Tag: instagram
We Can't Blame Polarized America On Social Media Alone

We Can't Blame Polarized America On Social Media Alone

To hear some people tell it, social media — Facebook, Twitter, Instagram, YouTube, etc. — have driven Americans crazy. Our very democracy is imperiled by mis- and disinformation circulating online among angry crackpots fomenting civil war between rival “tribes” that sound like street gangs.

The Crips versus the Bloods, for example, or the Libs versus MAGA. Each a partisan cartoon to the other; both dreaming of victory and the subjugation of their imagined (and often largely imaginary) enemies.

Perhaps the most influential proponent of this view has been the eminent social psychologist Jonathan Haidt. A prolific author and self-described political centrist, Haidt took to The Atlantic recently to explain “Why the Past 10 Years of American Life Have Been Uniquely Stupid.”

“Something went terribly wrong, very suddenly,” he wrote. “We are disoriented, unable to speak the same language or recognize the same truth. We are cut off from one another and from the past.

“It’s been clear for quite a while now that red America and blue America are becoming like two different countries claiming the same territory, with two different versions of the Constitution, economics and American history.”

At the expense of being a smart aleck, when has this not been true? Never mind the unpleasantries of the 1860s. How about the upheavals a century later, when billboards appeared all over the American South depicting “Martin Luther King at a Communist Training School”?

For sheer chaos, nothing in my lifetime rivals 1968, with the assassinations of Rev. King and Robert Kennedy, followed by the Chicago police riot at the Democratic National Convention and the presidential candidacy of Alabama’s segregationist Gov. George Wallace.

One could go on. I’ve always been a fan of Philip Roth’s novel The Plot Against America, an alternate history in which Charles Lindbergh defeated FDR in the 1940 presidential election, leading to a Hitler-friendly regime.

Absurd, you say? Not much crazier than Donald Trump’s man-crush on Vladimir Putin. Not to mention North Korean dictator Kim Jong Un.

That said, there’s plenty of evidence for Haidt’s view of “social media as a universal solvent, breaking down bonds and weakening institutions everywhere it reached.” He thinks the great turning point came in 2009, when online platforms invented the “like,” “retweet” and “share” functions, greatly enhancing what George Orwell called “groupthink.”

Online echo chambers definitely encourage users to communicate only with like-minded people, Haidt stresses, thus “supercharging confirmation bias, making it far easier for people to find evidence for absurd beliefs and conspiracy theories ... such as those spreading across right-wing media and now into Congress. ‘Pizzagate,’ QAnon, the belief that vaccines contain microchips, the conviction that Donald Trump won re-election — it’s hard to imagine any of these ideas or belief systems reaching the levels that they have without Facebook and Twitter.”

True enough. On the Democratic left, Haidt thinks, online groupthink has helped stifle dissent at universities and large news organizations. One small but telling example: The New York Times has never published a review of J.K. Rowling’s most recent novel, The Ink Black Heart, although the author is perhaps the best-selling novelist in the English-speaking world. However, she has also expressed views deemed transphobic by activists and thus has been rendered an unperson in literary circles.

(I bought the novel on publication day but found it heavy going. I also find the hubbub over her views incomprehensible.)

The great political beneficiary of social media, Haidt argues, has been Trump, whom he calls “the first politician to master the new dynamics of the post-Babel era, in which outrage is the key to virality, stage performance crushes competence ...”

To me, Trump’s superpower was TV, not the internet. He imported the race-based themes of professional wrestling to politics; that, and his sheer shamelessness. Because something else happened in 2009 that was far more consequential to the MAGA crowd than Facebook’s “like” function: The United States inaugurated Barack Obama, a Black president with an Islamic-sounding name.

A large proportion of Trump’s target audience simply lost their minds. And social media had very little to do with it. One of his most attention-grabbing falsehoods, early on, was that he’d employed investigators who were making shocking discoveries about Obama’s allegedly foreign birth and secret Muslim faith. Un-American outsiders were taking over.

The same crowd that heeded Rev. Jerry Falwell’s Clinton Chronicles videos, depicting Bill and Hillary Clinton’s many supposed murders, and who sat stuck in traffic listening to Rush Limbaugh railing against liberal perfidy was all too ready to believe that a Black impostor had infiltrated the White House.

And then along came the Fox News network, developing a larger audience and a more comprehensively conspiratorial worldview — to the point where its executives now admit pandering to audience views not of what actually happened out there in the visible world, but what ought to have happened in the world of their collective imagination.

So it’s all Facebook’s fault?

I don’t think so.

Reprinted with permission from Sun Times.

Facebook And Instagram Kick RFK Jr's' Anti-Vax Outfit Off Platforms

Facebook And Instagram Kick RFK Jr's' Anti-Vax Outfit Off Platforms

During the COVID-19 pandemic, anti-vaxxers have been, to a large degree, far-right MAGA Republicans and evangelical Christian fundamentalists — although former President Donald Trump himself has encouraged vaccination, and former White House Press Secretary Sarah Huckabee Sanders has tried to put a pro-MAGA spin on the Moderna, Pfizer and Johnson & Johnson vaccines by describing them as “the Trump vaccine.” Democrats have, for the most part, joined President Joe Biden and Dr. Anthony Fauci, Biden’s top White House medical adviser, in encouraging vaccination for COVID-19. But one well-known Democrat who is known for his anti-vaxxer views is Robert F. Kennedy, Jr., who now finds himself at odds with Facebook and Instagram for spreading what those social media outlets consider misinformation.

