Tag: turning point usa
TPUSA demonstration in San Antonio

Trad Wives And Tate Bros: My Weekend With TPUSA's Submission Marketeers

Your Freakshow guide is just back from a weekend in San Antonio, soaking up the sights and sounds at Turning Point USA’s Women’s Leadership Summit – and yes, coincidentally watching the Knicks kick the Spurs.

The word “leadership” was perhaps an oxymoron among the thousands of young women who sat through speech after speech about submitting to God, husband and female biology. The lineup featured high profile conservative women including Erica Kirk, Arkansas Gov. Sarah Huckabee Sanders, Kayleigh McEnany, and even Texas State Sen. Angela Paxton (Ken Paxton’s estranged and cheated-on wife), alongside a bouquet of hip and pretty right-wing Gen Z influencers all advocating early marriage and pregnancy and putting husband and hearth ahead of worldly pursuits.

The TPUSA Women’s Leadership Summit is an annual, expensively produced and carefully packaged political propaganda product. This year, the organization occupied three floors of the San Antonio Marriott, plastering the hotel’s walls, doors, escalators and elevators with slick signage. The main co-sponsor was the International Fellowship of Christians and Jews (IFCJ), whose founder said she flew in from Israel to encourage the gathered to repeat a Hebrew word offering themselves to God.

To the naked eye, the event was more tent revival than political conference. The most reliable applause lines invoked the dangers of Muslims and “transgenders.” No one needed a Trump button here. The politics of the participants was presumed. “It’s Not Political It’s Biblical” read one button on a table devoted to recruiting GOTV door-knockers, where a digital electoral map ranked the states according to how “tyrannical” – aka progressive – their policies are.

TPUSA’s project of selling Gen Z women on a submissive posture aligns with the Heritage Foundation’s latest manifesto. The overt push for submission – a concept that occupied white-nationalist fringe swamps merely a few years ago – has now become one of the ideological pillars enabling the predators’ ball assembled at the White House, headed by a convicted sex abuser and oft-accused serial sex pest.

The supposed personal misery and baby-hating of feminists is bedrock to the ideology (See: JD Vance and childless cat ladies). Twenty-something influencer Isabel Brown declared that the Handmaid’s Tale-dressed protesters outside the building “will say the baby growing inside you is a lethal parasite.”

“Charlie would often say that feminism was about wanting women to become men and eventually not needing men,” Erica Kirk said. “He watched feminism rear its head on college campuses in a way that was openly hostile to conservative women who were told to reject the very things that make womanhood unique. Things like motherhood is a burden, marriage is a trap, or motherhood is something that should be stalled or not even experienced at all…”

“Feminism is the biggest lie we have ever been sold as women,” said podcaster Savanna Stone, whose merch includes a Good Wife hat and a sweatshirt that reads Normalize Liking Husbands Again. “While the textbook definition of feminism is about equality between the sexes and women having agency over their own lives, what feminism actually is, is a movement funded by the wealthiest evil people with the goal to destroy marriage and family.”

Several of the speakers cited polls from the early 2000s showing women reporting lower levels of happiness relative to men than women did in the 1970s. No one mentioned the other polls that consistently find single women happier than married women.

If the unhappy women poll is in fact accurate, though, is it fair to blame feminists?

The best guesses for why women might be unhappy involve some version of the Second Shift problem that Arlie Hochschild identified: women don’t enjoy going to jobs and returning home to still do all the work traditionally assigned to women.

All such polls prove is that women changed while many male partners did not.

Every one of the esteemed speakers at the San Antonio Marriott holds bank accounts and credit cards in her name, and every one of them has taken advantage of the right to pursue good-paying jobs – all rights earned by our feminist grandmothers. They’re cynically – and cleverly – leveraging the American birthright assumption that all people, women included, have a right to happiness, conveniently forgetting, as usual, the “pursuit of” part of that phrase.

They prey on the fact that no one bothered to drill into the next generation that the fight for women’s equality as human beings was never going to be easy, nor was it going to end anytime soon.

