What’s The Matter With White People?
September 21st, 2012 6:13 pm Joan Walsh
Excerpted with permission from the publisher, Wiley, from What’s the Matter with White People: Why We Long for a Golden Age That Never Was by Joan Walsh. Copyright © 2012
Empathy for one party is always prejudice against another.
—Senator Jeff Sessions, July 2009
I am repeatedly struck by the extent to which conservatives have given up on the America we all grew up with: apparently it costs too much and we can’t afford it, and besides, we can’t all get along, so we can’t enjoy it.
In 2011 New York Times columnist Ross Douthat warned Americans that we can no longer provide a strong social welfare state—the kind of society that supports people the way we did from the mid-1930s until the end of the 1970s—because we’re too diverse for it. As Douthat argued:
Historically, the most successful welfare states (think Scandinavia) have depended on ethnic solidarity to sustain their tax-and-transfer programs. But the working age America of the future will be far more diverse than the retired cohort it’s laboring to support. Asking a population that’s increasingly brown and beige to accept punishing tax rates while white seniors receive roughly $3 in Medicare benefits for every dollar they paid in (the projected ratio in the 2030s) promises to polarize the country along racial as well as generational lines.
Douthat seemed to fear that the “brown and beige” kids who’ll be paying into Social Security and Medicare for the next generation might not look kindly on supporting a population that’s disproportionately white. So we may as well unravel our social insurance programs before those tawny kids pull the plug on Grandma? How cynical, how sad.
It’s brazen of anyone on the right to warn us that government programs might polarize the country along racial lines, as though we are not already polarized, at least partly because of GOP divide-and-conquer politics. Yet the relationship between American diversity and trust in government is actually an old controversy, with Douthat adding a twenty-first-century right-wing spin. Scholars have long debated whether Americans have a weaker public sector because of our heterogeneity. Some argue that we have less social support and more harried lives than people in comparable nations, at least partly because we don’t want to take the chance that increased social spending and a broader safety net will help “other people,” those slackers and moochers we’ve always feared.
In fact, the United States lags behind all industrialized nations when it comes to direct government funding of health care, family leave, child care, and unemployment benefits. In an influential 2004 book, Fighting Poverty in the U.S. and Europe: A World of Difference, Harvard economists Alberto Alesina and Edward Glaeser attributed most of the gap in social spending between western Europe and the United States to our unrivaled mix of racial and ethnic groups and the distrust that engendered.
Now, when you add in American social spending on public education, which used to be the highest in the world, as well as employer-provided social supports subsidized by government with tax breaks—health insurance and 401(k)s, to name two big examples—the U.S. welfare state isn’t necessarily smaller than that of a lot of industrialized nations. But it’s a heavily privatized welfare state, and that strange hybrid has a lot to do with our racially and ethnically polarized political history. Yet even that hybrid is now being threatened as employers insist they can’t afford to keep the promises made in an earlier generation. As businesses shed the benefits that used to help keep American workers in the middle class, they imply that those workers are greedy to expect them. They’re slackers. Moochers. Privatized-welfare queens.
There is also a fascinating correlation relationship between societies that provide universal government programs—such as Social Security and Medicare, as opposed to food stamps and Medicaid and cash grants only for the “poor”—and societies with high levels of social trust. Which comes first, the trust to provide universal government programs, or government programs that foster a sense of unity and trust? As the right loses faith in the America we grew up with, it gives the rest of us an opportunity and a clear responsibility. Douthat seems to be saying we can’t have a real social compact in a multiracial society; it works only in monochromatic societies. I think it would be the ultimate example of American exceptionalism to prove him (as well as Pat Buchanan and Charles Murray) wrong. We have to be the ones who develop a version of the American Dream that works for everyone.
And yes, that includes the white working class.
