Tag: isaac herzog
The High Cost Of Bibi’s Comeback

The High Cost Of Bibi’s Comeback

WASHINGTON — Wednesday was a hard day for pro-Israel liberals.

Some of the dejection arose from sheer surprise over Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu’s victory, and especially the size of his margin. The pre-election polling — by law, polls can’t be published within five days of voting — showed Netanyahu’s Likud Party trailing Isaac Herzog’s Zionist Union, the main opposition that allies Israel’s historic center-left Labor Party with the smaller centrist party of former Foreign Minister Tzipi Livni.

On Tuesday, the exit polling found Likud essentially tied with the Zionist Union. Netanyahu’s apparent 30-to-24 seat advantage over Herzog in Israel’s 120-member parliament emerged only when nearly all the votes had been counted in Wednesday’s early morning hours. Senator John McCain (R-AZ), proclaimed on Twitter: “Congrats to Bibi — the comeback kid!”

But far more disturbing than Netanyahu’s electoral miracle (at his victory party, his supporters proclaimed him a “magician”) was the way he brought it about. Seen abstractly as a matter of pure politics, his moves were brilliant. Viewed in light of Israel’s long-term survival, they were reckless, or worse.

Netanyahu’s only path to survival was to boost Likud’s vote and seat-share at the expense of smaller right-wing parties. And so he tacked hard to the right. He abandoned his publicly stated support for a Palestinian state and engaged in what The Atlantic’s Jeffrey Goldberg saw as a version of the old Republican “Southern strategy” that had been aimed at consolidating white votes.

On Election Day itself, Netanyahu made reference to the relatively high turnout among Israel’s Arab voters and declared: “Right-wing rule is in danger. Arab voters are streaming in huge quantities to the polling stations.” Goldberg translated this as: “The Arabs are coming!”

That Arab citizens can vote in Israel reflects its commitment to democracy. A “Joint List” that aligned various Arab parties in a single bloc emerged as Israel’s third largest party. Yet as Goldberg noted, the Joint List was not the real threat Netanyahu faced. It was just an excuse for incendiary words to rally the right.

They did. Polling analyst Mark Blumenthal and his Huffington Post colleagues noted the right-of-center and religious parties had been slated by the pre-election polls to win 57 seats — exactly where the current tallies have them. Days earlier, polls showed Netanyahu winning only 21 or 22 of those seats. He won 30. The Jewish Home Party, led by next-generation right-wing politician Naftali Bennett, ran three to four seats below the pre-election poll projections, while the far-right Together Party, once projected at four seats, appears to have been shut out of the Knesset, Israel’s parliament, pending final returns.

So in electoral terms, Netanyahu’s gambits worked. But at what cost to Israel’s future?

Israel was already divided, but the harshness of the campaign split it further. The Israeli center-left very nearly succeeded in making the campaign about Israel’s social and economic problems and the country’s sharp class divide. Those will not go away. But in the end, Netanyahu made this into the one election he could win, focusing voters’ attention on security just before they cast ballots. As the political writer Anshel Pfeffer noted in the left-of-center newspaper Haaretz, the Israeli left needs a dose of populism to “truly engage with the Israeli working class.” Sound familiar?

Much will depend on Moshe Kahlon, a one-time Likud politician who was the other big winner on Tuesday. He broke with Netanyahu to form a new, more centrist party that secured ten seats. The betting in Israel is that he will join Netanyahu’s coalition. But the side bet is that because he and Netanyahu dislike each other and will disagree on policy, the coalition won’t last long. This could mean another election soon. And while Herzog failed, his Labor Party is better positioned than it has been since the late 1990s.

Liberal friends of Israel are not going to abandon their commitment to the survival of a democratic Jewish state because of one extremely troubling election campaign. Yet neither will they give up on the idea that recognizing the right of Palestinians to their own state — a view advanced by George W. Bush no less than by Barack Obama — is in the interest both of justice and, over the long run, of Israel itself.

Netanyahu has played fast and loose not only with those loyalties but also with the moral commitments of a large share of his own people. He will not easily live down the way he chose to win.

E.J. Dionne’s email address is ejdionne@washpost.com. Twitter: @EJDionne.

