Plane Disaster Tests Once-Close Relationship Between China, Malaysia

Plane Disaster Tests Once-Close Relationship Between China, Malaysia

By Stuart Leavenworth, McClatchy Foreign Staff

NANYANG, China — Last October, as the U.S. budget meltdown was forcing President Barack Obama to abandon a key trip to Asia, China’s top leader, Xi Jinping, seized on Washington’s dysfunction and courted Malaysia with a big trade pact.

“Our two countries have proven to be good neighbors, good friends and good partners who go through thick and thin together,” Xi was quoted as saying in an account of his visit to Malaysia’s capital, Kuala Lumpur, published October 4 by The Star, a Malaysian newspaper.

Five months later, China’s bonds with Malaysia are fraying, a victim of the Malaysian Airlines Flight 370 disaster, which has presumably killed all 239 people on board, two-thirds of whom were Chinese citizens.

China’s government this week issued bellicose statements against Malaysia, its third-largest trading partner in Asia, as the search for the plane entered its third week. It ramped up its rhetoric on Monday when Malaysia concluded that the plane had gone down in the south Indian Ocean, based on no findings of debris but rather on a satellite data analysis by Inmarsat, a British company.

“We demand the Malaysian side to make clear the specific basis on which they come to this judgment,” Deputy Foreign Minister Xie Hangsheng told Malaysia’s ambassador to Beijing, according to China’s state-run media.

Such government statements mirror the national mood in China, where the public has been exposed to wrenching news broadcasts of relatives of MH370 passengers weeping, fainting and lashing out at airline officials at a Beijing hotel. They also reflect the fears of Chinese Communist Party leaders that the national mood might turn against them — especially if they don’t project a strong image in the face of an unprecedented national tragedy.

“The Chinese government is under enormous domestic pressure to get to the bottom of what happened to MH370 and to find the plane,” said Bonnie Glaser, a senior adviser for Asia at the Washington-based Center for Strategic and International Studies research organization.

“There is a perception that the Chinese government must be seen by its people as doing everything possible to protect the interests of its people and the nation,” she wrote in an email. “The failure to do so might negatively affect the legitimacy of the CCP.”

China normally doesn’t issue public demands to its Asian neighbors, partly because it bristles when any of them make anything resembling a demand on China. But this is hardly a normal situation. Never before has China lost so many citizens in an air crash involving a foreign airline. China’s worst aviation disaster came in 1994, when a China Northwest Airlines Tupolev TU-154 crashed after takeoff near the northern city of Xian, killing all 160 people on board.

Glaser said the current situation reminded her of the SARS epidemic of 2003 and 2004, when the respiratory ailment spread from southern China to 37 countries, amid accusations that Chinese officials had been slow to report the outbreak. China tried to project an image of controlling the situation while relying on the World Health Organization and other international groups to stem the crisis.

In the case of MH370, China has sent ships, planes and technical advisers to search the “target area” off Australia. A Chinese IL-76 aircraft reached the area in the south Indian Ocean on Wednesday morning, according to Chinese media. A Chinese icebreaker arrived Monday, joining five other nations — Australia, New Zealand, the United States, Japan and the Republic of Korea — in the search for the plane.

The search crews are racing against the clock, since the black box in the MH370 will stop sending out signals at some point, generally 30 days after a commercial airliner has been lost.

At the same time, China has played tough with Malaysia, allowing rare public protests and newspaper editorials accusing Kuala Lumpur of outright lies.

On Monday, police stood by as an angry crowd threw water bottles outside the Malaysian Embassy in Beijing, with some demonstrators carrying signs that read, “Malaysian government has cheated us.” Public protests are permitted in China’s capital only infrequently, and when they happen they’re almost certainly government approved.

On Tuesday, Xi dispatched a special envoy, Zhang Yesui, a vice foreign minister, to meet with top-level officials in Kuala Lumpur.

On Wednesday, Malaysian officials seemed to have had enough of it, countering Beijing’s suggestions that China alone has an interest in learning the fate of MH370.

“For the Chinese families … they must also understand: We in Malaysia also lost our loved ones,” acting Transport Minister Datuk Seri Hishammuddin Hussein said at a news conference. Fifty of the 239 passengers on board were Malaysian.

Neither China nor Malaysia can afford to watch their long-standing relationship unravel. Malaysia, with 29.6 million people, is China’s third-largest trading partner in Asia, behind only Japan and South Korea, and the two countries had bilateral trade last year worth $106 billion. They’ve grown increasingly close since 1974, when Malaysia became the first of the countries within the Association of Southeast Asian Nations to establish diplomatic ties with China. More than one-fifth of Malaysia’s population is of Chinese descent.

While analysts don’t expect the MH370 tragedy to seriously damage that economic relationship, there’s anecdotal evidence that the flight’s mysterious disappearance is hurting Malaysian tourism. Various news agencies have reported that online and travel agencies’ bookings between China and Malaysia have fallen sharply in recent weeks.

Photo: Shen Bohan/Xinhua/Zuma Press/MCT

Start your day with National Memo Newsletter

Know first.

The opinions that matter. Delivered to your inbox every morning

Greg Abbott
Gov. Greg Abbott
Youtube Screenshot

The local economy of Eagle Pass, Texas was all set to rake in a huge financial windfall this weekend, when the town was expected to play host to tens of thousands of visitors eager to be the first in the US to see Monday's solar eclipse. Instead, Republican Gov. Greg Abbott's ongoing border standoff with the federal government ended up scaring most tourists away.

Keep reading...Show less
Joe Biden

President Joe Biden

In the four weeks since his fiery State of the Union address, President Joe Biden's campaign has kicked into high gear—barnstorming eight battleground states, opening up more than 100 field offices, making a $30 million ad buy, and launching a Latino outreach strategy targeting the Southwestern swing states of Arizona and Nevada.

Keep reading...Show less
{{ }}