Continue Reading >> 1 2
-
bcarreiro
-
carsrus
-
http://profile.yahoo.com/IUDTH2HAONNJJGJEPQFHD42JXQ oacic123
-
sisterH
-
sisterH
-
http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=1121705556 Bruce Michael Barrett
-
http://www.facebook.com/dominick.vila.1 Dominick Vila
-
http://www.facebook.com/fern.woodfork Fern Woodfork
-
dham69
-
http://www.facebook.com/fern.woodfork Fern Woodfork
-
dham69
-
http://www.facebook.com/people/Charlie-Watkins/100001075495857 Charlie Watkins
-
dham69
-
Dazednconfused1
-
http://www.facebook.com/dominick.vila.1 Dominick Vila
-
http://www.facebook.com/joel.sorenson.9 Joel Sorenson
-
SaneJane
-
SaneJane
-
http://www.facebook.com/fern.woodfork Fern Woodfork
-
adler56
-
mpjt16
-
http://profile.yahoo.com/U2AQMOLGWOSKQ7HM7VI57FCD7I Ron
-
http://openid.aol.com/lonefox368 lonefox368
-
http://www.facebook.com/dominick.vila.1 Dominick Vila
-
http://www.facebook.com/fern.woodfork Fern Woodfork
-
dham69
-
SaneJane
-
dham69
-
http://www.facebook.com/fern.woodfork Fern Woodfork
-
http://profile.yahoo.com/HGC4BGWVYXV76PHZBPSPOOU5GA Independent1
-
dham69
-
http://www.facebook.com/iraajackson Ira Jackson
-
dham69
-
http://www.facebook.com/joel.sorenson.9 Joel Sorenson
-
kimbo55
-
http://www.facebook.com/fern.woodfork Fern Woodfork
-
http://profile.yahoo.com/47UD7UZ7UQ5IK3EO3BBZAS63IM Eduardo
-
ALLLLAMERICAN
-
JSquercia
-
http://www.facebook.com/fern.woodfork Fern Woodfork
-
ajjohnson31
-
http://www.facebook.com/dominick.vila.1 Dominick Vila
-
truesoy
-
http://www.facebook.com/fern.woodfork Fern Woodfork
-
truesoy
-
http://www.facebook.com/people/Charlie-Watkins/100001075495857 Charlie Watkins
-
http://www.facebook.com/fern.woodfork Fern Woodfork
-
Pesos
-
http://www.facebook.com/fern.woodfork Fern Woodfork
-
dham69
-
Pesos
-
http://www.facebook.com/fern.woodfork Fern Woodfork
-
http://www.facebook.com/people/Charlie-Watkins/100001075495857 Charlie Watkins
-
http://www.facebook.com/fern.woodfork Fern Woodfork
-
dham69
-
http://profile.yahoo.com/HGC4BGWVYXV76PHZBPSPOOU5GA Independent1
-
dham69
-
Julio Macias
-
dham69
-
http://twitter.com/msbrodie JB
-
http://www.facebook.com/fern.woodfork Fern Woodfork
-
http://www.facebook.com/people/Vernon-Sukumu/100000963359102 Vernon Sukumu
-
http://www.facebook.com/fern.woodfork Fern Woodfork
-
http://www.facebook.com/iraajackson Ira Jackson
-
http://www.facebook.com/fern.woodfork Fern Woodfork
-
kimbo55
-
1concernedsenior
-
dham69
-
http://profile.yahoo.com/YS2TEKIDWOLQH6FLUOQCFTLZSE Robert
-
http://www.facebook.com/fern.woodfork Fern Woodfork
-
http://profile.yahoo.com/QYH6TCIO6NZDB3SOU6DJT5NVI4 tbone
-
dham69
-
http://www.facebook.com/fern.woodfork Fern Woodfork
-
http://www.facebook.com/fern.woodfork Fern Woodfork
-
dham69
-
http://www.facebook.com/fern.woodfork Fern Woodfork
-
dham69
-
http://www.facebook.com/fern.woodfork Fern Woodfork
-
dham69
-
prowler789
-
http://www.facebook.com/fern.woodfork Fern Woodfork
-
http://www.facebook.com/dominick.vila.1 Dominick Vila
-