Photo: Israeli Prime Minister and Likud Party’s leader Benjamin Netanyahu gives a statement to the media at the Prime Minister’s residence in Jerusalem, on March 17, 2015. Results tallied Wednesday showed Netanyahu’s party with a decisive win. (Xinhua/Zuma Press/TNS)

After Israel Vote, Netanyahu And Herzog Scramble For Political Allies

After Israel Vote, Netanyahu And Herzog Scramble For Political Allies

By Laura King and Batsheva Sobelman, Los Angeles Times (TNS)

TEL AVIV, Israel — In a dizzying outcome to a divisive and angry Israeli election campaign, exit polls pointed to a virtual tie between the two main parties, leaving Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu and his chief rival scrambling early Wednesday to secure political alliances that would enable one of them to form a new government.

Netanyahu had gone into Tuesday’s vote trailing in opinion polls, so he painted the deadlocked preliminary outcome as a victory. And in the absence of a clear-cut defeat for his party, coalition politics now give the prime minister, a consummate political survivor, an edge.

Addressing cheering, chanting supporters early Wednesday at his headquarters, Netanyahu declared that “reality does not take time out. … The citizens of Israel expect us to swiftly form a responsible leadership that will work for them, and so we shall do.”

But his opponent Isaac Herzog said he too would try to head up a governing coalition. “We will wait for the real results,” he said. “The people of Israel want change.”

Throughout the campaign, the two candidates have been a study in contrasts, not only in style and personality but also on the big issues confronting Israel. Herzog said he would try to engage the Palestinians and mend ties with Europe and the United States; Netanyahu sought to quash Palestinian statehood hopes and railed against outside critics who he said were trying to unseat him.

Reflecting voter passions, turnout was even higher than the 68 percent in the last election, which was the highest in 16 years. Throughout the day, soldiers in rumpled uniforms, ultra-Orthodox Jews in long black coats and twentysomethings in nose rings made their way to polling stations across the country, sometimes waiting patiently in long lines.

Whatever the final voting results, they herald a fresh battle. No single political party has ever captured a majority of the 120 seats in the parliament, or Knesset. So the popular vote is only the first step in the painstaking process of assembling a governing coalition. As ballots were counted throughout the night, results showed some fluctuation that could affect coalition-building prospects in the tight race.

But if exit polls suggesting near-even votes for Netanyahu’s conservative Likud and Herzog’s left-center Zionist Union are borne out, the stage is set for the centrist party Kulanu, uncommitted as yet to either side, to play kingmaker by throwing its support to one of the two.

Kulanu’s leader, former Likud Cabinet minister Moshe Kahlon, was already being intensely courted by both sides.

Although an apparent dead heat was an enormous relief for the Netanyahu camp, it represented a deeply disappointing outcome for the Zionist Union.

Herzog’s supporters had hoped that the lead of up to five seats, projected in the final opinion polls before the vote, would translate into a victory sufficiently commanding that the 54-year-old lawyer-politician would be asked by President Reuven Rivlin to form the next government.

Rivlin was holding consultations with the various factions beginning Wednesday and within days was to issue an invitation to one of them to try to build a coalition.

The president has expressed hope for a so-called unity government that would incorporate the rival factions. Netanyahu, however, has ruled out such a scenario. The Zionist Union, having put the campaign focus in the final days on ousting the prime minister, would be hard-pressed to embrace him, although Herzog said earlier he would talk to any party, including Netanyahu’s.

As the exit polls were reported and the vote-counting began, the mood among the stunned crowd at Zionist Union headquarters was subdued, although Herzog’s post-midnight appearance drew warm cheers. “You put your heart and soul into this campaign,” he told backers.

Netanyahu in recent days had made a frantic push to retain support from conservative and nationalist voters amid signs the electorate had tired of him, and hardened already hardline positions toward the Palestinians. On the eve of the vote, he declared that there would be no Palestinian state on his watch and that Jewish construction projects would continue in East Jerusalem, which the Palestinians want as the capital of their future state.

On election day, he drew widespread criticism with a Facebook video declaring that voters from Israel’s Arab minority were descending “en masse” on the polls, a stance denounced as racist by his opponents.

The preliminary picture painted by the exit polls illustrated a highly fragmented political scene that analysts predicted would make it difficult for either Netanyahu or Herzog to assemble a governing coalition or to keep that alliance from fracturing.

