The National  Memo Logo

Smart. Sharp. Funny. Fearless.

Monday, December 09, 2019 {{ new Date().getDay() }}

By Eric D. Lawrence and Gina Damron, Detroit Free Press

DETROIT — The stepmother of 12-year-old Charlie Bothuell V — who was found alive in the basement of his Detroit home 11 days after he vanished — was taken into custody on a warrant issued for a probation violation, police said Thursday.

Meanwhile, police continue to investigate Charlie’s case, focusing on whether he was abused. Police said they have not ruled out the possibility of abuse.

Police have said evidence, including a PVC pipe, has been collected.

A person familiar with the investigation said the pipe was reportedly used to discipline the child. Blood was found on the child’s clothing in the house, but it is uncertain whose blood it is, the source said.

Police are working with the Wayne County prosecutor’s office and will be in touch with the Department of Human Services and other agencies.

Charlie is now staying with his mother and other relatives in Detroit.

His father and stepmother — Charlie Bothuell IV and Monique Dillard-Bothuell — have come under increased scrutiny since Charlie, missing since June 14, was found Wednesday in the basement of their home in the 1300 block of Nicolet Place while police executed a search warrant.

Maria Miller, a spokeswoman for Wayne County prosecutor Kym Worthy, said the office has not received a warrant request in Charlie’s case; police said a warrant request could be turned over within the next couple of days.

Dillard-Bothuell’s two children have been removed by Children’s Protective Services, Detroit police spokesman Michael Woody said.
She is on probation for a weapons offense, records show.

According to Wayne County Circuit Court records, Dillard-Bothuell was charged in 2013 with carrying a concealed weapon.

According to a police report, obtained by the Detroit Free Press, Dillard-Bothuell got a flat tire on I-75 on May 19, 2013. When a Michigan State Police trooper offered assistance, she provided him with her expired concealed pistol license, told him she was in possession of a pistol, and was arrested, the report says.

In January this year, she pleaded guilty to obtaining a pistol without a license, the charge of carrying a concealed weapon was dismissed and she was given two years’ probation, records show.

On the order of probation, it says Dillard-Bothuell “may not own, use or possess a firearm.”

On Monday, a bench warrant was issued for Dillard-Bothuell for violating her probation after a handgun was found in her home on Nicolet Place while police executed a search warrant.

According to court records, police recovered the gun while Dillard-Bothuell was present.

In yet another development Thursday, WXYZ-TV reported that Charlie’s stepmother is the niece of Detroit attorney and Michigan attorney general candidate Godfrey Dillard, who lives only a few doors away from the Bothuells. Dillard, a Democrat, did not return messages seeking comment.

Woody said the investigation is continuing.

Police found Charlie concealed by a makeshift barricade, crouched behind a large container, Detroit Police Chief James Craig said Wednesday. He said police had searched the home several times before the one conducted Wednesday.

Woody said Thursday that Charlie had been in another location during earlier searches of the house. Police would have discovered Charlie otherwise, he said. Woody described the area in which the boy was found as a small mechanical room. Police found the boy Wednesday behind a large container with some food, including cereal and pop bottles.

“It was somewhat staged but … you could tell he was there for a short while,” Woody said. “It wasn’t any grand, elaborate setup.”

Woody said that when he was found, Charlie was wearing the same clothes he’d had on when he disappeared. On Wednesday, Craig said Charlie was happy to see police.

Police said Charlie’s condition is good and he has been talking to them.

“He was in a hospital this morning. He is being closely monitored by us,” Woody said Thursday.

On Thursday, a woman leaving the mother’s house, where Charlie is now staying with his mother, said police told the family not to speak with reporters, but she said the boy is fine and with his family before she drove away.

Charles George, 63, a man walking in the neighborhood who identified himself as a family friend, said he spoke with family members on Charlie’s mother’s side Wednesday and they were simply praying the boy was OK.

“I met little Charlie when he was 5 or 6 years old. He was a good boy. I hate that he went through this,” said George.

The saga of a family searching for a missing child took an abrupt and bizarre turn Wednesday. Craig held a news conference to announce that police were not ruling out the possibility of homicide in the case followed hours later by news that the boy had been found alive.
As Craig was addressing the media, Charlie’s father learned the news from cable TV show host Nancy Grace on live television. He left the interview and rushed to his home, where he started sobbing and collapsed in the arms of WDIV-TV reporter Guy Gordon.

Bothuell was adamant that he did not know his son was in the basement and said “there was no abuse of my son.”

Mark Magidson, the attorney for Bothuell, said it “defies logic” that the many searches failed to uncover Charlie.

“If that child was down there, they would have found him,” Magidson said.

AFP Photo / Bill Pugliano

Interested in national news? Sign up for our daily email newsletter!


Start your day with National Memo Newsletter

Know first.

The opinions that matter. Delivered to your inbox every morning

Sen. Bernie Sanders, left, and President Joe Biden during 2020 presidential debate

I look at September 2019 as a month where I missed something. We began with a trip to New York to do Seth Meyers’s and Dr. Oz’s shows. Why would we go on The Dr. Oz Show? For the same reason we had gone on Joe Rogan’s podcast in August: We could reach a vast audience that wasn’t paying attention to the standard political media. On Dr. Oz, Bernie could talk about Medicare for All and his own physical fitness. While at the time we believed Bernie was uncommonly healthy for his age, he was still 78. Questions would be raised related to his age, and we needed to begin building up the case that he was completely healthy and fit. It turned out to be a spectacular interview, ending with the two of them playing basketball on a makeshift court in the studio. Bernie appeared to be on top of the world.

Yet in retrospect, I should have seen Bernie growing more fatigued. After New York, with the school year starting, we did a series of rallies at colleges and universities in Iowa; this was the kickoff of our campus organizing program in the state. We would then fly to Colorado for a large rally in Denver before heading to Boulder to prep for the third debate, to take place in Houston on September 12. In Iowa, Bernie’s voice was a little hoarse. After the rally in Denver, he had completely blown it out. He sounded terrible.

Keep reading... Show less

Rep. James Clyburn

When I interviewed House Majority Whip James Clyburn in 2014 about his memoir Blessed Experiences: Genuinely Southern, Proudly Black, the South Carolina Democrat was confident in America’s ability to find its way, no matter how extreme the political swings might appear at any given time.

“The country from its inception is like the pendulum on a clock,” the congressman told me. “It goes back and forward. It tops out to the right and starts back to the left — it tops out to the left and starts back to the right.” And remember, he said, it “spends twice as much time in the center.”

Keep reading... Show less
{{ }}