The National  Memo Logo

Smart. Sharp. Funny. Fearless.

Monday, December 09, 2019 {{ new Date().getDay() }}

In reality, President Obama’s policies have grown government spending at a lower rate than any president since Dwight Eisenhower. In Republican reality, Obama has exploded government spending in a way that makes even George W. Bush seem miserly.

The only way Republican reality makes sense is if they can convince Americans to do one thing: Completely forget what happened in September of 2008.

Then make ALL-CAPS accusations like this:

The linked story compares fiscal year 2008 — which conveniently ended on September 30, 2008 — to fiscal year 2012. That’s a comparison you would make if you were obsessed with absolving George W. Bush and blaming Barack Obama for the explosion in government spending.

What happened in September, 2008?

Well, September, 2008 is the month when Lehman Brothers declared bankruptcy and the financial crisis began its slow-motion demolition of trillions in American wealth and millions of American jobs.

Then on September 30, 2008:

Then, on October 3, 2008, Bush signed the first part of TARP, which authorized hundreds of billions more in emergency spending.

In early January of 2009, before President Obama took office, the Congressional Budget Office suggested the 2009 deficit would be $1.2 trillion. It ended up being closer to $1.4 trillion.

How much of 2009 federal spending is Obama responsible for? Experts estimate that Obama was responsible for $140 billion to $203 billion of 2009 government spending.

So Bush was responsible for about $3.3 trillion of the $3.52 the U.S. spent. Adjusted for inflation — as the right-wing site that DrudgeReport linked to, CNS News, did to make its ridiculous charges against Obama — Bush’s share of the 2009 budget is about $3.56 trillion. In 2012, the government spent $3.54 trillion. It’s a slight decline, but a decline nonetheless.

What is much more significant is the rapid decline of the deficit, as depicted by this graph from MaddowBlog‘s Steve Benen:

The deficit in Bush’s last fiscal year was $1.4 trillion. The deficit for President Obama’s fourth fiscal year as president will be around $800 billion.

The president hasn’t cut the deficit in half as he promised — but he’s come very close. In fact, the deficit has never fallen this quickly without triggering a recession.

The entire GOP argument for rapid austerity hinges on the American public believing that there has a been an “orgy” — nay, an “inferno!” — of spending under President Obama, when the opposite is true. He’s managed to reverse the policies of the Bush era and shrink the deficit by keeping the private sector creating jobs despite huge cuts to the public sector.

While 76 percent of Americans polled agree with President Obama that any deficit reduction must include both spending cuts and tax increases, only 6 percent are aware that the budget deficit is getting smaller.

How do you convince a wounded economy to slash itself with unnecessary budget cuts as millions look for work? Pretend the deficit is exploding when it’s actually shrinking. And for now, that strategy is working.


Start your day with National Memo Newsletter

Know first.

The opinions that matter. Delivered to your inbox every morning

Donald Trump
Youtube Screenshot

Allies of former President Donald Trump have advised members of the Republican Party to cool down their inflammatory rhetoric toward the United States Department of Justice and the Federal Bureau of Investigation following the execution of a search warrant at Trump's Mar-a-Lago estate in Palm Beach, Florida on Monday.

Trump supporters, right-wing pundits, and lawmakers have been whipped into a frenzy over what Trump called a "raid" by federal agents in pursuit of classified documents removed from the White House during Trump's departure from office.

Keep reading... Show less

Former President Donald Trump

Youtube Screenshot

On August 20, 2022, Donald Trump will have been gone from the White House for 19 months. But Trump, unlike other former presidents, hasn’t disappeared from the headlines by any means — and on Monday, August 8, the most prominent topic on cable news was the FBI executing a search warrant at Trump’s Mar-a-Lago home in South Florida. Countless Republicans, from Fox News hosts to Trump himself, have been furiously railing against the FBI and the U.S. Department of Justice (DOJ). And in an article published by Politico on August 11, reporters Kyle Cheney and Meridith McGraw describe the atmosphere of “paranoia” and suspicion that has become even worse in Trumpworld since the search.

“A wave of concern and even paranoia is gripping parts of Trumpworld as federal investigators tighten their grip on the former president and his inner circle,” Cheney and McGraw explain. “In the wake of news that the FBI agents executed a court-authorized search warrant at Donald Trump’s Mar-a-Lago residence in Florida, Trump’s allies and aides have begun buzzing about a host of potential explanations and worries. Among those being bandied about is that the search was a pretext to fish for other incriminating evidence, that the FBI doctored evidence to support its search warrant — and then planted some incriminating materials and recording devices at Mar-a-Lago for good measure — and even that the timing of the search was meant to be a historical echo of the day President Richard Nixon resigned in 1974.”

Keep reading... Show less
{{ }}