Type to search

Do The CIA Revelations Mean Trump Will Be Putin’s Puppet?

Campaign 2016 Elections Politics Russia Top News US White House

Do The CIA Revelations Mean Trump Will Be Putin’s Puppet?

Trump, Putin, CIA

Reprinted with permission from AlterNet. 

In 1964, when Barry Goldwater ran against Lyndon Johnson, a man named John A. Stormer self-published a book called None Dare Call It Treason. It accused America’s left-leaning elites of paving the way for a Soviet victory in the Cold War. The book sold seven million copies, but Johnson crushed Goldwater in the election.

Now that the CIA has determined that the Russians intervened in the presidential election to help Trump win, the Cold War politics of left and right have been flipped. If Stormer rewrote his book for 2016, its thesis might go like this:

Beware of Donald Trump. Witlessly or willfully, he’s doing the Kremlin’s bidding. Anyone who enables him—on his payroll or in the press, by sucking up or by silence, out of good will or cowardice—is Vladimir Putin’s useful idiot. This is a national emergency, and treating it like normal is criminally negligent of our duty to American democracy.

Trump as traitor: I can just imagine the reaction from the Tower penthouse. Lying media. Paranoid hyperbole. Partisan libel. Sour grapes. A pathetic bid for clicks. A desperate assault on the will of the people. Sad! (Note to Tweeter-in-Chief: You’re welcome.)

As a kid in a New Jersey household where Adlai Stevenson was worshipped, I thought Stormer was a nut job, so I won’t pretend that accepting the modern inverse of his case is a no-brainer. I’m also not trying to recast my political differences with the president-elect as a national security crisis. Trump won. Elections have consequences. I get that.

I may not like it, but I’m not surprised that Trump tapped Oklahoma Attorney General Scott Pruitt, a crusading climate change denier and an advocate of dismantling the Environmental Protection Agency, to run the EPA, presumably into the ground. Anyone who interpreted Al Gore’s meeting with Trump as a sign of his open-mindedness on climate change got played, just like Gore got played.

Similarly, I’m cynical, but not shocked that Trump’s picks for treasury secretary, National Economic Council and chief adviser—Steven Mnuchin, Gary Cohn and Steve Bannon—are alumni of Goldman Sachs. A billionaire managed to hijack Bernie Sanders’ indictment of Wall Street and brand Hillary Clinton as the stooge of Goldman Sachs. The success of that impersonation isn’t on Trump, it’s on us.

I’m infuriated, but not startled that Trump refuses to disclose his tax returns, divest his assets, create a credible blind trust, obey the constitutional prohibition of foreign emoluments or eliminate the conflict between fattening his family fortune and advancing American interests. That’s not draining the swamp, it’s drinking it.

It’s abysmal that Democrats didn’t have a good enough jobs message to convince enough Rust Belt voters to choose their economic alternative to Trump’s tax cuts for the rich. It’s disgraceful that the media normalized Trump, propagated his lies, monetized his notoriety and lapped up his tweet porn. It’s maddening that the Electoral College apportions ballot power inequitably. But as enervating as any of that is, none of it is as dangerous to democracy as the CIA’s finding that Putin hacked the 2016 election on Trump’s behalf. Without firing a single shot, the Kremlin is weeks away from installing its puppet in the White House.

Within days, Trump is expected to name Rex Tillerson, Exxon Mobil’s CEO, as his secretary of state. Putin bestowed the Order of Friendship, one of Russia’s highest civilian honors, on Tillerson, after Exxon signed a deal with Rosneft, the Russian government-owned oil company, to jointly explore the Black Sea and Arctic. The plan died when the U.S. and EU sanctioned Russia for annexing Crimea; Tillerson, whose Exxon shares’ value will skyrocket if sanctions are lifted, favors lifting them.

The Tillerson appointment is the latest dot in the pattern of Trump’s Putinophilia. When 17 U.S. intelligence agencies concurred that Russia was behind the hacking of Democratic emails, Trump—who’s refused most of his security briefings—rejected their conclusion, claiming at one point that it “could be somebody sitting on their bed that weighs 400 pounds,” at another that “it could be some guy in his home in New Jersey.” I knew that Trump is a serial fat-shamer, but I didn’t know until now that being a Newarker puts me in his crosshairs, too.

It’s entirely conceivable that Russia has something on Trump. They may hold hundreds of millions of dollars of Trump debt. They may have spousally unsettling video of him—a KGB specialty, and a plausible Trump susceptibility. Surely the Kremlin has mapped his character disorder. In the third debate, when Trump said Putin had no respect for Clinton, and she shot back, “Well, that’s because he’d rather have a puppet as president,” Trump’s interruption—“No puppet, no puppet, you’re the puppet, no, you’re the puppet”—sounded like a third-grader. Actually, it was a confession, what clinicians call projective identification. Putin’s psy ops must know every such string on him to play.

