• Home
  • Congress
  • Headlines
  • Law
  • Newsletter
  • Ukraine
  • White House
  • Campaign 2020
  • Race and Ethnicity
  • Far Right
  • Media
  • Cartoons
  • Budget
  • Poverty
  • Endorse This
  • Agriculture
  • Trade
  • Impeachment
  • National Security & Intelligence
  • Top News
  • Military
  • Healthcare
  • Poll
  • China
  • Health
  • Border
  • Immigration
  • Law Enforcement
  • Democrats
  • Politics
  • Medicine
  • Republicans
  • Aviation
  • Conspiracy Theories
  • Entertainment
  • Investigations
  • Russia
  • Iran
  • Ethics
  • Courts
  • Elections
  • Gender
  • Inequality
  • Taxes
  • Voting Rights
  • Corruption
  • Social Media
  • Economy
  • Infrastructure
  • Authoritarianism
  • Books
  • Culture
  • Government
  • History
  • Uncategorized
  • Campaign 2016
  • Editor's Blog
  • Anti-Semitism
  • Social Security
  • Constitution
  • Veterans
  • Climate Change
  • Diplomacy
  • Business
  • Labor
  • Middle East
  • War
  • Civil Rights & Liberties
  • Religion
  • Energy
  • Education
  • Crime
  • World
  • Human Rights
  • Animals
  • Environment
  • Sports
  • Wealth
  • LGBT+
  • Supreme Court
  • Campaign 2018
  • Technology
  • Children
  • National News
  • Memo Pad
  • Morning LOL
  • LOL Of The Week
  • Bloomberg View
  • Guest Post
  • Carville-Greenberg
  • Memo Share
  • Press Releases
  • Weekend Reader
  • Newsmaker Memo
  • Countdown To Shutdown
  • Sorry -- Wrong Number
  • McClatchy Tribune News Service
  • Slideshow
  • Tribune News Service
  • Travel
  • Late Night Round-Up
  • This Week In Crazy
  • Money
  • Lifestyle
  • Technology
  • #NationalMeme
  • Science
  • Food
  • Reuters
  • Europe
  • Africa
  • US
  • Asia
  • Latin America
  • Entertainment and Lifestyle
  • Canada
  • Central America
  • UK
  • Letters
  • Oddly Enough
  • Australia
  • Tribune Content Agency
  • Mexico
  • Deals
  • Narcotics
  • Disasters
  • Guns
  • Transportation
  • National Security
  • Reproductive Rights
  • Nat Security/Intelligence
  • Youth
  • Disability
  • Lobbying and Influence
  • Lobbying
  • Finance
  • Terrorism
  • Consumers
  • Aging
  • Privatization
  • Criminal Justice
  • Activism
  • Housing
  • UN
  • Women
  • Refugees
  • Students
  • Cities
  • Afganistan
  • Supreme Court Nominations
  • Nonprofit
  • Ideas
  • Employment
  • Scandals
  • Gay Rights
  • Income Inequality
  • Native Americans
  • Drugs
  • Weather
  • Judiciary
  • Socialism
  • Urban Development
  • Venezuela
  • Family
  • House Judiciary Committee
  • North Korea
  • Anti-Trust
  • Cannabis
  • Census
  • Colleges & Universities
  • Human Trafficking
  • Water
  • Manufacturing
  • Nuclear
  • Brexit
  • Most Read
  • Trending
  • Mexico
  • Corporate Power
  • Israel/Palestine
  • Seniors
  • Independent Voters
  • Yemen
  • Holiday
  • Population
  • Science
  • Privacy
  • Space
  • Donald Trump
  • Afghanistan
  • Sexuality
  • Syria
  • Propaganda
  • Iraq
  • Prisons
  • Pandemics
  • Sponsored
  • Arts
  • Statistics
  • Rural
  • Protest
  • Jobs
  • Marijuana
  • Featured
  • law
  • unemployment
  • Transition 2021
  • campaign 2022
  • Campaign 2024
  • LGBTQ
  • Civil Rights
  • Mental Health
  • Immigrants
  • Campaign 2021
  • Families
  • Campaign Finance
  • Disabled
  • Wealthy
  • Cults
  • Social Democracy
  • Espionage
  • Scams
  • Di
  • Log in

Start your day with The National Memo Newsletter

The National  Memo Logo

Smart. Sharp. Funny. Fearless.

