Type to search

What Democrats Should Fear Most About Scott Walker

Featured Post Memo Pad Top News

What Democrats Should Fear Most About Scott Walker


Before there were public employee unions, there was Tonette.

Unintimidated is the title of Wisconsin Gov. Scott Walker’s book, the title of his SuperPAC, and the thematic spine of his presidential campaign. It is of course a reference to his knock-down, drag-out fight with state worker unions, and his subsequent triumphs in politics and policy.

The protracted showdown over collective bargaining rights revealed the small-town pastor’s son with the low-key manner to be unusually audacious and persistent, as well as undeterred by custom or convention. None of that would have surprised anyone familiar with the story of his marriage — a revelatory tale that should make smart Democrats nervous about Mr. Unintimidated.

Tonette Walker lost her first husband, her grandmother, and her brother (her only sibling) in the same year, when she was 30. Five years later, she exchanged glances with Walker on karaoke night at a barbecue restaurant and nearly threw out the paper napkin on which he had written his phone number. She thought he was handing her his trash as he walked out.

“He actually told my roommate that the night he met me [he knew] he was going to marry me. You can only imagine the laugh my roommate and I had over that,” Tonette said last fall in accepting the Margaret Thatcher Award from a conservative group called Right Wisconsin.

Her losses, she said, had made her cynical about men and dismissive of marriage. On top of that, she was 12 years older than Scott. “At first I thought Scott was just infatuated with an older woman. But you know with Scott, he had a counterpoint to every concern I raised. When I pointed out our age difference, he told me that his grandparents, they were 12 years apart and they were married for decades,” she said in her speech.

Walker, a conservative who had started running for office at 22, managed to convince not only Tonette but her Democratic, union-member parents. The age difference “was more of an issue to my family than him being a Republican,” Tonette told Brava Magazine in Madison just before Walker took office in 2011. Now, her Democratic upbringing long behind her, she is a full political partner to her husband and an effective public champion for him.

Walker’s dogged pursuit of an older woman bruised by tragedy is consistent with his damn-the-torpedoes conservative governance in a state that hasn’t voted for a Republican presidential candidate since 1984. A lot of people were shell-shocked, but in retrospect, they shouldn’t have been. His marriage was an early example of his disregard for the usual path and in fact a sign that he thrives on the challenges of going off-road.

The age gap that gave Tonette’s family pause — and which she recently told The Washington Post she herself would wonder about if her son brought home an older woman — could even work to the Walkers’ advantage in a campaign. Consider that just 2 percent of men marry or remarry women 10 or more years older than they are, according to a Pew Research Center poll last December.

In popular culture, there’s a stereotype of desperate “cougars” of a certain age going after younger men. But in politics, a man with an older wife can benefit from a halo effect. Admit it, until the whole thing imploded, didn’t you feel better about the impossibly attractive John Edwards because Elizabeth, his late wife, was five years older and looked her age?

Walker has been one long walking, talking, maddening provocation to Democrats. Even more annoying, there were few overt clues to his intentions. He did not campaign in 2010 on going after collective bargaining rights for public employees, but that battle defined him once he took office. Likewise, in 2011 he signaled disinterest in right-to-work laws that would affect private unions — but he signed such a law in March.

Democratic strategist Bill Burton warned his fellow Democrats more than once before the 2014 elections that they would have deep regrets if they didn’t oust Walker right then and there. “Scott Walker is a real threat in 2016,” he said on Bloomberg TV. “If we miss the opportunity as Democrats to take him out now, it could be a real issue for us.”

His alarms came months after the party had nominated a political novice, businesswoman Mary Burke, who proved not nearly up to the task of defeating a national conservative icon in a Republican year. Walker won in 2010. He won a recall in 2012. He won re-election in 2014. His coming announcement for president Monday in Waukesha is a formality. He has been firmly lodged in the elite top tier of the gigantic GOP field for months.

All of that was against the odds. Just like against the odds, he got the girl.

Follow Jill Lawrence on Twitter @JillDLawrence. To find out more about Jill Lawrence and read features by other Creators Syndicate writers and cartoonists, visit the Creators Syndicate website at www.creators.com.