My 48-hour bath in submissive-wife propaganda ended at the San Antonio airport just as Heidi Blake’s devastating report on the choke-rapist Tate brothers landed in my news feed. The article details years of violent abuse inflicted on dozens of digitally trafficked women, both in the United States and abroad, with a sickening degree of legal impunity. The porn entrepreneurs made millions from pay-per-view sex and a pyramid scheme of social media rape propaganda advising young men how to violently and psychologically force women to submit.

The Tates and their minions are, of course, the post-millennial inheritors of the Epstein class. They share their ideological forefathers’ profound contempt for women, their refusal – or incapacity – to view women as human, the same assumption of impunity, same obsession with manipulation and total control over women that we see in every one of Epstein’s interactions with his “girls.”

All you have to do is behold the worldwide influence and social and legal impunity of the rape-Tates to understand that women are in a war. A real war with real violence.

What TPUSA’s well-financed and slick influencers are selling to young women is the idea that they would be a lot happier if they had never had to fight at all. And the price of that attrition is abandoning efforts to earn one’s own living, choose when and with whom to have children, maintain financial independence, vote, or fully participate in the world outside the kitchen and bedroom.

They preach – literally, in speeches threaded with Biblical passages – that submission is the path to both happiness and spiritual salvation. They present feminism as rebellion against “God’s purpose” and the fountainhead of virtually every challenge women face today.

They do see a war, but their strategy involves a Christian soldier, fighting a very different kind of battle: an internal one devoted to molding herself to husband, childbirth and motherhood, and to crushing her own secret dreams because – although they never say this explicitly – it is simply too hard under current conditions to chase them.

It is certainly unfortunate, but hardly a coincidence, that the misogynistic and corrupt Trump administration propped up by TPUSA helped spring the Tate monsters and bring them back to America. The submissive wife movement is the performative, cross-wearing, milkmaid-dressed light side of the Epstein-class coin.

The young women in prairie mufti, chiffon baby doll dresses and cowboy boots do not hear a peep of objection from TPUSA. What they will hear are Bronze Age admonitions to endure, like this from Book of Genesis: “To the woman [God] said, “I will surely multiply your pain in childbearing; in pain you shall bring forth children. Your desire shall be contrary to your husband, but he shall rule over you.”

.Nina Burleigh is a journalist, author, documentary producer, and adjunct professor at New York University's Arthur L. Carter Journalism Institute. She has written eight books including her recently published novel, Zero Visibility Possible.


Florida Republicans Vow To Oust Student Leader Over 'Nazi Heaven' Group Chat

Florida Republicans Vow To Oust Student Leader Over 'Nazi Heaven' Group Chat

The Miami New Times reports that a local affiliate of the Florida Republican Party is begging the state party for permission to eject a secretary who created a racist group chat named “Nazi Heaven.”

Participants included some of the campus’ top conservative leaders: the county GOP secretary, Florida International University’s Turning Point USA chapter President Ian Valdes, and the former College Republicans recruitment chair. The school later told the Herald that the chat logs are now part of a criminal investigation.

“’Total N---- Death!’ wrote Dariel Gonzalez, a former board member of FIU’s College Republicans,” according to Miami New Times.

“In a different text, while discussing a Black student who reportedly left FIU’s College Republicans after being subjected to racial slurs, Gonzalez wrote that another member of the group ‘called her a n—— so she left,’” the Miami New Times reported.

The Miami Herald reported that “Miami-Dade County GOP secretary Abel Alexander Carvajal started the group chat primarily for conservative students last fall — and within three weeks it was filled with racist slurs. … In WhatsApp conversations leaked to the Miami Herald, participants used variations of the n-word more than 400 times, regularly described women as ‘whores,’ used slurs to talk about Jewish and gay people and mused about Hitler’s politics.”

The Floridian reported on Wednesday that the chat also included a message in which a participant allegedly enumerated “dozens of violent methods of killing Black people — including crucifixion, dissection, and beheading.

But now, following outcry, the Republican Party of Miami-Dade County has voted to request the 23-year-old’s resignation and remove him from his role.

In a statement posted to X on Thursday, Kevin J. Cooper, chairman of the Miami-Dade Republican Party, wrote: “We condemn in the strongest possible terms Abel Alexander Carvajal’s racist group chat. His words and actions are reprehensible and are completely inconsistent with the values of the Republican Party of Miami-Dade County. The words and actions of this individual does not speak for our Party.”