Monday, December 09, 2019

Home
PoliticsNational NewsWorldEconomyLifestyleStore
AboutContact
Type to search
The stories you want. The opinions that matter.

Sign up for our Daily Newsletter and never miss a story.

No, thanks

Trump Voter Fraud Commission Is Sued — By One Of Its Own Commissioners

Jessica Huseman
@JessicaHuseman
November 10 | 2017

Reprinted with permission from ProPublica.

 

Update, Nov. 9, 2017: Responses from Kris Kobach and Andrew Kossack, co-chair and executive director, respectively, of the voter fraud commission, have been added.

A Democratic member of the Presidential Advisory Commission on Election Integrity filed suit against the commission in federal court in Washington, D.C. on Thursday morning, alleging that its Republican leadership has intentionally excluded him from deliberations and violated federal transparency laws. The commission has been sued more times (eight, including the new filing) than it has officially convened for meetings (two times).

The suit, filed by Maine Secretary of State Matthew Dunlap, accuses the commission of violating the Federal Advisory Commission Act, which, among other things, requires that advisory committees be bipartisan and sets transparency requirements for them. “Everything we are doing is absolutely perpendicular to that,” Dunlap charged in an interview. “We aren’t inviting the public to participate. We aren’t transparent. And we aren’t even working together at all. My real fear is that this commission will offer policy recommendations that have not been properly vetted by all of the commissioners.”

The complaint contends Dunlap “has been, and continues to be, blocked from receiving Commission documents necessary to carry out his responsibilities” despite repeated requests to be included. It asserts that Dunlap is moving forward with the lawsuit “reluctantly” in order to prevent the commission from “becoming exactly the kind of one-sided, partisan undertaking the Federal Advisory Committee Act was designed to prohibit.”

The commission shouldn’t be surprised by the suit, said Austin Evers, executive director of American Oversight, an advocacy group that is representing Dunlap in the suit. Dunlap has written to the commission multiple times, asking them to address his grievances. “We think the commission is on more than enough notice they are not living up to their obligations,” Evers said, adding that he hopes to avoid a protracted legal battle.

In a statement, a spokesperson for Kris Kobach, the commission’s co-chair and the Republican secretary of state for Kansas, called Dunlap’s lawsuit “baseless and paranoid.” The statement asserted that the commission’s work has been “stalled” by lawsuits, the arrest of a staff member on child pornography charges, and the death of one commissioner. “It is not at all surprising that Commission staff were very busy during this period,” the statement noted “Ironically, Dunlap’s lawsuit is only going to increase the workload faced by Commission staff and Department of Justice Attorneys.”

Kobach’s statement addressed just a small number of Dunlap’s allegations. For example, it asserted that it was “incorrect” that Kobach excluded Dunlap from communications “between September 12 and October 17”; the bulk of Dunlap’s complaints predate that period. For example, email records filed with a federal court by the Department of Justice show Kobach repeatedly discussed commission business in June with a handful of people without including other commissioners. Most notably, Kobach drafted a controversial letter to states requesting publicly available voter rolls with input from Hans von Spakovsky and J. Christian Adams, two Republicans who only joined the commission afterwards. Those discussions didn’t include other commissioners.

Dunlap asserted that the remainder of the commission was made aware of Kobach’s intent to send the letter only hours before states received copies. The suit claims this “deprived Secretary Dunlap of the opportunity to consult with other members of the Commission or to formulate and express his views as to the legality or propriety of this action.”