The exit polls by the three main television channels may not prove accurate; some previous elections have seen substantial divergence between the initial indications and the ultimate count. Final official results will take days.

The exit polls and early tallies also pointed to a political landmark: an alliance of Israeli Arabs, who normally distance themselves from the country’s political scene, emerging as the third-largest party in parliament.

“We are in the midst of an historic founding moment,” said the alliance’s leader, Ayman Odeh, whose Joint List won up to 13 seats.

The new government that emerges from this maneuvering will be faced immediately with daunting challenges at home and abroad: economic woes that played an outsized role in the campaign; a damaged relationship with the United States, Israel’s most important ally; external threats such as Iran’s nuclear program, which Netanyahu sought to frame as the most crucial threat to Israel’s existence.

Herzog has said he will attempt to engage diplomatically with the Palestinians, a process that will be complicated by simmering anger over the summer war in the Gaza Strip and Palestinian moves to challenge Israel in the International Criminal Court.

The prime minister’s campaign had placed heavy emphasis on security issues, including the nuclear threat posed by Iran, while the center-left stressed social issues such as the soaring cost of living.

To some, Netanyahu’s relentless focus on threats to Israel amounted to a scare tactic.

Irit Neeman, a 58-year-old lawyer and talent agent, said she voted for the Zionist Union because “I’m fed up of living in fear.”

Despite the growing signs of social discontent, the prime minister’s core supporters remained loyal. In Tel Aviv’s open-air Carmel Market, traditionally a Likud bastion, 46-year-old Adi Hayek, who runs a stall selling cheap cosmetics and drugstore goods, said he would not turn away from Netanyahu now.

“It’s Bibi or nothing,” he said, referring to Netanyahu by his nickname. “We are in good hands.”
___
Times staff writer King reported from Tel Aviv and special correspondent Sobelman from Jerusalem.

An Israeli voter casts his ballot at a polling station in Bnei Brak, near the city of Tel Aviv, on March 17, 2015 (AFP/Gil Cohen Magen)

Israel Exit Polls Show Virtual Tie Between Netanyahu And Herzog

Israel Exit Polls Show Virtual Tie Between Netanyahu And Herzog

By Laura King and Batsheva Sobelman, Los Angeles Times (TNS)

TEL AVIV, Israel — Exit polls on Tuesday night suggested that Israel’s divisive and hard-fought election campaign had resulted in a virtual tie between the two main competitors, which could open the way for Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu to remain in office.

The exit polls, released moments after balloting ended, indicated that Netanyahu’s conservative Likud Party and the Zionist Union, led by Isaac Herzog, each took about 27 seats in the 120-member parliament, or Knesset. One TV channel said its poll indicated 28 seats for Likud.

The results, if borne out, would represent an enormous relief for the prime minister’s camp, after opinion polls last week suggested that Herzog’s party had pulled ahead by up to five seats. Netanyahu in recent days had made a frantic push to retain support from conservative and nationalist voters.

However, the early picture pointed to a highly fragmented political scene that could make it difficult for any leader to remain in power for long.

The exit polls by the three main television channels may not prove completely accurate; some previous elections have seen substantial divergence in the final count from initial indications.

Ballots were being tallied through the night, and a preliminary tally was expected early Wednesday. Final official results will take days.

Earlier in the day, Netanyahu had engaged in an extraordinary election day outburst directed at the country’s Arab minority, his political rivals and what he called foreign opponents seeking to engineer his downfall, leading to speculation that he believed he was in danger of losing the election.

Throughout the day, soldiers in rumpled uniforms, ultra-Orthodox Jews in long black coats and twentysomethings in nose rings made their way to polling stations across the country, propelling what was reported by election authorities to be a strong turnout as the vote stretched well into the evening. Election day was a national holiday, with nearly 6 million people eligible to vote.

Netanyahu, who as head of the conservative Likud Party has served as prime minister for the last six years, had lagged behind in pre-election opinion polls as he faced off against Herzog, whose party is considered center-left.

Under Israel’s political system, people vote for party lists, not individuals, so the real result will not be clear-cut even once the ballots are tallied. With the race so closely fought, some said they couldn’t make up their minds until they were in the polling booth.

