post office — Social Security, Medicare, you name it, is privatized.


Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.