http://www.facebook.com/fern.woodfork Fern Woodfork
-
http://profile.yahoo.com/ZH7P6S3S2R2CKCLYATIEHKNTMA jaw
-
http://profile.yahoo.com/6BHV2CML6W4VKEPM5EHF4NJETQ donald c
-
Teddy Parker
-
dham69
-
http://www.facebook.com/dominick.vila.1 Dominick Vila
-
dham69
-
http://www.facebook.com/people/Charlie-Watkins/100001075495857 Charlie Watkins
-
dham69
-
http://www.facebook.com/dominick.vila.1 Dominick Vila
-
dham69
-
http://www.facebook.com/dominick.vila.1 Dominick Vila
-
dham69
-
http://www.facebook.com/people/Charlie-Watkins/100001075495857 Charlie Watkins
-
dham69
-
http://www.facebook.com/people/Charlie-Watkins/100001075495857 Charlie Watkins
-
http://www.facebook.com/fern.woodfork Fern Woodfork
-
dham69
-
113121
-
CarolO
-
http://profile.yahoo.com/VZIHVXZSOR4LBQND2HPA3PPKUY Howard
-
http://www.facebook.com/dominick.vila.1 Dominick Vila
-
http://www.facebook.com/people/Charlie-Watkins/100001075495857 Charlie Watkins
-
http://pulse.yahoo.com/_32DMSNBPIOL3D6TBCUXRML6YLA Jim
-
OakenTruncheon
-
http://profile.yahoo.com/YBYYIQHBLD7BZAU6L3DC7MS4YM Rodney
-
OakenTruncheon
-
busterbull
-
http://www.facebook.com/dominick.vila.1 Dominick Vila
-
crestdad
-
http://www.facebook.com/dominick.vila.1 Dominick Vila
-
http://pulse.yahoo.com/_7DKWSXHQIDBW5PUAPZ2HZAYYUY Baron Cormac
-
Robert Lewis
-
brotherscoe
-
http://www.facebook.com/cjakobsson2 Carl Jakobsson
-
http://twitter.com/TweetsforFrida tweetsforFrida
-
LisaC134
-
http://profile.yahoo.com/OKL3SFOJ62BEVG6TXV5R3QG2OM lee
-
http://www.facebook.com/people/Gary-Godfrey/100000665142650 Gary Godfrey
-
Barry Feist
-
http://profile.yahoo.com/LOUNG4GGSP7C55J2OFYXVTO6NI james
-
ethelene3
-
http://www.facebook.com/people/Christopher-P-Doyle/1517044469 Christopher P Doyle
-
http://www.facebook.com/dominick.vila.1 Dominick Vila
-
http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=1191843392 Jenny K. Hernandez
-
http://www.facebook.com/dominick.vila.1 Dominick Vila
-
http://profile.yahoo.com/F7CDQG555EPVRQFVX5KBEW33XM Bill
-
http://www.facebook.com/dominick.vila.1 Dominick Vila
-
http://profile.yahoo.com/DPY5ADXTDUGABOL7TPUJQEP5YE JOAQUIM
-
http://pulse.yahoo.com/_KOPKDFAUQPIIRAFI3HEXNMSHLQ Ed
-
http://www.facebook.com/dominick.vila.1 Dominick Vila
-
http://profile.yahoo.com/5VIB5WOIUAEUIQHU5BLO5D4WGU elan
-
http://profile.yahoo.com/LOUNG4GGSP7C55J2OFYXVTO6NI james
-
http://pulse.yahoo.com/_7DKWSXHQIDBW5PUAPZ2HZAYYUY Baron Cormac
-
http://twitter.com/Muzixcal1 Rebecca Long
-
DurdyDawg
-
13observer
-
http://profile.yahoo.com/LOUNG4GGSP7C55J2OFYXVTO6NI james
-
mrbluesays
-
http://www.facebook.com/fern.woodfork Fern Woodfork
-
mrbluesays
-
http://www.facebook.com/fern.woodfork Fern Woodfork
-
mrbluesays
-
http://www.facebook.com/fern.woodfork Fern Woodfork
-
mrbluesays
-
http://www.facebook.com/fern.woodfork Fern Woodfork
-
mrbluesays
-
grammyjill
-
montanabill
-
http://www.facebook.com/fern.woodfork Fern Woodfork
-
montanabill
-
http://profile.yahoo.com/OIWHIIHWEWBKKLVU4FQS3XQQKE Todd
-
