By Jason Sattler

4 Reasons The Individual Mandate Will Not Be Delayed (And 1 Reason It Could Be)

November 7, 2013 3:54 pm Category: Memo Pad, Politics 5 Comments A+ / A-
4 Reasons The Individual Mandate Will Not Be Delayed (And 1 Reason It Could Be)

The House Republican “Suicide Caucus,” which joined with Senators Ted Cruz (R-TX) and Mike Lee (R-UT) in demanding that the Affordable Care Act (ACA) be defunded as part of any deal to keep the government open, had a backup demand: delay the individual mandate.

The mandate requires that all Americans who can afford it purchase health insurance or pay a penalty that begins at $95 or 1 percent of yearly income, whichever is higher.

This aspect of the ACA was developed by conservatives as an alternative to the Clinton health care plan in the early 90s and it’s designed to end the problem of “free riders,” uninsured people who get treatment in emergency rooms with no hope of providers ever recovering the costs. The mandate provides the subscriber base insurers need to cover people with pre-existing conditions without charging them exorbitant premiums.

Delaying this aspect of the law could wound the ACA, or possibly even destroy it, before it’s ever given a chance to work. That’s why Republicans would love to see it happen.

However, the continuing problems with have given Republicans another opportunity to make the argument that the mandate should be delayed. Here are four reasons it’s not really “an option” and one nightmare scenario where it could be.

1. It will leave millions and millions of Americans without health insurance.
The Congressional Budget Office (CBO) estimates that delaying the individual mandate would leave millions uninsured. And those who did sign up for insurance would likely be sicker and thus costlier to cover. Other estimates suggest that the number of uninsured would increase by between 7.8 and 24 million.

Most of these people would be low-income Americans who are far more likely to use emergency rooms than those with insurance.

2. People will die.
A Harvard University study released in 2009 found that uninsured adults have a 40 percent higher death risk than those with private health insurance. ”Deaths associated with lack of health insurance now exceed those caused by many common killers such as kidney disease,” David Cecere of the Cambridge Health Alliance wrote in 2009.

Media Matters‘ Hannah Groch-Begley explains the risk of not having health insurance:

Those who lack adequate insurance often “avoid going to the doctor or getting prescriptions filled because they can’t afford it,” according to Kaiser Health News, and others “end up with medical debt and other severe financial problems.” The Commonwealth Fund has found that half of the underinsured ”said they had not received needed care because of cost,” and 67 percent of uninsured people “reported at least one cost-related problem getting needed care.” Emergency rooms are required by federal law to treat all individuals regardless of insurance, but the uninsured are less likely to receive follow-up care, are at higher risk for preventable hospitalizations and for missed diagnoses, and have significantly higher mortality rates than those with insurance.

Pages →  1 2

4 Reasons The Individual Mandate Will Not Be Delayed (And 1 Reason It Could Be) Reviewed by on . The House Republican "Suicide Caucus," which joined with Senators Ted Cruz (R-TX) and Mike Lee (R-UT) in demanding that the Affordable Care Act (ACA) be defunde The House Republican "Suicide Caucus," which joined with Senators Ted Cruz (R-TX) and Mike Lee (R-UT) in demanding that the Affordable Care Act (ACA) be defunde Rating:

More by Jason Sattler


5 Reasons The Deficit Has Fallen By Nearly $5 Trillion (And Why That’s A Bad Thing)

This year’s deficit will likely be $514 billion, down about a quarter from last year’s deficit of $680 billion, which was down by more than a third from the year before. “Since 2010, projected 10-year deficits over the 2015-2024 decade have shrunk by almost $5.0 trillion, $4.1 trillion of which is due to four pieces


5 Ways The GOP Refuses To Learn From History

It’s not entirely their fault. The 2014 map looks as if it were designed to make sure the GOP does not change. With a House majority they maintained in 2012 even though they won 1.4 million fewer votes than Democrats and as many as 11 chances to pick up the six Senate seats they’d need


5 Things You Need To Know About New GOP ‘Frontrunner’ Rand Paul

A new CBS/New York Times poll has bad news for the man who can only now be called a former frontrunner for the 2016 Republican presidential nomination — Governor Chris Christie (R-NJ). With 41 percent of Republicans saying they don’t want the governor to run and only 31 percent saying they do, he’s the only




  • sigrid28

    “Things are in the saddle and ride mankind.”–Emerson

    • Germansmith

      If you fall of a horse, climb on it again, and again, and again……
      Christopher Reed

  • Germansmith

    And I think even a propagandist should at least pretend to do a little work and actually go to the street and talk to real people before sitting there and write BS
    Places like Amazon, E-Bay can sell, ship, pay and keep track of who and what that person is buying and Gov. need to drop a billion in a system that still not work as intended trying to explain different health insurance plans to people that had never had any and may not even have a computer.
    Good Luck with that

    • sigrid28

      Not so fast. I’ve said this before on the NM comment thread, and it bears repeating: “In the ACA’s favor stands the longing of so many Americans who need health insurance themselves or long for it to sustain the well-being of a sick or disabled family member. Their love and patience can outlast these initial delays, as these families have already overcome the many obstacles that stand in the way of obtaining the best care available for their loved ones. They are warriors when it comes to struggle and sacrifice. The ACA will succeed on the basis of their will power and insistence that it should work. President Obama and the administration are not fighting alone.”

      • Germansmith

        It is only a matter of time

scroll to top