"The majority of our Party’s Board voted to request Carvajal’s resignation,” the post added. “We have commenced removal proceedings and look forward to resolution from the Republican Party of Florida.”

Reprinted with permission from Alternet

Grift Culture: Why MAGA Productions Can Keep Failing Forever As Art And Commerce

Grift Culture: Why MAGA Productions Can Keep Failing Forever As Art And Commerce


By any normal metric, the Turning Point USA “All-American Halftime Show” was a massive failure. At its peak, it had 6.1 million concurrent views, which might sound good until you learn that the actual NFL halftime show with Bad Bunny had 135 million based on preliminary reports. If that number holds, it will be the most-watched halftime show ever, knocking last year’s Kendrick Lamar show from the top spot.

An alternative that couldn’t even pull five percent of the real-time eyeballs affixed to the dreaded Bunny is not a success, full stop. iIn a normal world, immediately announcing that you were going to do it all over again in 2027 would be deeply odd and delusional.

But the pathetically low viewership doesn’t matter, because the point of the TPUSA halftime show was to gin up outrage over the real halftime show, not to create a well-produced, well-run, or well-performed event. And with so much right-wing money sloshing around, there is no pressure for anything like this to succeed. It just has to come into being.

Notably, the TPUSA show was also not a success as a show. It wasn’t filmed anywhere recognizable and ended up looking like the performers had wandered onstage at CPAC. Headliner Kid Rock’s lip-syncing was off. TPUSA head Erika Kirk couldn’t be bothered to attend. Not exactly a world-class event.

This was never a serious enterprise. Artists weren’t even finalized until a week before the Super Bowl, despite being announced in October. That sort of delay might have been fine if TPUSA had ultimately revealed some amazing heavy hitter, but instead it coughed up the infinitely washed-up Kid Rock and three other country singers who were in no way household names but did have the requisite MAGA grievance politics.

If anything, this haphazard slop shows a complete disregard and disdain for TPUSA fans, Kid Rock fans, and fans of the also-rans: a last-minute lineup, a shitty venue, and no actual broadcast rights. Just a hastily assembled, low-rent event whose purpose was not to provide people with quality entertainment but to serve as a way to howl about Bad Bunny.

Nonetheless, there is an impressive level of post-show flop sweat as conservatives try to tell themselves what a massive success this thing was. Far-right activist Jack Posobiec declared the event was the number one YouTube livestream of all time in various categories and that Kid Rock’s hot new release passed Bad Bunny on iTunes, but without any, you know, proof.

But by midday on Monday, Posobiec was bragging that somehow 40-50 million people watched the thing on some combination of live and streaming and platforms and whatever and therefore, as Posobiec said, “VOTED WITH THEIR REMOTE CONTROLS LAST NIGHT.”Except that is obviously not true. Even if somehow 40-50 million people really did tune in to see Kid Rock beclown himself, it didn’t make a dent in the official halftime show numbers. There was no mass voting via remote control, with people clicking away from Bad Bunny. Instead, it appears that Bad Bunny put up the biggest halftime numbers ever.

This is clearly some self-soothing for Posobiec, but it isn’t really necessary. The money will always be there for next year’s alternative halftime show, because TPUSA had revenue of $85 million in 2024 alone. Under Charlie Kirk, the group raised $389 million from 2012 to 2023, and conservative billionaires just love to give the group money. Even the existence of the alternative halftime show was a fundraising opportunity.

At first glance, the MAGA entertainment world seems similar to the closed world of evangelical entertainment that has been around for decades. However, that stuff is actually popular, albeit with a limited market. It’s telling that TPUSA didn’t pull any of those high-profile Christian recording artists, who arguably would be aligned with TPUSA’s values. Instead, they got a has-been who has a song bragging about statutory rape and some Nashville denizens whose phones aren’t ringing as much as they used to.

The right having such a tremendous amount of money warps the incentives here. No one needs to put on a good show. No one needs to get good ratings. External metrics are meaningless because the point was not to actually dethrone the NFL halftime show, a ludicrous proposition even if TPUSA had landed big performers. The point was just to be angry, to scream about Bad Bunny, and to offer a tepid, half-assed alternative that conservatives are forced to pretend was terrific.That’s true of Bari Weiss at CBS just as much as here. Normally, coming in and having your ratings immediately nosedive and making weird choices to put yourself on camera despite being not at all good at it would be serious missteps for a new leader.

