Booed In Maine, Collins Faces Dimming Prospects In Midterm

@alexvhenderson
Susan Collins

Sen. Susan Collins

Photo by AFGE / CC BY 2.0

When Sen. Susan Collins (R-ME) spoke at a late August ribbon-cutting ceremony in her state, she was aggressively booed and heckled by attendees. This booing was quite a contrast to the enthusiastic support she enjoyed in Maine in the past, when she was reelected by 23 percent in 2008 and 37 percent in 2014.

Maine voters were quite willing to split their tickets in 2008, choosing Barack Obama in the presidential race while voting overwhelmingly to give Republican Collins another term in the U.S. Senate.

MSNBC's Steve Benen, in an opinion column published on August 28, stresses that the booing Collins recently suffered underscores a broader problem in the GOP. President Donald Trump's economic policies, according to Benen, are wildly unpopular — and even a moderate conservative like Collins is having a hard time distancing herself from them.

The recent booing, according to Benen, is quite a contrast to 2017 — when she voted "no," along with Sen. Lisa Murkowski (R-AK) and the late Sen. John McCain (R-AZ), on a Trump-backed bill that would have overturned the Affordable Care Act of 2010 (also known as "Obamacare").

"In July 2017," Benen recalls, "Republican Sen. Susan Collins made a routine trip home, as she'd done countless times during her lengthy congressional career. But this time, her arrival was quite a bit different: After walking into the terminal at Bangor International Airport, the senator was greeted with spontaneous applause. There was no great mystery as to why: Collins had just voted to derail the Republican Party's far-right health care gambit, and relieved Mainers apparently wanted to show their appreciation for her having done the right thing to protect the public from her own party's agenda."

Benen adds, "Collins, receiving the kind of outpouring of support most members of Congress can only dream of, described the scene as 'amazing.' Eight years later, the GOP incumbent is facing a very different kind of public reception in her home state."

Collins, now in her fifth term, is up for reelection in the 2026 midterms — and the recent booing, according to Benen, "probably wasn't encouraging."

"Collins' detractors raised a variety of points, though at this specific event, a local report from the Midcoast Villager noted, 'Detractors questioned Collins’ role in celebrating new spending while President Donald Trump and her fellow Republicans in Congress push through federal budget cuts to health care, food assistance and other services.'"

Benen continues, "The senator has argued that when her party's far-right megabill recently came to the Senate floor, she voted against it. That's true. But it's also true that when the inaptly named One Big Beautiful Bill Act needed to clear a key procedural hurdle a few days earlier, which allowed senators to advance the radical legislation, Collins voted with her party and the megabill's proponents — even as some other Senate Republicans sided with the package's Democratic opponents. Some of her constituents appear to have noticed."


"In July 2017," Benen recalls, "Republican Sen. Susan Collins made a routine trip home, as she'd done countless times during her lengthy congressional career. But this time, her arrival was quite a bit different: After walking into the terminal at Bangor International Airport, the senator was greeted with spontaneous applause. There was no great mystery as to why: Collins had just voted to derail the Republican Party's far-right health care gambit, and relieved Mainers apparently wanted to show their appreciation for her having done the right thing to protect the public from her own party's agenda."

Benen adds, "Collins, receiving the kind of outpouring of support most members of Congress can only dream of, described the scene as 'amazing.' Eight years later, the GOP incumbent is facing a very different kind of public reception in her home state."

Collins, now in her fifth term, is up for reelection in the 2026 midterms — and the recent booing, according to Benen, "probably wasn't encouraging."

by TaboolaSponsored LinksYou May LikeWhy Appetite Patches Are Suddenly Everywhere50&Beyond

READ MORE: 'Let me just stop you there': Wallace cuts off guest who calls for 'nuance' on Trump move

"Collins' detractors raised a variety of points, though at this specific event, a local report from the Midcoast Villager noted, 'Detractors questioned Collins’ role in celebrating new spending while President Donald Trump and her fellow Republicans in Congress push through federal budget cuts to health care, food assistance and other services.'"

