Dominion Lawsuit Exposed Fox Propaganda, But Accountability Still Waits
WILMINGTON, DELAWARE – Fox News today opted to settle with Dominion Voting Systems in order to avoid a drawn-out, embarrassing trial over the network’s lies about the 2020 election. But no amount of money can erase the ruinous reputational damage to Fox from months of pretrial filings.
Just as the long-awaited trial over Dominion Voting Systems’ $1.6 billion lawsuit was set to move to opening statements, the proceedings unexpectedly paused for several hours. Upon returning to the courtroom, the judge announced a settlement.
“The parties have resolved the case,” Judge Eric M. Davis told the jury, thanking them for their service that day. “Without you, the parties would not have been able to resolve their situation.”
The trial presented a rare moment of accountability for Fox -- and perhaps the greatest threat to the network since its founding. Fox has steadily amassed power and profit over the last several decades, using virulent rhetoric, unhinged commentary, and baldfaced fabrications to create a media juggernaut with expansive influence over the conservative movement, the Republican Party, and the United States at large.
Fox hired a small army of lawyers to help defend what’s left of its honor but in the end decided that preemptively paying up was worth limiting further looks behind the curtain at the network.
But even without the trial, the network has been completely exposed for what critics like Media Matters have long shown that it is: a shameless Republican propaganda organ that prioritizes profit and politics over anything resembling journalistic ethics.
Dominion’s filings in the case, based on reams of internal network documents, text messages between Fox staffers, and depositions, have revealed that Fox executives, hosts, and producers knew at the time that the stolen election narratives the network peddled following the 2020 presidential election were false; that the network’s promotion of these conspiracy theories came amid internal fears that viewers would abandon Fox for its Trumpier competitors; that executives cracked down on “news” side staffers who tried to report facts about election fraud to the network audience; that network chief Rupert Murdoch and star host Tucker Carlson privately disparaged Trump; and that Murdoch effectively used the network as a super PAC to help Republican political candidates.
For Fox, there’s no way to reverse the public disclosure that the network’s employees are propagandists who knowingly lie to its viewers.
This isn't the first hit Fox has taken in recent years.
Reports of widespread sexual harassment at the network spurred the expulsions of co-founder Roger Ailes in 2016 and longtime star host Bill O’Reilly in 2017, among others.
Bigoted commentary and conspiracy theories by Tucker Carlson, SeanHannity, and Laura Ingraham drove major brands away from their prime-time broadcasts, leaving commercial breaks filled with ads for election denier Mike Lindell’s My Pillow company.
And Fox’s promotion of white nationalist conspiracy theories, its anti-vaccine advocacy, its fusion with Donald Trump’s White House, and its January 6 revisionism triggered wave after wave of damning headlines from other outlets that depleted the network’s mainstream credibility.
Dominion Lawsuit Still Poses A Threat To Fox’s Bottom Line
The embarrassing saga couldn’t have come at a worse time for Fox, which is currently negotiating or preparing to negotiate with three of its biggest carriers. As Media Matters President Angelo Carusone detailed on Twitter last week, the network hopes to jack up its already overpriced carriage rates in order to offset ad losses and boost profits.
