Smart. Sharp. Funny. Fearless.
Monday, October 24, 2016

This week, Weekend Reader brings you Above The Din Of War by veteran journalist and author Peter Eichstaedt. Above The Din Of War details Eichstaedt’s interviews with Afghans who discussed with the author their experiences during the war. Afghans opened up about what they’ve seen, how they feel about the United States, the Taliban, and the direction they hope to see the country move in. As the U.S. prepares to withdraw troops from Afghanistan, the fear of the country slipping back into turmoil and chaos looms. Eichstaedt’s firsthand account of life in Afghanistan coupled with his suggestions for withdrawal and further U.S.-Afghanistan relations offer a valuable perspective.

You can purchase the book here. A Q&A with the author is included at the end of the excerpt.


The Afghan Failure

No one is more worried about their future than the Afghans. As of this writing, the Taliban is stronger than it has ever been in the prior ten years. Life is more dangerous than ever before. Afghanistan is among the world’s poorest countries, and the Afghan economy is totally dependent on the foreign military and civilian aid programs. If the international community packs up and leaves, Afghans know full well that the Taliban will come back to power and again make their lives miserable. As Afghans fearfully prepare for an uncertain future, they have grown increasingly sullen and hostile. Who can blame them? After ten years of war and the expenditure of billions of dollars, what has changed? More important, what has gone so wrong when at first it had been so right?

The failures in Afghanistan can be attributed to an emphasis on the military solution to the exclusion of most everything else. The nation and its people were put on life support while the militaries of some forty nations waged war against the Taliban, itself a creature of a significant portion of the society. Civil society and government were left to atrophy.

In ten years of war, little or nothing has been done to improve basic aspects of Afghan society. A look at the numbers is shocking. Life expectancy in Afghanistan is less than forty-five years, one of the lowest in the world. One in every four children will not see his or her fifth birthday. For those who survive, expectations are abysmal. Only one in five adults can read and write, which is a vast improvement in ten years but still far from adequate. Unemployment is consistently about 40 percent.

Basic infrastructure is abysmal. Electricity only reaches a third of the Afghan population. Though 70 percent of all Kabul households are connected to the grid, power cuts are routine and brownouts are expected. Those who can afford them rely on polluting and noisy portable generators or on bottled gas, kerosene lanterns, and candles. Afghanistan’s power is imported from Iran, Turkmenistan, and Tajikistan and bolstered by a line from Uzbekistan, but it is hampered by antiquated and inadequate transmission lines. Although some $200 million annually is reportedly poured into improving the power supply, the projects languish due to cost overruns and the war.

Some people have suggested that Afghanistan would have been better off if countries like the United States had taken $500 billion of what it spent on the war in Afghanistan and given it directly to the people. Divided among the population, every man, woman, and child in the country could have been handed about $17,000. That is about ten years’ worth of income for the average Afghan. This notion points to the fact that while large amounts of international cash enter the country, little of it reaches most Afghans. Much of it comes into the country via nonprofit organizations that pay for high-priced international staff, their housing, their transportation, and their security.

As most Afghans have waited for their lives to improve, they have watched as heavily armed and well-equipped foreign militaries prowl the countryside, rolling down roads in every corner of the country. The presence of foreign armies has not made Afghans feel safe or protected. Rather, they feel the opposite. As the Taliban clumsily and ruthlessly detonates roadside and car bombs and launches suicide attacks, civilians bear the brunt of the bloodshed. Foreigners are viewed as the problem, not the solution, even though the Taliban has planted the bombs and conducted the attacks. It is no wonder that the Taliban is poised for a comeback. The lives of average Afghans have changed little in ten years of war, and international forces have gone from a cause for celebration to a thing to be hated.

What baffles most Afghans is why the U.S. and coalition forces have been unable to defeat the Taliban. Many Afghans insist that the United States could have defeated the Taliban any time it wanted but has intentionally dragged out the war. When I asked Afghans why America would do that, they responded with shrugs.

Buy From

Afghan Voices

Three knowledgeable Afghans, each a behind-the-scenes player, told me that the Taliban were not the problem behind the Afghan dilemma and never had been.

It was not easy to meet with Sibghatullah Mojaddedi, the president of Afghanistan’s upper house of parliament, the Mushrano Jirga, or House of Elders. Among his other duties, he headed the Afghanistan National Independent Peace and Reconciliation Commission. I had wanted to talk with him because it was his younger relative in Herat, Safiullah Mojaddedi, who had been kidnapped by the Taliban and ultimately set free in exchange for the release of Taliban prisoners, a deal that involved the elder Mujaddedi.

After negotiating a gauntlet of security at a government building in a quiet neighborhood of Kabul, I was ushered into a long, carpeted hall where about twenty Afghan elders were seated, each wearing a large turban and sporting a long, graying beard. They nodded gravely as I ambled to the far end, where Sibghatullah Mojaddedi sat in a padded wooden chair and casually motioned for me to sit. Despite his eighty-five years, Mojaddedi was a striking figure, dressed in crisp white cotton clothing and a turban to match, much like his colleagues. His large glasses magnified his eyes, which by any measure had seen a lot.