http://profile.yahoo.com/LOUNG4GGSP7C55J2OFYXVTO6NI james
-
ajjohnson31
-
http://profile.yahoo.com/WOKWYTTCSA4OS3DBN53UGTN7CE michaels
-
http://twitter.com/jmaciasrios Julio M
-
http://www.facebook.com/people/Tyler-Durdan/100001577516366 Tyler Durdan
-
pbrower2a
-
excavatoreddie
-
ethelene3
-
Migwaumps
-
http://profile.yahoo.com/2MV4YFXTDIRFFICEOMUKUL4ZCA EVERSTEIN
-
adler56
-
SaneJane
-
Jim Lou
-
http://www.facebook.com/fern.woodfork Fern Woodfork
-
SaneJane
-
Dazednconfused1
-
http://www.facebook.com/fern.woodfork Fern Woodfork
-
http://profile.yahoo.com/XF2GSLWKUXTWLRQENEKUKLHI7A Flower
-
http://www.facebook.com/fern.woodfork Fern Woodfork
-
http://www.facebook.com/people/Charlie-Watkins/100001075495857 Charlie Watkins
-
mpjt16
-
Dazednconfused1
-
SaneJane
-
dscf44
-
Ed Mays
-
http://profile.yahoo.com/X2KKGDYW2F5T5XUT6233KBNWSI robert
-
http://twitter.com/faireem Faith M Martin
-
http://profile.yahoo.com/U2AQMOLGWOSKQ7HM7VI57FCD7I Ron
-
http://pulse.yahoo.com/_AOZVISW3XL7243YWES5SXAXXZA Kent
-
msrita
-
carsrus
-
http://profile.yahoo.com/X2KKGDYW2F5T5XUT6233KBNWSI robert
-
deniswinkle1
-
http://twitter.com/roseburton13 Rose Burton
-
CarolO
-
TheOldNorthChurch
-
http://www.facebook.com/people/Charlie-Watkins/100001075495857 Charlie Watkins
-
TheOldNorthChurch
-
Nick559
-
dham69
-
http://profile.yahoo.com/X2KKGDYW2F5T5XUT6233KBNWSI robert
-
dham69
-
http://pulse.yahoo.com/_3QBYCB6SQDS5ECF4RVFFCGQK5E erwind
-
http://www.facebook.com/fern.woodfork Fern Woodfork
-
http://profile.yahoo.com/YZ4ZDOGFXIEYPVLFK4YGWJKKWA Clever Bob
-
http://www.facebook.com/fern.woodfork Fern Woodfork
-
dljones
-
http://profile.yahoo.com/X2KKGDYW2F5T5XUT6233KBNWSI robert
-
EARTHMAN1
-
Gammaanya
-
mrbluesays
-
mrbluesays
-
http://pulse.yahoo.com/_PAUIKIQNIDB7IU5R6PHBXSQURY Mr. Bombastic
-
http://profile.yahoo.com/A5KDOJUGJFPL5QBDE73HRHMRUE Gregory
-
http://profile.yahoo.com/A5KDOJUGJFPL5QBDE73HRHMRUE Gregory
-
donbronkema1
-
http://profile.yahoo.com/HUAPJTKZ6USWUKL6TK535ACUPA James Curran
-
http://www.facebook.com/people/Charles-Martin/100002494473545 Charles Martin
-
kimbo55
-
http://www.facebook.com/people/Charles-Martin/100002494473545 Charles Martin
-
dsand1445
-
http://profile.yahoo.com/GIWK37ZXBVSGIL72YNILXJL4E4 Paku
-
dham69
-
http://www.facebook.com/people/Charlie-Watkins/100001075495857 Charlie Watkins
-
dham69
-
1concernedsenior
-
1concernedsenior
-
1concernedsenior
-
http://profile.yahoo.com/YS2TEKIDWOLQH6FLUOQCFTLZSE Robert
-
1concernedsenior
-
http://www.facebook.com/joel.sorenson.9 Joel Sorenson
-
1concernedsenior
-
mrbluesays
-
http://www.facebook.com/joel.sorenson.9 Joel Sorenson
-
http://www.facebook.com/joel.sorenson.9 Joel Sorenson
-
Elsa
-
http://www.facebook.com/joel.sorenson.9 Joel Sorenson
-
http://pulse.yahoo.com/_EIKF46FCKSAG2AGCEMEMQTBS4M BosFanInChgo
-
http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=1481587338 Anne E Herrera
-
http://pulse.yahoo.com/_QDRNW4QSTFDEMQELYX7VRTRORI slightlycrazy
-
busterbull
-
http://profile.yahoo.com/QOEP6232OJ7PIZCAZ7NLSS64EQ Pat Jackson