Dunlap asked Andrew Kossack, the executive director of the commission, for copies of this and other correspondence in a letter on Oct. 17 and again in a follow-up email on Nov. 1. Dunlap asserted that he has not been provided anything in response.

In a statement, Kossack said Dunlap’s lawsuit “has no merit and we look forward to refuting it in court.” He said he was “disappointed that Mr. Dunlap has chosen conflict over working cooperatively in a bipartisan manner to achieve the important goals of this commission.” He did not respond when asked why he had not given Dunlap the documents he’d asked for prior to filing the suit.

Among the other claims in the suit are contentions that the commission’s record-retention practices are lax and its use of personal email accounts presents data security risks.

The suit also claims the commission has not communicated with Dunlap since it last met in mid-September, including about plans for any future meetings. However, other commissioners and even outside groups have spoken publicly about such plans. On Oct. 19, for example, the conservative Minnesota Voters Alliance announced in a fundraising email that it had been “invited to speak at the December 2017 meeting of the ‘Presidential Advisory Commission on Election Integrity.’”

Dunlap, who said he was unaware of any such meeting, emailed Kossack on Oct. 25 to ask who had invited the group. Kossack, whose job is to run the commission’s operations, stated that he didn’t know. “I have never communicated with this group, and no meeting is scheduled for December,” he wrote in an Oct. 27 email to Dunlap, a copy of which was provided to ProPublica. Said Dunlap: “If the executive director of this commission doesn’t know what his commissioners are planning, that’s a sign of bigger problems. I think that really means we’ve gone off the rails.” (The Minnesota Voters Alliance has not responded to questions from ProPublica.)

Finally, Dunlap’s suit claims the commission’s purported bipartisanship is just “a facade,” a contention Dunlap has repeatedly made since the release of a now notorious email penned by von Spakovsky in February. “There isn’t a single Democratic official that will do anything other than obstruct any investigation of voter fraud,” von Spakovsky wrote, adding that if Democrats or “mainstream Republicans” were named to the commission, it would be an “abject failure.”

In a recent interview with The Hill, von Spakovsky defended the email, asserting it was part of a “private conversation.” He also stated that he believes he is getting along with the Democrats on the commission. “So far, at least, it seems like we’ve worked well together,” he said.

Countered Dunlap: “I just laughed when I read that. We aren’t working together at all.”

 

Header image: Maine Secretary of State Matthew Dunlap’s lawsuit accuses the Presidential Advisory Commission on Election Integrity of violating the Federal Advisory Commission Act, which requires that advisory committees be bipartisan and sets transparency requirements for them. (Carl D. Walsh/Portland Press Herald via Getty Images)

From Your Site Articles
  • No Democrats! Controversial GOP Lawyer Meets Secretly With State Election Officials - National Memo ›

Advertising

Start your day with National Memo Newsletter

Know first.

The opinions that matter. Delivered to your inbox every morning

Trump's Four Years Of Baiting NATO Came At Terrible Cost For Ukraine

Lucian K. Truscott IV
@LucianKTruscott
January 26 | 2023

Former President Donald Trump at an American military cemetery near Paris in 2018

AP Photo by Jacquelyn Martin

To help me write more columns like this one, as well as my screeds attacking traitorous Republicans, please consider becoming a paid subscriber.

Keep reading...Show less

Danziger Draws

Jeff Danziger
January 26 | 2023

Jeff Danziger lives in New York City. He is represented by CWS Syndicate and the Washington Post Writers Group. He is the recipient of the Herblock Prize and the Thomas Nast (Landau) Prize. He served in the US Army in Vietnam and was awarded the Bronze Star and the Air Medal. He has published eleven books of cartoons, a novel and a memoir. Visit him at DanzigerCartoons.

From Your Site Articles
  • Biden Will Send Sophisticated M1 Abrams Battle Tanks To Ukraine ›
  • Why Those Leopard II Tanks Are So Vital To Ukraine (And So Menacing  To Russia) ›
{{ post.roar_specific_data.api_data.analytics }}