Seattle Boy Scouts Council Revokes Charter In Gay Scoutmaster Case

Seattle Boy Scouts Council Revokes Charter In Gay Scoutmaster Case

By Nancy Bartley, The Seattle Times

SEATTLE — The Seattle Boy Scouts of America council has revoked the charter of the church that hosts the troop led by gay scoutmaster Geoff McGrath.

In a prepared statement, BSA said the decision was made to pull the charter from Rainier Beach United Methodist Church “because the church no longer agrees to the terms” of the agreement.

“We are saddened by this development, but remain committed to providing all youth with the best possible scouting experience where the scouting program is the main focus,” Deron Smith, BSA director of communications, wrote in the statement. “We have already identified a new chartered organization to sponsor the units and are contacting the parents and leaders of the units to inform them of the change.”

But the Rev. Monica Corsaro, whose Rainier Beach United Methodist Church sponsors McGrath’s Boy Scout troop, hopes the council will change its mind once Robert Gates becomes national BSA president next month.

Gates, the former CIA director and secretary of Defense, overturned the military’s “don’t ask, don’t tell” policy. He could not be reached for comment Monday.

McGrath, who is married to his partner of 20 years, said he was disappointed and surprised at the decision but insists his group of about 15 boys will continue to meet — even though they’ll be looking for another organization to belong to.

He and the church have retained a lawyer to determine their options.

And Corsaro said that “based on our religious principles, we will continue to act as an autonomous church that does not discriminate. We will continue to have our troop meetings here, every Thursday night, with business as usual.”

Last May, BSA’s National Council agreed to allow gay youth into the program but not in leadership.

The controversy surrounding Troop 98 emerged in March, when an NBC News report on the troop prompted the BSA to question McGrath’s sexual orientation.

“I got a call from an attorney from BSA. They had received an inquiry from the press about our troop and he asked me, ‘Are you an open and avowed homosexual?’ I thought the question was abrupt and insulting,” McGrath said.

McGrath acknowledged his sexual orientation to the BSA, which in turn responded by revoking his status as scoutmaster. Now that the church stood by him, BSA has revoked its charter.

“I was shocked and dismayed that parents were going to have to work through this,” McGrath said. And he was in disbelief because a number of people in the Seattle council had known he was gay for a long time and supported him.

The Rainier Beach group offers Scouting for boys who may not have other activities, Corsaro said. She said the support for McGrath has been overwhelmingly positive.

The United Methodist Church is the BSA’s second-largest sponsoring organization, accounting for more than 363,000 youth members nationwide. The Rainier Beach church is part of the Reconciling Ministries Network, comprising more than 600 United Methodist communities across the country who welcome and affirm LGBTQ individuals.

There are at least 70 other Scouting units chartered to Reconciling Ministries congregations throughout the U.S.

Photo via Flickr; ewan traveler

Local Volunteers Provide Help Like No Other At The Mudslide

Local Volunteers Provide Help Like No Other At The Mudslide

By Nancy Bartley, The Seattle Times

SEATTLE — Just before dark on the drizzling day, the long line of trucks came back. Windshield wipers clicking, headlights beaming, there were firetrucks, aid cars, flatbed trucks with bulldozers and dump trucks. Dozens of them moved slowly along Highway 530 from the mudslide to the Oso Fire Department.

“They’re coming in,” said Nikki Stinson, as she watched from her front yard. She walked back to the old farmhouse. In minutes, she could hear the stomp of boots and voices as the rescue workers peeled off fluorescent bunker gear, leaving chunks of blue-gray mud on the wraparound porch.

Ever since the March 22 mudslide killed about 20 percent of the village’s 180 people and left several more missing, Stinson, her husband, Corey, and their six children have been helping out. They’ve taken unpaid leave from jobs to “go out to the pile,” the swath of refuse-laden gray mud, moved boxes of donated items, kept the coffee pot going and housed visiting workers.

About 900 workers and 31 excavators remain at what is still a recovery operation. Among the workers is a cadre of locals — usually those with special skills — who volunteer. In the Oso and Darrington communities, most who live in the small houses along Highway 530 have fed or housed volunteer searchers and have gleaned the mounds of mud at the slide scene for human remains or personal possessions. Sometimes they find clues — a comic book, a toolbox, a toy — from how life used to be.

At this time last year, Oso was planning an Easter Egg Hunt, one of the many such events in the small community, where losing neighbors is losing family. The other day, volunteers back from the site warmed themselves at a burn barrel. Against the distant foothills, rolls of blue-black clouds gathered as the last rays of sun slid against wet grass. Smoke drifted from chimneys of houses scattered through the valley.

Next door to the Stinsons, Jeff Smith, 62, came home after working on an access road at the slide site. His wife, Teresa, stood out on the porch with their grandsons as slide traffic crawled past.

Teresa Smith, 61, grew up in their white farmhouse, where American and Marine Corps flags fly at half-staff. Heavy equipment and a flatbed truck are parked at the side.

The day of the slide, she was doing dishes when the lights blinked and her husband, an Oso Fire Department volunteer, was paged. There was a roof in the road and some flooding, something Jeff Smith thought would require putting up traffic cones. Nothing prepared any of them for what they found: a lunar landscape of gray where trees, homes and Highway 530 had been.

The community immediately rushed to the rescue, with the all-volunteer Oso Fire Department first on the scene.

While many out-of-town volunteers have left, a core group of local volunteers continues on — some giving full-time hours at the slide, others sandwiching volunteer time during days off from work.

“You just do what you have to do,” Teresa Smith said. “You don’t think about it.”

She has worked at the fire-station kitchen, which at one point was feeding 200 people a day. Jeff Smith volunteered his heavy equipment, despite the high cost of the diesel to operate it or the time it takes away from other jobs.

“We’re Oso. We just do it,” Teresa said. For her, it’s part of being in a community. It’s where she went to the historic white Oso School with its bell. It’s where she spent summers making money by picking raspberries down the road. It’s where she gossiped about boys with girlfriends along the beach at the creek that meanders through the valley.

At first, some of the volunteers from Oso and Darrington felt pushed out when crews from the Federal Emergency Management Agency (FEMA) arrived a few days after the slide. Working in the piles of mud helped the locals cope with the loss of neighbors and friends, and the loggers familiar with the area argued they had local knowledge that out-of-towners didn’t. The contentiousness eventually subsided.

Teresa Smith praised FEMA’s John Bentley from Maryland for his kindness and efficiency. “He said we were like family.”

Nikki Stinson walked across the wet grass to Teresa’s house. Ron and Gail Thompson, who were away from home when the slide hit, were visiting. One of Nikki’s boys who worked at the slide recovered Ron’s toolbox — the entire thing flattened.

Nikki Stinson’s great-grandmother was born in a tent near the Oso Community Chapel. Nikki Stinson grew up in Arlington and moved back a few years ago. She, too, helps at the fire station. These days have brought everyone more into contact than ever before.

The old days when you could “pass through Oso and not know so” are over, she said.

Later, as Stinson’s family gathered around the table in the bright-blue dining room, Morgan Stinson, 18, talked about being at the slide and finding “cars completely mangled and then finding a quilt perfectly intact.”

He took time off from his work at a cabinet shop. “I feel I have to be out there,” he said. “This is my community.”

Lindsey Wasson/Seattle Times/MCT