\u201c2/ As the trial is happening, Fox News will be renegotiating or gearing up to renegotiate carriage renewal with 3 cable providers -- Xfinity, Chater and Cox.\n\nIt's hard to overstate how significant this and how potentially consequential this is for Fox News' future. Here's why...\u201d— Angelo Carusone (@Angelo Carusone) 1681440233
\u201c3/ The dirty secret is that Fox News is the only commercial tv channel that actually doesn't need a single adl. They could have $0 in ad revenue and they'd still have more than a 35% profit margin.\n\nThat's cuz Fox is the 2nd most expensive channel on every cable bill (ESPN is #1)\u201d— Angelo Carusone (@Angelo Carusone) 1681440233
\u201c5/ Now, Fox News is going to renegotiate these deals in with a lot of headwinds. Cable providers tightening belt due to cord cutting, Fox is in barrel PR wise due to Dominion trial and their audience is kind of tepid on them (something Fox need to pressure cable companies).\u201d— Angelo Carusone (@Angelo Carusone) 1681440233
\u201c6/Here's the thing: Fox doesn't just need to renew at the current rate. Oh no. The Murdochs have been promising to extract big increases from cable companies in order to offset ad loses and massively increase profits.\u201d— Angelo Carusone (@Angelo Carusone) 1681440233
\u201c7/ Cable companies already probably pay about 2x market value for Fox News in these fees (which is absurd). But now, Fox is going to go into these meetings...and say not only should cable companies continue overpaying, but that they pay increases of 30-35%.\u201d— Angelo Carusone (@Angelo Carusone) 1681440233
\u201c8/ There are about 90 million cable customers in this country. There are about 3 million regular Fox News viewers. Fox is not only forcing everyone with cable to overpay, but now they will try to pick Americans' pockets even more.\u201d— Angelo Carusone (@Angelo Carusone) 1681440233
\u201c9/ This is a real pivot point for Fox News. A genuine moment of potential accountability. If they are able to renew with the increases they're hoping to get, then well, Fox News will continue to have obscene profits, guaranteed revenue and no reason to change.\n\nBut...\u201d— Angelo Carusone (@Angelo Carusone) 1681440233
\u201c10/ If Fox meets resistance and the cable companies don't roll over and force everyone to overpay in order to subsidize Fox News (as they have been doing all these years), then Fox News quite literally can't continue it's current course. It would need to change.\u201d— Angelo Carusone (@Angelo Carusone) 1681440233
\u201c11/ If you want to know what you can do this in moment, I strongly recommend you visit https://t.co/Ez98Afaxqg\n\nThe website tells you how to contact the current providers talking to Fox and what to say.\u201d— Angelo Carusone (@Angelo Carusone) 1681440233
The Dominion lawsuit has also spurred shareholder actions against Fox Corp., Fox News’ parent company. Dominion’s filings suggest that Fox Corp. board members violated their fiduciary duty and top executives neglected their responsibilities, and the behavior seemingly flouts Fox Corp. shareholders’ understanding of responsible corporate governance, as Media Matters detailed. This breach has already resulted in at least one shareholder lawsuit against the Murdochs and other board members, and numerous law firms are also seeking plaintiffs. Fox’s settlement will not stop that process — it will put the company at risk of more shareholder lawsuits.
\u201cUnless Fox is willing to start settlement discussions at at least a couple billion, I just don\u2019t think this settles. \n\nAnd if Fox ends up settling this thing for a couple billion after all this, they will get buried in shareholder lawsuits. \n\nThere\u2019s just no good path for Fox.\u201d— Angelo Carusone (@Angelo Carusone) 1681691554
And looming beyond the Dominion settlement is an even larger $2.7 billion lawsuit against Fox from Smartmatic, another voting services company that suffered similar false attacks from the network following the 2020 election. In February, a New York state appeals court ruled against Fox’s motion to quash that lawsuit, raising the probability that it, too, could go to trial.
It’s a perfect storm for Fox, and all because the network’s malfeasance and depravity finally caught up to it.
Reprinted with permission from Media Matters.
- New Tapes: Trump Campaign Directed Bartiromo To Push January 6 (VIDEO) ›
- What To Do About Fox? Stop Treating It As A 'News' Organization ›
- Why Would Fox News Kill Democracy? For Money ›
- Newsflash: You Really Can't Trust Fox News Channel, Ever ›
- 'This Is Very Serious': Judge Sanctions Fox News In Dominion Lawsuit ›
- Judge Announces Settlement Of Dominion Lawsuit Against Fox News ›
- Murdochs Demand All Subscribers Cough Up Huge Increase In Fox Cable Fees - National Memo ›
- How Big Media Mogul Murdoch Steamrolled Little Tucker Carlson - National Memo ›
- Carlson: When They Say It's Not About Money, It's About Money - National Memo ›
- What Fox's Bret Baier Revealed About Himself In Texting With Carlson - National Memo ›
- 'Put Up Or Shut Up': Cyber Expert Asks Court To Enforce Lindell's $5 Million Forfeit - National Memo ›