An ethnic Pashtun, he was the patriarch of one of Afghanistan’s eminent and extended religious families. Throughout most of his life, Mojaddedi had been integrally involved in the fate of his country. A moderate Muslim, he had been Afghanistan’s president for just two months in 1992 when the country struggled to set up a government in the turbulent days that followed the 1989 withdrawal of the forces from the former Soviet Union. He was quickly succeeded by the late Burhanuddin Rabbani, who two years later presided over the Afghan civil war. Mojaddedi resurfaced in 2003 to head the Loya Jirga, the national council of elders that adopted the modern Afghan constitution. He was later named to head the Afghan upper house of parliament, a position he continued to hold.

“Peace in this country is not possible with the ISI [Pakistan’s Inter-Service Intelligence agency] and Pakistan,” Mojaddedi said. Ninety percent of Afghanistan’s problems are due to Pakistan, he insisted, as terrorist fighters, including Chechens and radicalized Arabs, enter Pakistan and then “cross borders and cause problems for us. The main [barrier to] peace is the ISI. The terrorists are exported from Pakistan.” Although the US-funded Pakistan army fought against the Taliban in the border regions with Afghanistan, Mojaddedi complained that “it’s not enough. [The United States] needs to put pressure on Pakistan. Attack the ISI [training] camps. If they want peace, that is what they must do.” Some ten thousand fighters had been trained in these ISI-sponsored Taliban camps, he contended. “They have training centers in Pakistan, so why don’t you fight the terrorists there?” Mojaddedi asked. He had complained repeatedly to US officials about their soft approach to Pakistan, he said, but with no result. “I tell them that they can’t recognize their enemies and their friends.”
“Pakistan is not the only problem,” I said. “The Taliban is growing stronger because Afghans are turning to them out of disgust with the government.”

“People support the Taliban because they are afraid of them,” Mojaddedi said. “If [people] don’t agree with them, they kill them.” The dislike of the Karzai government had been caused by Karzai himself, he said, who put his family and friends into important posts. Karzai’s people were interested not in a better Afghanistan but only in themselves. The climate of corruption was rooted in war. “The character and morals have been changed due to the war,” he said. “It’s the main reason for the corruption here.” Solving the problem was simple. “The people who are corrupt must be punished, and those who are good must be rewarded,” he said. But to do that, “we need a strong government,” he continued. Such a government would not exist with Karzai at the helm, he said.

Excerpted from Above the Din of War: Afghans Speak About their Lives, their Country, and their Future—and Why America Should Listen by Peter Eichstaedt, with permission from Lawrence Hill Books, an imprint of Chicago Review Press. Published April, 2013.

Click here for reuse options!
Copyright 2013 The National Memo
  • republiCONsanddemsarebothsuck

    We need to drop afganistan like a bad habit. It should be done just as someone would quit smoking.

    We should pull out completely now and let the UN deal with them.

    Just like our lazy president should have done with guantanamo.

    • Sand_Cat

      Not too defend him too much, but Congress made it so he would have had to do something like threatening (and following through, if necessary) to just turn the inmates loose to close Guantanamo. Maybe that is what he should have done, but he is far too conservative to have even considered that.

  • charleo1

    Well, at the end of the day, Afghanistan is going to be another place on the
    map, where we expended our blood, and treasure. And, determine we gave far
    too much of both, when we see the final outcome. Two thousand, two hundred,
    dead, so far. Two thousand, two hundred, of our best. Who were Sons, and
    Daughters, Brothers, and Sisters, Mothers, and Fathers, to families forever
    changed. Forever less, than they might have been. I think we must ask, what
    would this, 10th century, tribal, illiterate, deeply socially flawed, by our standards,
    Country, need to look like? Before we could say, that, yes, far too many, some,
    impossibly young, and all, irreplaceable. Did, inevitably lose their lives. But, in
    the end, all the good, and righteousness, and suffering relieved, that flowed
    their sacrifice, made their loss, at least bearable. In the knowing, the world is a better
    place, because of them. I don’t think we are ever going to be able to say that,
    of Afghanistan. And, since it is not in our power to ever give these lives back to their rightful owners. The question then becomes, for us the living, how do we best honor
    the fallen, in what was no doubt, a valiant, effort. But, in the end, proved to
    fall, far too short of the goal, to justify the cost? The first thing we can do, and must
    do, is take care of the injured, both physically, and mentally. We owe (more than 17,000 of them,) a debt of gratitude. And, we owe them the best care money can buy. And we need to do a much better job of it, than we have been. We must, eliminate
    once, and for all of these heros, the waiting lists for care, that can span months.
    And the distances, many of our wounded must travel, to access that care. We should see both, as a breech of trust, an immorality, and a source of National shame, these two circumstances, were ever allowed to exist in the first place. If we could ask those
    who will never return to their families. Those, who out of love for the solider next to them. Who, without question, entrusted their lives. And in that terrible second, exchanged that life, for his Brother’s. We need to honor that sacrifice, by making his Brothers as whole as we can possibly make them. And stand with them, as they rebuild their lives, that the wars we sent them to, tore apart. It’s what’s left for us to do, about Afghanistan.