Kennedy leads the Children’s Defense Fund (CDF), a nonprofit anti-vaxxer group. And on Thursday, August 18, its accounts were removed for both Facebook and Instagram, according to the New York Times. Those platforms are owned by their Silicon Valley-based parent company Meta.

Sheera Frenkel, a technology reporter for the New York Times and co-author of the 2021 book An Ugly Truth: Inside Facebook's Battle for Domination, explains, “In an e-mailed newsletter, Children’s Health Defense said Facebook and Instagram had taken down its accounts after a 30-day ban by the social networks. The nonprofit, which Mr. Kennedy has run since 2018, accused the apps of censorship.”


Kennedy, in an official statement, complained, “Facebook is acting here as a surrogate for the federal government’s crusade to silence all criticism of draconian government policies.”

That sounds like the type of rhetoric that Infowars’ Alex Jones or former Alaska Gov. Sarah Palin, both far-right MAGA Republicans and anti-vaxxers, would make. Jones, in fact, is so angry over Trump’s support of COVID-19 vaccines that he is calling for Florida Gov. Ron DeSantis, not Trump, to be the 2024 GOP presidential nominee. But the 68-year-old Kennedy is hardly an Infowars employee. Kennedy comes from the Democratic Party’s most famous political dynasty; he is the son of the late Robert F. Kennedy, Sr. (who was assassinated in June 1968 only two months after Dr. Martin Luther King, Jr.’s assassination) and a nephew of President John F. Kennedy, Sr. (who was assassinated in 1963). One of his uncles was the late Sen. Ted Kennedy of Massachusetts, and his cousins include former Rep. Patrick Kennedy of Rhode Island (one of Ted Kennedy’s sons) and the late John F. Kennedy, Jr.

The Kennedy family is synonymous with the Democratic Party and synonymous with liberal politics in New England. But CDF, Frenkel notes, is “widely regarded as a symbol of the vaccine resistance movement.”

“Facebook’s and Instagram’s actions are a blow to Mr. Kennedy, who is the son of the former senator and U.S. Attorney General Robert F. Kennedy,” Frenkel observes in an article published on August 19. “But the account removals do not completely block him from speaking online. While Mr. Kennedy was personally barred from Instagram in February 2021, his personal Facebook page — with nearly 247,000 followers — is still up. Other Facebook pages dedicated to Children’s Health Defense, including those of its California, Florida and Arizona chapters, also remain online and have thousands of followers, according to a review by The New York Times.”

Robert F. Kennedy, Jr.’s views put him at odds with many of his fellow Democrats, and vaccine proponents have accused him of spreading dangerous misinformation about COVID-19 vaccines — which they credit with saving lives.

First reported in Wuhan, China in late 2019, COVID-19 has, according to Johns Hopkins University in Baltimore, Maryland, killed more than 6.4 million people worldwide, including over 1 million people in the United States — making it the world’s deadliest health crisis since the Spanish flu pandemic of 1918/1919. Vaccine proponents such as Biden and expert immunologist Fauci have emphasized that while vaccines don’t eliminate the possibility of being infected with COVID-19, they are likely to prevent a more dangerous infection. Biden and Fauci have both been infected with COVID-19 in 2022 despite receiving vaccines and booster shots; they are examples of what health experts call “breakthrough” infections, but both of them had milder cases and did not require hospitalization.

Frenkel observes, “Over the course of the pandemic, Children’s Health Defense has repeatedly questioned the safety of COVID-19 vaccines, falsely saying that the vaccines cause organ damage and harm pregnant women. The organization has also tried sowing doubt about other kinds of vaccines. Over the last two months, it claimed that vaccines for tetanus caused infertility and that polio vaccines were responsible for a global rise in polio cases.”

Reprinted with permission from Alternet.

Student’s Instagram Threats Prompt Beefed Up Law Enforcement Presence

Student’s Instagram Threats Prompt Beefed Up Law Enforcement Presence

By Stephen Ceasar, Los Angeles Times

The presence of law enforcement will be bolstered at Santa Clarita Valley schools on Monday after a teenage boy was accused of posting death threats on social media aimed at students.

The 15-year-old boy was arrested Sunday after authorities started getting dozens of calls about the posts on Instagram that threatened to shoot high school students on an unspecified date. According to the Los Angeles County Sheriff’s Department, the boy told detectives he was trying to get a reaction from his friends and realized too late the posts had been taken seriously.

The boy, who was not named because he is a minor, is a student at a local high school, authorities said.

The posts, which have since been deleted, included racist and sexist remarks, as well as threats against women and minorities, authorities said.

The posts also included photos of guns, dead bodies, and a school marquee for a “Valencia High School,” all later found to be stock images found on the Internet.

“Valencia High School has been nominated to be shot up first,” another post said.

The suspect “actually had no intention of carrying out these threats,” said sheriff’s Deputy Joshua Dubin, a department spokesman. “We still take it very seriously.”

Deputies worked with the William Hart Union High School District and Instagram to identify the suspect and arrested him after serving a search warrant at his home Sunday morning, Dubin said.

No firearms were found during a search of the home and the boy’s parents have cooperated with the investigation, Dubin added.

District spokeswoman Gail Pinsker said the district takes the threats seriously and has zero tolerance for such acts.

“There will be consequences for any student who pulls a prank like this,” she said.

AFP Photo/Glenn Chapman

Interested in national news? Sign up for our daily email newsletter!