But Weiss isn’t there to do good work. She’s there to push a right-wing agenda. And when she isn’t doing that, she’s got the most low-rent material imaginable, like putting her sister on air to talk about a random Free Press piece.It’s also true of Melania, the documentary that was really just a way for Jeff Bezos to bribe the president. Bezos spent $40 million to make the thing and another $35 million on advertising. Eager conservatives with smaller pocketbooks then had their own opportunity to suck up to Trump by purchasing massive amounts of tickets to artificially prop up sales.

But those moves only work one time, so sales for the second week of this epic tale dropped 67 percent. As with the TPUSA halftime show, there’s an attempt to pretend the film is an actual real piece of art and that people really want to see it, but why bother? The film has already served its dual purposes: letting Trump know just how far Bezos will go to curry favor and giving conservatives talking points about how Real America craves this sort of thing.

At best, this stuff is a waste of time, at worst, pure propaganda. But so many people behind it are in such an insular world that they have convinced themselves that everyone shares their fixations. Normally, that insularity would be pierced by the consistent failures of these projects, but with all that sweet right-wing cash, that never happens. These folks will continue making rage bait for each other, all the while telling themselves they are speaking to the majority of Americans.

Reprinted with permission from Daily Kos

Massive Backlash Surging Against MAGA's 'Hard-Edged Right-Wing Culture'

Massive Backlash Surging Against MAGA's 'Hard-Edged Right-Wing Culture'

President Donald Trump drew widespread criticism after forwarding, on his Truth Social platform, an overtly racist, AI-generated video depicting former President Barack Obama and former First Lady Michelle Obama as apes. Much of the criticism came from a combination of liberals, progressives, centrist Democrats and right-wing Never Trump conservatives, yet there was some outcry in MAGA World as well.

Sen. Tim Scott (R-SC) called the video out, and a frustrated 2024 Trump voter from New Mexico called C-SPAN and lamented, "I voted for the president; I supported him. But I really want to apologize. I mean, I'm looking at this awful picture of the Obamas. What an embarrassment to our country. All this man does is tell lies. He is not worthy of the presidency. He takes bribes blatantly, and now he’s being a racist blatantly."

A few days after that, Puerto Rican reggaetón star Bad Bunny performed en español at Sunday's 2026 Super Bowl Half Time Show — much to Trump's chagrin — and the event enjoyed way more viewers than Turning Point USA's alternative halftime show, headlined by Kid Rock. According to CBS News, 135 million viewers watched Bad Bunny; the El Paso Times reports that 6.1 million people watched Turning Point's event.

During a conversation for The New Republic's podcast posted on February 9, host Greg Sargent (formerly of the Washington Post) and NR reporter Alex Shephard stressed that between the "backlash" to the racist video and all the viewers who watched Bad Bunny, it's obvious that many Americans are rejecting MAGA's view of the world.

Shephard told Sargent, "I think that one of the big shifts is that there was this idea in the last election — 'Let Trump be Trump' — sort of pushed by Susie Wiles in particular, currently the chief of staff. That, essentially, the president knows best and that what he's doing may seem kooky and off the wall and irrelevant to politics as usual — but pursuing that kind of stuff is what people like about him, and you should just let him do it…. I think what we’re starting to see now is an increased willingness for politicians to call this kind of stuff out."Shephard argued, however, that even with the "backlash," Trump is still going to say and do offensive things.

Shephard told Sargent, "I think that we're not even close to seeing the bottom here yet, but it's really, really starting to break…. But the truth of the matter is that if they go anywhere, they're met with massive public resistance and backlash. You see it at the Grammys. You see it at the Super Bowl. You see it in the streets of Minneapolis. You see it all over the country. And I think there was this brief moment where it seemed like we were entering into a kind of 'new era' defined by hard-edged, right-wing culture, and that everything had changed. And all of that power that they had a year ago? It's just already gone now."

Reprinted with permission from Alternet

Shop our Store

Headlines

Editor's Blog

Corona Virus

Trending

World