-
http://www.facebook.com/robert.robertson.sr Robert P. Robertson
-
timeforchange321
-
busterbull
-
http://www.facebook.com/people/Christopher-P-Doyle/1517044469 Christopher P Doyle
-
http://www.facebook.com/people/Christopher-P-Doyle/1517044469 Christopher P Doyle
-
carsrus
-
http://www.facebook.com/robert.robertson.sr Robert P. Robertson
-
http://profile.yahoo.com/DPY5ADXTDUGABOL7TPUJQEP5YE JOAQUIM
-
http://profile.yahoo.com/DPY5ADXTDUGABOL7TPUJQEP5YE JOAQUIM
-
http://www.facebook.com/people/Walter-Gregory/1390006447 Walter Gregory
-
LynnaD
-
http://profile.yahoo.com/A5KDOJUGJFPL5QBDE73HRHMRUE Gregory
-
http://profile.yahoo.com/IIAFAK62EMBFOLOX76RKHIW7TA Gilbert
-
http://www.facebook.com/cjakobsson2 Carl Jakobsson
-
http://www.facebook.com/george.saufley George Saufley
-
LynnaD
-
http://profile.yahoo.com/ZHFTB6X3AZPE4ZKUA5ZP4BGWSM A j CARIAGA jr
-
http://profile.yahoo.com/ZHFTB6X3AZPE4ZKUA5ZP4BGWSM A j CARIAGA jr
-
ALLLLAMERICAN
-
sisterH
-
Jim_n_Panama
-
http://www.facebook.com/george.saufley George Saufley
-
LynnaD
-
http://pulse.yahoo.com/_OLT3BBICDAFJXQAHHKXXLJUCH4 Stella53
-
http://profile.yahoo.com/WAYM6CPMQ3M6RRKE6TA2MN2QYQ Rex H
-
http://profile.yahoo.com/HX4VKHONQHCTHTINNLJKDAWOWA Kathy G
-
http://www.facebook.com/people/Tyler-Durdan/100001577516366 Tyler Durdan
-
http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=100003094939104 Gia David
-
Jerpell
-
http://twitter.com/rpianome1st Robert Lewis
-
http://twitter.com/rpianome1st Robert Lewis
-
desertdustoff
-
ALLLLAMERICAN
-
ALLLLAMERICAN
-
http://pulse.yahoo.com/_OLT3BBICDAFJXQAHHKXXLJUCH4 Stella53
-
http://www.facebook.com/people/Ebenezer-Akrong/1335887677 Ebenezer Akrong
-
http://www.facebook.com/people/Andrew-Rei/100001727442607 Andrew Rei
-
LAX_Paperboy
-
http://profile.yahoo.com/YGBFV46MG3TNT2PNM4RKA65BJE Lasbrey
-
howa4x
-
IAMSuperPatriot
-
http://www.facebook.com/robert.benefiel.77 Robert Benefiel
-
Innisfail
-
jerrimyers
-
http://www.facebook.com/george.saufley George Saufley
-
http://profile.yahoo.com/TUAZKTGREJ77GMNERWVWOS6MG4 Jeff
-
ALLLLAMERICAN
-
BillAlphonso
-
http://profile.yahoo.com/OIWHIIHWEWBKKLVU4FQS3XQQKE Todd
-
ALLLLAMERICAN
-
http://profile.yahoo.com/2CQFBSDHGKRXXK6DQH3ONVSSMI rayvonne r
-
http://pulse.yahoo.com/_SJWNIRFK62TUVLD5Z2AUU7OO7E James
-
ALLLLAMERICAN
-
rustacus21
-
http://pulse.yahoo.com/_AU5ACNCEO3ROKB2JXGOXJMIZ5U hwhm
-
http://www.facebook.com/elvordfloyd.guidry Elvord Floyd Guidry
-
http://profile.yahoo.com/LOUNG4GGSP7C55J2OFYXVTO6NI james
-
http://profile.yahoo.com/LOUNG4GGSP7C55J2OFYXVTO6NI james
-
http://profile.yahoo.com/LOUNG4GGSP7C55J2OFYXVTO6NI james
-
http://profile.yahoo.com/LOUNG4GGSP7C55J2OFYXVTO6NI james
-
http://profile.yahoo.com/LOUNG4GGSP7C55J2OFYXVTO6NI james
-
ALLLLAMERICAN
-
ethelene3
-
http://profile.yahoo.com/HSWE7CFQJSUFDOYTNMZ2EBN4SE princess
-
http://twitter.com/rpianome1st Robert Lewis
-
http://twitter.com/Ekwesonmagnus magnus Ekweson
-
http://profile.yahoo.com/W5BDIK2NSZ3LKTIB277QIUFSCY John

