Type to search

Texas Pulls Funding From Air-Quality Program Over Released Data

McClatchy Tribune News Service National News

Texas Pulls Funding From Air-Quality Program Over Released Data


By Lisa Song, InsideClimate News

A few casual words and the early release of some scientific data have cost the San Antonio region much-needed state funds to battle its growing air pollution problem. The misstep, which appears to have been unintentional, highlights the sensitivity of studying oil and gas pollution in business-friendly Texas.

The dispute began after the Alamo Area Council of Governments (AACOG) — a coalition that oversees 13 counties in the San Antonio region — launched a two-part study to determine how oil and gas drilling was affecting the city’s air quality.

San Antonio’s air quality has been deteriorating since 2008, the same year drilling began in the nearby Eagle Ford Shale, site of one of the nation’s biggest energy booms. The air pollution is now so bad that metropolitan San Antonio could soon be declared in nonattainment with federal standards for ozone, the main component of smog. If that happens, it could be subject to sanctions from the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, including increased EPA oversight for new development projects.

Local officials hope to avoid that fate by curbing pollution through voluntary measures, but first they need to understand where the emissions are coming from. Because San Antonio is one of the fastest-growing cities in the nation, much of the ozone-forming chemicals are likely emitted by cars and trucks. But AACOG knew little about the contributions from oil and gas drilling.

AACOG released the first part of the study, an emission inventory of the Eagle Ford, on April 4. It projected a dramatic increase in air emissions by 2018 during peak ozone season, including a possible 281 percent increase in releases of volatile organic compounds, which react with nitrogen oxides to form ozone. More details are expected in the second part, a photochemical model that explains how the emissions affect San Antonio’s ozone levels.

About a week after the emission inventory was released, the Austin American-Statesman reported that the Texas Commission on Environmental Quality (TCEQ), which funded the study, had slashed AACOG’s air-quality planning budget by 25 percent because an AACOG employee had made some of the draft results public. AACOG’s contract with the TCEQ prohibited AACOG from releasing any results without TCEQ approval.

TCEQ spokesman Terry Clawson said the contract was breached when AACOG posted a “summary presentation” on its website. He declined to identify the person responsible for the posting, and said AACOG management was notified of the consequences soon after TCEQ decided to cut the agency’s budget.

InsideClimate News and the Center for Public Integrity have been reporting on air quality problems in the Eagle Ford for the past year. The initial group of stories stemming from the investigation, published in February, showed that state regulators and politicians are more focused on protecting the industry than protecting the public.

“This is among the more petulant, childish and vindictive things I’ve seen TCEQ do,” said Al Armendariz, a former EPA regional administrator who now works for the Beyond Coal campaign at the Texas chapter of the Sierra Club. “It’s cheap, it’s schoolyard bullying … to go after a local government whose sole mission is to protect public health.”

In an interview last week on Texas Public Radio, AACOG chairman Kevin Wolff acknowledged that an AACOG employee had made a “fairly minor mistake,” but said he didn’t think the TCEQ’s reaction was very logical. Wolf told the radio show his agency would try to pool some city and county resources to replace the lost funds.

Peter Bella, AACOG’s natural resources director who has worked at the agency for 15 years, has concluded that he is the person the TCEQ is referring to. Bella said he summarized preliminary results from the study last July at a meeting attended by companies that operate in the Eagle Ford, who provided much of the data used in the emission inventory.

After the meeting, Bella posted the summary presentation on AACOG’s website. He said the agency routinely posts documents presented at its meetings, and he never thought it would be considered a breach of contract. Bella said the presentation was well-received by the industry representatives.

A scientist by training, Bella has an undergraduate degree in physics and a master’s in math. Emails between his team at AACOG and TCEQ’s technical staff, obtained through a Texas Public Records Act request, show polite, scientific discussions about the emission inventory over the past 18 months. There’s nothing to indicate animosity.

The draft results actually predicted fewer emissions than the report released this month. The draft projected that by 2018, Eagle Ford development would produce 198 tons per day of volatile organic compounds during San Antonio’s peak ozone season. The final report predicted almost three times as much, 544 tons per day.

Six days after the July meeting, Bella presented the same data to AACOG’s technical staff. The TCEQ was invited to attend the meeting, but no one from the agency showed up. Bella said he was never told — by either the TCEQ or AACOG upper management — that he had done anything wrong.

“I thought the state environmental agency would be happy I was making progress and bringing data forward,” he said. “Part of the difficulty is that I have yet to receive a true indication of the true nature of the breach.”


You Might also Like


  1. docb April 25, 2014

    Let us see..No expansion of Medicaid and no ‘exchange’ for the people creates 1.4 Million subject to the Perry Abbott DEATH PANELS!!!!

    The claim job creation when they are Military and minimum wage jobs..Perry Abbott have shutdown Women’s clinics all across the state! Abbott and Perry are attempting to pull a LAND GRAB along the Rio Grande…You have a inhumane pair of ugly nasty repub bags causing air pollution from Corporate Welfare recipients to continue to pollute! Do not forget the lack of State Inspections of the fertilizer plant that exploded in West, Tx! That is on the heads of Abbott -Perry and the repub bags, too!

    No surprise here..Abbott and Perry are the scourge of the earth…

    1. Independent1 April 27, 2014

      Last year Texas was awarded the prestigious “State with the Most Polluted Environment in America” Award. I’m sure what’s going on around San Antonio these days will guarantee Texas a lock on that award for years to come.

      1. docb April 27, 2014

        Wow, had not heard that. Have you a cite?

        1. Independent1 April 27, 2014

          Doc, I was dramatizing that up a bit. I’m sure the state doesn’t consider the designation as being “prestigious”.

          I came across the designation of that in one of the many articles I have recorded which gave the findings of a government backed study that had determined that Texas had the most polluted overall environment in the nation because of all the oil and toxic substances that are spilled there during the many fossil fuel drilling operations which pollute the state’s terrain; and by all the coal fired power plants that spew toxic fumes and the extensive oil/gas drilling operatons in the state that add to the pollution of it’s air (as is documented by the above article)

          And then you have this article that came out just yesterday about a Texas family winning a lawsuit against 3M due to the damage fracking operations in Texas have had on their health:

          Texas family plagued with ailments gets $3M in 1st-of-its-kind fracking judgment


          Not only that, but another article I have found that Texas has the worst healthcare delivery system in the nation. So not only does Texas have the most people without health insurance, even for those who have it, Texas overall has the worst system of allowing its citizens that do have insurance to get it. The last I read is that the wait time to see a new docter was around 72 days – possibly the longest in the nation.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.