Before the election, when both parties’ congressional leaders were secretly informed that Russia had its thumb on the scale for Trump, Republican leader Mitch McConnell torpedoed a bipartisan plan to decry their intervention. Now that the news is out, Democrats and Republicans on the Senate Armed Services Committee said Sunday that the intel “should alarm every American,” and they called for a bipartisan investigation to stop “the grave threats that cyberattacks… pose to our national security.”

Trump’s response? “I think it is ridiculous. It’s just another excuse. I don’t believe it. Every week it’s another excuse. We had a massive landslide victory, as you know, in the Electoral College.”

As we don’t know. Trump’s Electoral College margin will rank 44th among the 54 presidential elections that have been held since the 12th Amendment was ratified. Nate Silver called Trump’s “landslide” claim “Orwellian.” The Washington Post gave it Four Pinocchios. Why not just call it a lie?

Trump blew off the Kremlin’s intervention in our election the way Putin denied Russia’s intervention in Ukraine. Do we call that a lie, too?

Maybe there’s a better word we should dare to use.

IMAGE: Russian President Vladimir Putin (C), Defence Minister Sergei Shoigu (L) and Russia’s Federal Security Service (FSB) Director Alexander Bortnikov watch events to mark Victory Day in Sevastopol May 9, 2014. REUTERS/Maxim Shemetov/File Photo 



  1. I Am Helpy December 13, 2016

    Don’t forget that his daughter goes on holidays with Putin’s girlfriend. Trump voters are so dumb that they’re not even bothering to pretend.

    1. skisok December 14, 2016

      They’ll find out the hard way but unfortunately, they have taken us who know better with them.

  2. Otto T. Goat December 13, 2016

    More skype loser smears.

    1. I Am Helpy December 14, 2016

      Oh no, an actual goddam Nazi who believes discredited eugenics nonsense thinks this is a smear.

  3. Andor Trayven December 13, 2016

    Trump already IS Putin’s puppet. He has made that crystal clear, with his idiotic denial of Russian aggression against Ukraine (is he so stupid he doesn’t realize the Crimea was part of Ukraine?), with his refusal to reveal how much he owes to Russian oligarchs (it must be a lot; he hasn’t been able to conceal that he owes the Chinese almost a billion dollars), with his infantile praise of Putin “because he says nice things about me”, and with the appointment of OTHER Russian toadies like Tillotson, to name just one, to high office.

    Most corrupt administration in history, and hasn’t even been sworn in yet…

    1. FireBaron December 14, 2016

      This is going to make the Harding and Grant administrations look like exemplars of clean administrations!

  4. FireBaron December 14, 2016

    Waddya mean “Will Be”? Every pronouncement he has made has already told the rest of the world he will allow at least Eastern Europe, and possibly the Middle East to be Vladimir Vladimirovich, Tsar of All Russias’ personal sandbox. He has told our long time NATO Allies that they have to pony up if they expect our support – this despite the fact that our European Allies already contribute a significant portion of their budgets to support our troops still treating Europe like it is our occupied territory after WW2!

    1. dpaano December 14, 2016

      Wow….that’s pretty scary!!

  5. FT66 December 14, 2016

    Hillary warned us during one of the debates that Trump will be Putin’s puppet. Here we are it hasn’t taken long to start seeing with our own eyes. She was quite right.

  6. Paul Anthony December 14, 2016

    The CIA has a long history of interfering in the elections of other countries. It is not surprising they would suspect other countries of similar behavior. But the FBI disagrees.
    Who you believe seems to depend on which side of the political spectrum you stand.

    1. skisok December 14, 2016

      Well the FBI showed what side of the political spectrum they are on during the final days of the election.

    2. johninPCFL December 14, 2016

      And the FBI showed themselves to be fully onboard for Agent Orange.

      Putin can now run the country through Manafort, Bannon, and Tillerson. He doesn’t have to talk to Trump.

      But on the plus side, Agent Orange has shown that he’s more than willing to pick winners and losers in the market, then use government money to back the folks he wants to be winners. What’s that called again? Oh, yeah. Commun…er…Putinism, right?

  7. yabbed December 14, 2016

    Trump is what is called in the vernacular Putin’s b**ch. The Republicans sold our country out to the Russians. And just as Khrushchev said, America failed not with a bang but with a whimper.

    1. Dan S December 14, 2016

      If Trump is Putins beyotch what does that make us I’m afraid to ask ????

      1. dpaano December 14, 2016

        It makes some of us (those that voted for Trump) stupid!

  8. Burt of Saint Augustine December 14, 2016

    Amplify this and Trump’s in the process of making America Putin’s satellite country.


Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.