Smart. Sharp. Funny. Fearless.
Friday, October 21, 2016

In a place haunted by ghosts, on a thoroughfare of the damned, standing upon ground once watered by blood, Breanna Mitchell lifted a camera to take her own picture. She smiled a sunshine smile.

And the Internet exploded.

The image the Alabama teenager captured of herself at Auschwitz, an earbud in one ear, has gone viral in the month since she posted it on Twitter. She’s been harshly criticized. She’s been called vile names. And yes, she’s endured that act of lazy person’s terrorism, the Internet death threat.

Mitchell insists she is unbowed. She explained in a video interview for something called TakePart Live that she wouldn’t do anything differently because she didn’t mean any harm. The photo, she says, was meant to honor her father, who passed his love of World War II history on to her. It was taken on the anniversary of his death.

Mitchell’s attitude toward her international notoriety is probably best summed up in a tweet she posted July 20: “I’m famous y’all.”


I don’t generally use this space to beat up teenagers for doing regrettable things. Doing regrettable things is pretty much your job description at that age and I’ve always felt you should be free to go about that job without the spotlight of media attention.

But what Mitchell did seems to demand a few words. Especially since she’s not the only one doing it. To the contrary, we learn that it has become quite the modern “thing,” people clowning, sticking out their tongues, lifting thumbs up, grinning like loons in somber and sacred places. They’ve done it at Auschwitz, at the New York memorial to the victims of 9/11, at the American cemetery at Normandy, at the Vietnam War Memorial in Washington, at grandmother’s funeral.

Nor is it just kids who are doing it. To the contrary, there exists a photo of a certain 52-year-old president of the United States grinning for a selfie with British Prime Minister David Cameron, and Danish Prime Minister Helle-Thorning Schmidt (both 47) at last year’s memorial service for Nelson Mandela. First lady Michelle Obama sits apart from them wearing a somber, funeral-appropriate expression that says clearly, “I don’t know these people.”

Look, I understand this is not exactly a federal crime. And yes, I get that people take pictures of themselves in order to place themselves in a context. It is a way of saying, “I was there.” Nothing wrong with that. I’ve done it myself.

But this whole thing of mugging for cameras in inappropriate places feels viscerally … wrong. It suggests a cluelessness, a shallowness, and an incapacity for reverence that have come to feel like the signature of these times. It suggests a lack of home training and a surplus of narcissism that have come to feel ubiquitous. For all her professed love of World War II history, Breanna Mitchell bespeaks a fundamental lack of respect for, and comprehension of, that history when she poses at Auschwitz — death place for nearly 1.1 million human beings — like she thinks she’s at Epcot.

That should not even have to be explained. But social media have rewritten the social contract and apparently what once did not need explaining now does — to kids and, worse, to their parents. More’s the pity.

Do we take nothing seriously? Is nothing so awful or so awesome as to make us look up from our own lives? Is no place so hallowed or holy that we would never think to use it as a stage upon which to showcase the fizzy wonderfulness of our own selves?

Apparently, not.

When you take a picture of yourself grinning and mugging at some sacred place, it diminishes the place and sends a message that has become too common: This is all about me.

And you know what? It isn’t.

(Leonard Pitts is a columnist for The Miami Herald, 1 Herald Plaza, Miami, FL, 33132. Readers may contact him via email at [email protected])

Photo via Twitter

  • Budjob

    At the very least,it is insensitive.

  • ps0rjl

    As an old-timer who doesn’t take selfies at all, I have to agree. We seem to have lost all sense of propriety especially at places where solemnity and respect should be shown.

    • Sand_Cat

      Why should that be a surprise in a society where one party has promoted refusal to pay taxes to support the government for years, with considerable success.

  • The lucky one

    Ms. Mitchell is just another exemplar of the clueless generation.

  • wilty707

    Narcissism, seflie – all choice words to describe this phenomenon. Yep, “I’m famous, y’all!!” does say it all. Clueless, totally clueless.

    I wonder what the GI’s would think of all this self absorption; those soldiers who came upon those camps at the end of WWII and saw the horror of it all.

    Not too kindly, I imagine.

  • RedBaxter

    I do agree that the selfie was insensitive, but she is a child to whom those memories are ancient history. Furthermore, she has been born into a present day where war is made almost as a matter of course, with absolutely NO regard for the innocent who are destroyed and dismissed as “collateral damage”. MONEY is to be made on war and MONEY is the god of the day. The disrespect of the cost of war was never made in clearer or uglier terms than the cheney/bush debacle’s refusal to allow pictures of the caskets and/or funerals of those killed in these illegal wars of choice, culminating in the firing of a photojournalist who dared publish the picture of all those flag-draped caskets aboard a plane.

  • charles king

    My daughter of (60yrs) tell me that the past is done with, but I tell her that you try not to let it happen again. Thank You are the magic words in my book. I Love Ya All. Mr. C. E. KING

    • mah101

      “The past is never dead. It isn’t even past.”
      William Faulkner (1951)

  • Daniel Jones

    The worst thing is, she probably feels this is a form of victory, that putting the horror behind her is a means of burying it.
    It isn’t. It just makes it easier for the next time–and there will always be a next time unless we remember and learn the fucking *lesson* of the time before.
    I know that that old line about those that do not remember history is considered a cliché. It *is* a cliché, but it is a cliché for a god damned *reason*.

  • howa4x

    the selfie absorbed generation

  • jointerjohn

    Should this be so surprising in a world where we have found it necessary to have constant entertainment? Where every classroom lesson must be cloaked in “fun” for the kids? Where children go to the playroom rather than learn to sit still in church with the adults? Our societal apetite for wall-to-wall thrills and amusements has brought us here.