One such voter was Michael Doron, a 46-year-old social worker from Mevaseret Zion, a town west of Jerusalem. She had intended to back her choice in the last elections — the centrist, pocketbook-minded party Yesh Atid, led by former Finance Minister Yair Lapid — but made a last-minute switch to the Zionist Union and Herzog.

“Why? Before anything else, we need to get rid of Bibi,” she said, using the nickname by which Netanyahu is known to friend and foe alike.

Although election rules ban the release of opinion polls while the vote is going on, parties make internal assessments of the voting trends, and Likud appeared alarmed by what it was seeing as the day wore on. The prime minister sought to summon the media to his residence for a live early-evening broadcast, but the Zionist Union obtained an injunction banning it as improper electioneering.

Earlier, in remarks that were swiftly and widely condemned by opponents, the prime minister contended in a video posted on Facebook that “Arab voters are moving en masse to the polling places” — referring to indications of a strong turnout among Israel’s Arab minority after the formation of a political alliance meant to give them more clout in the Knesset.

After being rebuffed in his efforts to go on live TV, Netanyahu’s campaign posted a second Facebook video in which he warned that “we are in a fateful battle … the only way to reduce it is go to vote Likud.” He repeated allegations that foreign money has buoyed left-wing organizations seeking to push him from office, and insisted that his main opponents would make “every concession” to the Palestinians.

Netanyahu backed down slightly on his remarks regarding Arab voters, saying that they had a right to cast ballots, but suggested that transportation to the polls had been organized by outside groups targeting him and his party.

“Netanyahu’s panic is embarrassing,” said Herzog, making an appearance in the town of Modiin. “Anyone wanting a prime minister who cares about the citizenry, and doesn’t divide and incite, must get up, go out and vote.”

The voting results herald a fresh battle. No single political party has ever captured a majority of the 120 seats in the Knesset. So the popular vote is only the first step in the painstaking process of assembling a governing coalition. Usually the head of the biggest vote-getting party is tapped to do so, but not always.

Opinion polls conducted last week gave the Zionist Union an edge going into Tuesday’s vote, but even if Herzog’s party wins the largest number of seats, Likud has more potential allies among right-wing and nationalist parties. Thus, Netanyahu could be asked by the country’s president to form a government even if his party stumbles. Smaller centrist parties such as Lapid’s will probably emerge as kingmakers.

In the waning hours of the campaign, Netanyahu hammered on a theme surprising to few Israelis, declaring that no Palestinian state would be created on his watch. Although the Israeli leader had endorsed a two-state solution six years ago, the peace process has been stymied since, and his rhetoric was read as an attempt to siphon off votes from other right-wing parties and shore up Likud.

The new government that emerges from this maneuvering will be faced immediately with a daunting set of challenges at home and abroad: economic woes that played an outsized role in the campaign; a damaged relationship with the United States, Israel’s most important ally; external threats such as Iran’s nuclear program, which Netanyahu sought to frame as the most crucial threat to Israel’s existence.

Herzog has said he will attempt to engage diplomatically with the Palestinians, a process that will be complicated by simmering anger over the summer war in the Gaza Strip and Palestinian moves to challenge Israel in the International Criminal Court.

For nearly all of the campaign, Herzog had publicly teamed up with running mate Tzipi Livni, a former Cabinet minister and peace negotiator. But on the eve of the vote, the two quietly dropped a proposed arrangement to rotate the premiership between them, a deal that might have alienated some of the smaller parties the Zionist Union would need to form a coalition.

More than two dozen parties contested Tuesday’s vote, with only about half forecast to muster enough votes to pass a threshold for representation in the Knesset.

Despite the signs of Netanyahu’s growing personal unpopularity, some supporters remained loyal. In Tel Aviv’s open-air Carmel market, traditionally a Likud bastion, 46-year-old Adi Hayek, who runs a stall with cheap cosmetics and drugstore goods, said he would not abandon the prime minister now.

“It’s Bibi or nothing,” he said. “We are in good hands.”
___

Special correspondent Sobelman reported from Jerusalem and Times staff writer King from Tel Aviv.

Photo: Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu casts his vote (AFP/Sebastian Scheiner)

Israelis Vote In Tight Race As Netanyahu Fights For Survival

Israelis Vote In Tight Race As Netanyahu Fights For Survival

Jerusalem (AFP) – Israelis voted Tuesday in a close-fought election pitting the center-left against Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu who is fighting for his political survival after six years in power.