Benen continues, "The senator has argued that when her party's far-right megabill recently came to the Senate floor, she voted against it. That's true. But it's also true that when the inaptly named One Big Beautiful Bill Act needed to clear a key procedural hurdle a few days earlier, which allowed senators to advance the radical legislation, Collins voted with her party and the megabill's proponents — even as some other Senate Republicans sided with the package's Democratic opponents. Some of her constituents appear to have noticed."

READ MORE: 'What happens when he's gone?' Trump’s health issues have associates jockeying for leadership

Steve Benen's full MSNBC column is available at this link.

Report typos and corrections to: feedback@alternet.org.

Do you think Trump’s influence is weakening within the Republican Party?

'I'm very good at grass': Trump goes off-script in bizarre rantDiscoverThis single sentence will fast-track Trump to a prison cellDiscoverThe Motley FoolExperts think this could be like buying Nvidia at $0.16Read MoreSkipKeeps getting worse: Timeline of Trump's futile Epstein diversions details his newest scamDiscover'Dementia alert': Trump’s bizarre 'grass' rant raises alarmDiscoverAre These New Appetite Patches Worth the Attention?50&Beyond|SponsoredThe Shampoo That’s Changing Men’s LivesWellness+Lab|SponsoredMassachusetts Residents With Credit Card Debt Could Be In For Loan-Free ReliefForbes|SponsoredNantucket: Here’s The Average Price of a 6-Hour Gutter UpgradeHomebuddy.com|SponsoredBefore You Blame Low Vitamin B, Learn The Real Cause of NeuropathyFootRenew|SponsoredFlight Attendant Reveals How Seniors Can Fly Business Class For The Price Of EconomyAirlines | Insider Deals|SponsoredRead Comments - Join the Discussion

'They became more and more extreme': Shocking website revealed as 'gateway' for shooters

'Traumatic' wave of active-shooter hoaxes on campuses linked to right-wing extremist group

Inside the Trump strategy that should terrify you the most

Trump drops 'atomic bomb' on DOJ: analysis

An awful Trump secret is about to come crashing into the open

'Waste of time': Jen Psaki smacks down Karoline Leavitt's attack

Trump’s allies claim his popularity 'couldn't be higher' — but voters say otherwise

'C’mon man': Fox News analyst blasts Trump’s latest rant

'Everyone's the enemy now': DC insider details Trump’s myriad national security blunders

'Big boo-boo': GOP senators turn on Trump over fears of 'economic downturn'

Conservative lawmaker’s bombshell decision could radically reshape House GOP

Right-wing pundits rip 'the gratuitous viciousness' of Trump’s retaliation campaign

Trump may slap blue state's taxpayers with $1 billion charge over feud with governor

BRAND NEW STORIES

'Waste of time': Jen Psaki smacks down Karoline Leavitt's attack

'Just doesn't work': MAGA investor warns of dire consequences if Trump takes over Fed

'Man up!' Michael Steele rips Fed chair for not defending board member Trump is targeting

Convicted white supremacist band says they didn't mean for lyrics 'to be taken literally'

'Everyone's the enemy now': DC insider details Trump’s myriad national security blunders

'Dictator's playbook': Ex-GOP strategist says Trump may use military to disrupt elections

MOST POPULAR

'Very disrespectful!' Trump delivers late-night screed in response to 'bone spurs' hit

'Blatant and deplorable': Trump admin employees say they're forced to watch 'propaganda'

'What happens when he's gone?' Trump’s health issues have associates jockeying for leadership

'It’s a real gut punch': Rural voters 'stunned' by Trump’s damage

'Let me just stop you there': Wallace cuts off guest who calls for 'nuance' on Trump move

Trump drops 'atomic bomb' on DOJ: analysis

Trump's reckoning may be right around the corner — here's why

Outrage as Minneapolis mass shooting exposes more Republican lies

'You think he's joking?' CA gov hits raw nerve with latest Trump warning

Trump is breaking the promise our nation made to military veterans

Trending TopicsContactAdvertise with AlterNetPrivacy PolicyWriter GuidelinesPress InformationAbout AlterNetMeet the AlterNet StaffDebug Logs@2025 - AlterNet Media Inc. All Rights Reserved. - "Poynter" fonts provided by fontsempire.com.

Start your day with National Memo Newsletter

Know first.

The opinions that matter. Delivered to your inbox every morning

{{ post.roar_specific_data.api_data.analytics }}