The National  Memo Logo

Smart. Sharp. Funny. Fearless.

Monday, December 09, 2019 {{ new Date().getDay() }}

It was Monday, after school. Toni Coral and four of her fellow high school teachers in Hamtramck, Michigan, were finalizing plans for the next morning.

They would meet at 5:30 for the two-hour drive to the state house in Lansing. Republicans were expected to pass legislation on Tuesday that would cripple, if not eliminate, unions. Coral and the other teachers were taking the day off, as allowed by their contract, to join thousands of fellow union workers in protest.

“Bring a towel,” the more experienced teacher said to Coral and her colleagues. “Bring a bottle of water, too.”

“Why?” Coral asked.

“Because there might be pepper spray again,” he said, referring to an incident at the Capitol the previous week when Michigan police sprayed protesters trying storm the Senate chambers. “The wet towel will help you breathe.”

Pepper spray.

This was a first in Coral’s 17 years of teaching. She has an 8-year-old son. She loves her job, and her students. She had to think about what she might be getting herself into.

She drove home and made dinner. Her son was with his father, so she had the time, and the silence, to consider consequences. She got back into her car and headed to the neighborhood hardware store.

“I need a pair of goggles,” she told the woman behind the counter. Coral figured the woman to be about her age, 45. She explained why she needed eye protection, and the woman handed her one of the better goggles in stock.

“Use these,” she told Coral. “They’ll seal tightly. No gas will get in.” Coral nodded.

“I can’t believe this,” she told the woman as she waited for her receipt. “I can’t believe I’m a high school English teacher and I’m buying goggles because I might get pepper-sprayed.”

The woman shrugged her shoulders and smiled. “You do what you have to do,” she said.

For Coral, that meant bearing witness to the Republican majority’s power grab to break the rights and bludgeon the souls of hourly wage earners.

“Every year around the world, there are people trying to organize workers, and they disappear,” she said. “The least I could do was show up.”

On Tuesday, as expected, Michigan’s lame-duck legislature rammed through so-called “right to work” measures that ban unions from requiring workers to pay membership dues. That evening, Republican governor Rick Snyder broke his word and signed the legislation into law.

Without dues, there are no unions.

Without unions, there is no collective bargaining.

Without collective bargaining, workers’ rights become desperate hopes that are bound to die long, ugly deaths.

Barack Obama — the pro-worker Democrat who was just soundly re-elected as president by his fellow Americans — got it exactly right this week when he called Michigan’s new law “the right to work for less.” This legislation was an act of revenge by a defeated party.

The unions have vowed to continue fighting, perhaps with a ballot initiative and by targeting incumbent Republicans for defeat. Here in Ohio, voters overwhelmingly defeated a similar law in 2011. It can be done, but it takes a toll on people, I’m telling you, especially when they’re already feeling so belittled, so targeted. The wounds here have not healed.

Toni Coral, the English teacher in Hamtramck, said she is in for the long fight — for as long as she has a job, anyway. She spent half of our phone interview talking about her students. Most of them live in poverty, and she worries about what all this change will mean for them.

She’s also afraid that, once the new law goes into effect, many of her fellow teachers will stop paying the $62 month in union dues.

“I keep thinking about how they’re trying to divide and conquer us,” she said. “How they use social wedge issues to get us to vote against our own economic interests. How we have to stop letting them turn us against one another.”

How she had to buy goggles before she felt safe to protest her state legislature for workers’ rights.

Add that to the list.

Connie Schultz is a Pulitzer Prize-winning columnist and an essayist for Parade magazine. She is the author of two books, including …and His Lovely Wife, which chronicled the successful race of her husband, Sherrod Brown, for the U.S. Senate. To find out more about Connie Schultz ( and read her past columns, please visit the Creators Syndicate website at

Photo credit: AP/Detroit Free Press, Eric Seals


Start your day with National Memo Newsletter

Know first.

The opinions that matter. Delivered to your inbox every morning

Mehmet Oz

Youtube Screenshot

Fox News is in attack mode after its own polling showed Republican nominee Mehmet Oz trailing Democratic nominee Lt. Gov. John Fetterman in the Pennsylvania Senate race.

The July 28 Fox News poll showed that Fetterman has an 11-point lead over Oz. Additionally, according to the poll, “just 35 percent of those backing Oz say they support him enthusiastically, while 45 percent have reservations. For Fetterman, 68 percent back him enthusiastically and only 18 percent hesitate.” These results, combined with data showing that Fetterman is outraising and outspending Oz, could spell disaster for the GOP hopeful. However, since this polling, Fox has demonstrated it’s a reliable partner to help Oz try to reset the race.

Keep reading... Show less
Youtube Screenshot

For decades, abortion was the perfect issue for Republicans: one that they could use to energize "pro-life" voters, and one that would be around forever. What's more, they ran little risk of alienating "pro-choice" voters, who had little concern that the GOP would ever be able to repeal abortion rights.

Key to this strategy was the assumption that the Supreme Court would preserve Roe v. Wade. GOP candidates and legislators could champion the anti-abortion cause secure in the knowledge that they would not have to follow through in any major way. They could nibble away at abortion rights with waiting periods and clinic regulations, but the fundamental right endured. And their efforts were rewarded with the steadfast support of a bloc of single-issue voters.

Keep reading... Show less
{{ }}