Heading to the polls on a cold, sunny day, voters cast their ballots in an election seen as a referendum on the Netanyahu years, with turnout unusually high among defiant Arab Israelis.

The last polls published on Friday indicated a narrow win for the center-left Zionist Union, with the outcome likely to determine the prospects for new Middle East peace talks and Israel’s troubled relations with its U.S. ally.

In a last-ditch appeal to the far-right ahead of the vote, Netanyahu ruled out the establishment of a Palestinian state if reelected, effectively reneging on his 2009 endorsement of a two-state solution.

Some 5.8 million Israelis are eligible to vote in Tuesday’s election, with 25 parties in the race for the Knesset’s 120 seats.

But even if Netanyahu’s right-wing Likud party does end up losing, he could return to power by virtue of Israel’s complex proportional representation system.

With smaller right-wing and religious parties likely to win more seats than the left, experts say Netanyahu has a better chance of piecing together a majority of at least 61 seats needed to win backing for a coalition.

Polling stations opened at 7:00 am, with campaigners putting up party banners and bunting outside, as in Jerusalem the first voters shuffled in to place their slips in a blue ballot box.

“I’d like to see Netanyahu disappear for many, many years. The most important issue is relations with the Palestinians,” said Shulamit Laron, as music blasted from a nearby shop whose walls and door were plastered with pictures of “Bibi” — the burly Israeli leader.

In the mixed Jewish-Arab port city of Haifa, around 50 people were lined up outside an Arab school to cast their vote.

“This is the first time that I’ve seen so many people here to vote,” said Ehab Hamam, a 37-year-old Arab Israeli working in hi-tech.

“For the Arabs, voting in this election is saying to the right: We are here,” he said.

“I’ve never seen such a long queue outside a polling station,” agreed 73-year-old Gideon Leber.

Voters had until 10:00 pm to cast their ballots and nine hours into the voting, turnout stood at 45.4 percent, down slightly from at the same time during the 2013 election.

Exit polls were to be published minutes after polling stations closed.

It is Israel’s third election since 2009 and the biggest challenge yet for Netanyahu, who is seeking a third consecutive term but has seen polls giving Isaac Herzog’s Zionist Union a three-to-four seat lead.

But even if Herzog wins the most votes, he will face an almost impossible task to cobble together a majority without forming a unity government with Likud — an option Netanyahu has ruled out.

So far, the centrist Yesh Atid and the leftwing Meretz have agreed to back him, but the Joint List of Arab Israeli parties has ruled out joining a Herzog-led coalition.

Netanyahu has warned that a vote for the Zionist Union could endanger Israel’s security and lead to the division of Jerusalem and the establishment of a Palestinian capital in the annexed eastern sector.

Ayman Odeh, head of the Joint List, said it was a “historic day” for Israel’s Arab minority, which makes up 20 percent of the population and expects to win up to 15 seats — which would make it the third bloc in the Knesset.

“When we have 15 MPs we will be able to influence the decision making, no one will be able to act without the third-largest party in parliament,” he told AFP.

Three hours into the voting, turnout among Arab Israelis stood at 10 percent, compared with around three percent in 2013, drawing a panicked response from Netanyahu.

“The rule of the right-wing is in danger. Arab voters are going to the polls in droves!” he said in a video on Facebook. “Go to the polling stations! Vote Likud!”

“I voted for the Arab List because solidarity between Jews and Arabs is important for me,” said Karin Michael, a 40-year-old book publisher enjoying the sunshine in Tel Aviv where pavement cafés were packed.

In Jerusalem, Moshe Simchovic, a 70-year-old veteran of the 1967 and 1973 wars, also voted for the Arab List, turning up at the polling station in a traditional Palestinian headscarf.

“Israel changed after 1967, it’s become fanatical and right-wing since then. Before, we were fighting for our lives but now we’re the conqueror,” he told AFP.

But Natalie, a voter in her early 20s, said she voted for Naftali Bennett’s far-right Jewish Home party, which opposes a Palestinian state.

“He represents what I believe in: the importance of the state of Israel, and not giving any of it away to the Arabs.”

Photo: An Israeli voter casts his ballot at a polling station in Bnei Brak, near the city of Tel Aviv, on March 17, 2015 (AFP/Gil Cohen Magen)