Tag: fair and balanced
5 Examples Of Megyn Kelly’s ‘Fair And Balanced’ Coverage

5 Examples Of Megyn Kelly’s ‘Fair And Balanced’ Coverage

Screenshot/Fox News

Screenshot: Fox News

In a weekend interview with The Hollywood Reporter, Fox News Executive VP of Programming Bill Shine questioned those who accuse his network of skewing to the right. According to Shine, Megyn Kelly — host of The Kelly File — is someone who can “chip away at that reputation.” Shine attributes Megyn Kelly’s “newsier” reporting as part of the reason why Fox just reached its 50th consecutive quarter as cable news’ most-watched network.

But Megyn Kelly isn’t exactly a straight news journalist. Here are some of her not so “fair and balanced’ moments.

Kelly’s Obsession With The Black Panthers

In 2010, Kelly led Fox News’ deluge of racially charged coverage of a voter intimidation case in Philadelphia. In a two-week period, she spent 45 segments — more than 3.5 hours — discussing the “scandal.”

The case involved two members of the Black Panthers who stood outside a Philadelphia polling place in 2008. The Department of Justice, led by Bush appointee Michael Mukasey, declined to pursue criminal charges. Then after the start of the Obama administration, it served an injunction to King Samir Shabazz, who was filmed carrying a nightstick outside of a polling center. There wasn’t any other evidence of voter intimidation.

But Kelly used the incident to claim that President Obama and Attorney General Eric Holder were somehow protecting the Black Panthers, and that the DOJ had a policy to not prosecute black defendants.

She spent her time playing videos of Shabazz yelling about “crackers” and as Dave Weigel wrote at the time, convincing her viewers that “the New Black Panthers are a powerful group that hate white people and operate under the protection of Eric Holder’s DOJ.”

Kelly was even criticized by her own colleague, Kirsten Powers, in the video above, for taking advantage of racial tension and “doing the scary black man thing.”

Santa Claus Is A Real White Guy

Kelly intensified her network’s hysteria over a liberal “War on Christmas” by taking personal offense to a Slate article that suggested that there should be a new image of Santa, which children of all races can relate to.

Kelly scoffed at the idea. “I just laughed and said this is ridiculous,” she said on her show. “Yet another person claiming it’s racist to have a white Santa.”

She went on to reassure any kids who might be watching Fox News that, “Santa just is white.”

Later on in the segment, she also states that Jesus was white too, which is not exactly historically accurate.

Her Passionate Defense Of Hobby Lobby

After the Supreme Court sided with Hobby Lobby in its lawsuit against the federal government, Kelly went on The O’Reilly Factor to defend religious liberty — and push several factual inaccuracies along the way.

Kelly, like many other conservatives, conflated emergency contraception with abortion, saying that “it’s drugs that terminate an already fertilized egg.”

Actually, emergency contraception works before a woman is actually pregnant.

Kelly went on to insult Sandra Fluke and all other women who think they should have access to health care, saying that they should just pay for it on their own.

“Kathleen Sebelius had some of her HHS minions go down in the basement and write a regulation that said as part of Obamacare, you have to cover 20 out of 20 birth-control drugs — 20 out of 20,” she said. “And then women like Sandra Fluke started saying, ‘I’m entitled. Oh my God, I didn’t realize how victimized I was all those years when I was paying for it on my own.”

That Time She Called The Gender Pay Gap A ‘Meme’

In a discussion about how the Democratic Party excludes women who don’t want equal pay, Kelly dismissed and mocked the very real gender pay gap.

“They think you’re anti-woman if you question that meme about equal pay.”

Kelly’s segment was just one piece of conservative resistance to equal pay, even though women still make an average of 77 cents for every dollar a man earns.

When She Called Pepper Spray ‘A Food Product’

After UC Davis campus police sprayed students with pepper spray at an Occupy protest in 2011, Kelly went on The O’Reilly factor to discuss the incident.

Kelly started off the discussion by dismissing the gravity of the situation. O’Reilly asked her, “Pepper spray, that just burns your eyes, right?”

She responded, “Right. I mean, it’s like a derivative of actual pepper. It’s a food product, essentially.”

Kelly and O’Reilly went on to defend the actions of the police, stating that they were only acting on university orders. O’Reilly even felt it was necessary to point out that UC Davis is a “fairly liberal campus.”

Want more political news and analysis? Sign up for our daily email newsletter!

What Fox News Isn’t

A few words on what Fox News is.

The question has, of course, been debated forever. Fox says it is, as the name would suggest, a news network. Its critics say it is actually the propaganda arm of the Republican Party and that its highest loyalty is not to accuracy, fairness or other journalistic values but to the furtherance of the party line. Not that any sentient life form should need the help, but events have recently arranged themselves such as to make painfully obvious which view is truth and which is tripe.

As it happens, one of the biggest news stories of the past few weeks has been the phone-hacking scandal that now ensnares media baron Rupert Murdoch. For those who somehow missed it, it involves revelations that reporters at Murdoch’s News of the World British tabloid routinely paid police sources for information and hacked into people’s cellphones, including that of a murdered 13-year-old girl.

That’s led to the shutdown of the 168-year-old newspaper, a spate of resignations and arrests, hearings in Parliament, rumored hearings in Congress and criminal investigations here and in the UK. This story is a gift from the news gods, and any news organization worthy of the name would jump on it like a trampoline. Most have. Fox has not.

The Pew Research Center’s Project for Excellence in Journalism just surveyed reportage of the story in two time frames: July 6-8 and 11-15. In that period, according to Pew, CNN devoted almost 170 minutes to the story, MSNBC about 145. Fox? About 30. That bears repeating: One of the biggest stories of the summer gets, over the course of six days, a half-hour of attention from Fox “News.”

Now, let us be fair and balanced here. Fox is owned by Murdoch, and the last thing any news organization wants is to be in the awkward position of reporting on itself. To have to air that which might embarrass or damage colleagues or bosses is the definition of a no-win situation, especially since there will always be doubts, from within and without, about your ability to do so fairly. But when professionalism demands, this is what you do.

When CBS News’ report on President George W. Bush’s service in the Texas Air National Guard turned out not to be credible, CBS reported it.

When Jayson Blair hoodwinked and humiliated the New York Times, the New York Times reported it.

When NPR was mortified by a deceptively edited hidden camera sting, NPR reported it.

Fox’s failure to report — and allow viewers to decide — speaks volumes and offers a definitive answer to the question of what Fox is.

It is the nation’s leading manufacturer of false outrage and fake fury — War on Christmas! War on Christmas! — the top supplier of bogeymen for those who need to feel terrorized in order to feel alive.

It is America’s No. 1 distributor of misinformation — Hide Nana! The death panels are coming! — a warehouse of conspiracy theories, junk history and dubious “facts” given credit by virtually no one who does not watch Fox.

It is a noisemaker, a box of cacophony from which reason will seldom emerge unscathed. And it is a bovine excreta machine.

But a news organization? No. That is a designation you have to earn.

Step 1: Report the news.

Leonard Pitts is a columnist for the Miami Herald, 1 Herald Plaza, Miami, Fla., 33132. Readers may contact him via e-mail at lpitts@miamiherald.com.

(c) 2011 The Miami Herald Distributed by Tribune Media Services, Inc.