Illustration: DonkeyHotey via Flickr

Jill Lawrence

Award-winning journalist Jill Lawrence is a nationally syndicated columnist and a contributing editor to U.S. News & World Report. She also contributed to The Surge: 2014's Big GOP Win and What It Means for the Next Presidential Race (2015). Lawrence has discussed political and policy developments on television, radio, and many other media outlets. She was an adjunct professorial lecturer at American University in 2014, teaching on the relationship between politics and the media.

Lawrence has covered every presidential campaign since 1988, as well as historic events such as the Three Mile Island nuclear accident, the 1994 Republican takeover of Congress, the Clinton impeachment, the Florida recount, and the 1993 and 2009 battles over health reform.

  • 1


  1. charleo1 July 9, 2015

    What everyone would like to know, is if the Koch Brothers had anything to do with his picking this person for a mate? If not, it would be one of the few decisions this little creep has made on anything of import they haven’t personally bought and paid for. Yes, Tonette’s parents are Democrats, and Union Members, and Scott was a Right Winger. But did they know she was hooking her wagon to such a bought, and paid for POS? In fact, I’d like to know what, if anything, Scott Walker has done in the last couple of decades, where the Koch operation wasn’t pulling the strings.

    1. OK_Sam July 9, 2015

      You are actually quite a jerk.

      1. The lucky one July 9, 2015

        Is that what passes as a substantive reply from a right-winger?

        1. OK_Sam July 9, 2015

          It is good enough for you, and I mean that substantively.

          1. The lucky one July 9, 2015

            That’s okay, it’s all I expect from a moron.

    2. paulyz July 9, 2015

      You forgot that Walker won THREE elections in 4 years, so quit with your completely biased & uninformed B.S. already.

      1. FireBaron July 9, 2015

        Hi first election was won because he actually went out and campaigned for the job. He stated what he planned on doing without hedging his bets. That appealed to a state trying to recover from the Economic meltdown of 2007/2008. Unfortunately for Walker, the state still has not recovered.
        The 2012 recall was won because the people of Wisconsin felt that they were better served by the “Devil they knew”.
        The 2014 election was not so much won by Walker as lost by Democrats. Their failure to run a legitimate candidate that knew what she (or he) was doing was their major failure.
        Those three victories have convinced Walker that he can win the Presidency. Unfortunately for him, his brand of Conservatism doesn’t play well outside of the state where the Koch Brothers can afford to buy good press for him.

        1. paulyz July 9, 2015

          Constantly with excuses, just like your buddy Obama. Never admitting how wrong you are.

  2. Michael Ross July 9, 2015

    It would be a fair comparison if Tonette had ignored the constant warning of Scott’s ex that he was a lying cheating backstabbing fraud.

    Scott Walker doesn’t have that same luxury of ambiguity and a nonexistent past record. When he runs for POTUS, he’s going to have to deal with his home state repeatedly warning the country not to vote for him.

  3. angryspittle July 9, 2015

    I find it really hard to believe that the people of Wisconsin actually voted for this dweeb. I suspect some electoral shenanigans of some sort, lost ballots, machine fixes or something. Unless, of course, cheesehead voters are brain damaged window lickers.

  4. irishtap July 9, 2015

    This guy is dangerous. He is without conscience and is driven. Really driven. Everything he does is about starving government/education, weakening workers/women’s rights and of course lowering wages as part of his “Wisconsin is open for business” economic policy. Forget about the ACA – he refuses to accept federal money to help people obtain affordable health care. Privatization is his mission. He uses divide and conquer tactics to win elections and lies with every exhale. The NRA was helpful in the most recent election in scaring the hunters away from the “liberal candidate.”
    Walker would salivate at starting a middle east war and will stomp on the Constitution without the slightest reservation. He’ll stack the Supreme Court with more Scalia’s – count on it. He’s a devout climate change denier – loves the polluters. I’m telling you people: this guy has no soul. He is the face of corruption. DO NOT take this man lightly – he’ll make “W” look like FDR.

  5. Budjob July 10, 2015

    It is quite evident,that the best and,most intelligent part of this NAZI BASTARD ran down his Mother’s leg! He is an EXTREMELY DANGEROUS INDIVIDUAL!!!

    1. rudytbone July 14, 2015

      Nazis were socialists, and clearly Walker is a capitalist. But you are right to be afraid of him. Be very afraid. He very well may end the left’s long march through federal institutions…just like he started doing in Wisconsin.


Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.