Tag: anti-immigrant hate
Opposing Trump's Fascism, Pope Leo Wields Tactics Church Honed Against Communism

Opposing Trump's Fascism, Pope Leo Wields Tactics Church Honed Against Communism

A key part to the end of communism in Eastern Europe was the late Polish Pope John Paul II's decisive moral and spiritual role in a peaceful collapse. Pope Leo has now taken up that anti-authoritarian banner and is happy to bring it to MAGA.

Christopher Hale, who writes a Substack on Pope Leo, argued in his latest column that Pope John Paul II’s resistance to authoritarianism connects with Pope Leo XIV’s defense of immigrants and refusal to bend to President Donald Trump.

The message began when John Paul’s delivered his inaugural message in October 1978, telling those in St. Peter’s Square, “Do not be afraid. Open wide the doors for Christ. To his saving power open the boundaries of States, economic and political systems.”

Top communist leaders knew exactly what he meant, Hale said.

It was less than a year later that John Paul knelt and kissed the tarmac at Warsaw’s airport, Hale recalled. "That afternoon he celebrated Mass in Victory Square, a plaza the communists had renamed, before hundreds of thousands of Poles." A little over a year later, the Berlin Wall came down.

Pope Leo has taken up that same mantle and instead of confronting communism, he took on "the danger to human dignity [that] wears a red hat and speaks the language of the right. Just as God raised up John Paul II behind the Iron Curtain to stand up to communism, God has raised up a pope from the Americas, from inside the walls of MAGA authoritarianism, to stand up to it," said Hale.

In his first year in office, Leo, the first American pope, is using his position to urge Americans to uphold the value of loving their neighbor.

In a June letter, Leo said defending life includes “welcoming, protecting and assisting immigrants.” The writer contrasts that language with Trump’s warning about a communist threat involving newcomers. The pope who opposed communism also welcomed immigrants, wrote Hale, while Trump invokes communism to cast suspicion on them.

Meanwhile, the Trump administration is sounding the alarm that the communists are coming. The 21st century's "red scare" has been a huge part of Trump's 2026 election message. During his speech at Mount Rushmore, Trump claimed there is “a resurgence of the communist menace in our land, including from newcomers to our country.”

Hale pointed out how uniquely inverted that statement is from the pope's.

While the president desperately wanted Pope Leo to attend some of the America 250 events, His Holiness spent the day with the migrants of Lampedusa, a small island off the coast of Sicily. They have been experiencing an influx of migrants fleeing poverty, war and persecution.

Leo recalled the biblical parable of the Good Samaritan: “before any intellectual consideration or ideological conviction, the encounter with those who lie before us, stripped of everything, calls us to be close to them.”

Back home, the Pentagon brought in Cardinal Christophe Pierre to lecture on the pope's language, which some saw as anti-Trump. Leo hasn't been deterred, much less intimidated.

Leo has refused to trade moral independence for whatever political access he's been promised.

Hale closed his column by concluding that Catholics should recognize that resistance to MAGA authoritarianism is also a defense of human dignity, and far from a departure from their faith. While Pope John Paul II offered encouragement, Pope Leo XIV is speaking plainly to power while reminding Americans that welcoming the vulnerable is a responsibility, not a weakness.

Reprinted with permission from AlterNet

France's Rioting Has Nothing To Do With Immigrants -- And Everything To Do With Prices

France's Rioting Has Nothing To Do With Immigrants -- And Everything To Do With Prices

Polls being what they are, Republicans and their supporters must be feeling a bit like the condemned Frenchmen who rode to the guillotine during the Reign of Terror. It's fitting, then, that they are seizing on unrest in France as a desperate campaign gambit. "The Riots in France Are a Warning for America," declared The Federalist. And what is the lesson? "Mass immigration will split your country in two, and the two sides will eventually go to war."

Rep. Keith Self, chairman of the Foreign Affairs subcommittee on Europe, had the script down pat:

"They've been allowing this to happen for years and years, so they are reaping what they sowed. ... We're also trying to get a handle on our mass migration consequences, just like France should have done years ago. That's why I say this is a lesson to America. We are watching the future of America in France and the U.K., frankly."

So did Speaker Mike Johnson:

"France is descending into chaos because they wanted OPEN BORDERS — just like the socialist Democrats in America. What we are witnessing is a chilling warning for all Americans of what happens if the radical Marxist insurgent left gets their way."

JD Vance warned that "This is the future congressional Democrats seek for your country."

Naturally, President Donald Trump picked up the baton, telling reporters that the French protests were about "immigration, not schools," and posting:

"France is burning! The immigration of people from an entirely different world, people with hatred in their hearts, has shattered that once great country. Close your Borders and take control, before it is too late!"

Back in reality, there is no evidence that the French protests and riots have anything at all to do with immigration. There has been Islamist violence in France over the years, perpetrated by immigrants or children of immigrants, perhaps most famously the attack on the Paris offices of the magazine Charlie Hebdo in 2015 and the horrific Nice truck attack the following year that killed 86.

But that's not what's happening today, and no desperate eagerness by American Republicans to hijack these protests for their flailing campaigns can change that. There is no data on the ethnicity or color of the thousands of people arrested in the past week — France doesn't keep such records. Students in the Paris suburbs were protesting for weeks before the violence started. Similar protests have spread to Lyon, Marseilles, Lille, Bordeaux, and many other smaller cities and rural areas — and so did the violence. What originated with students protesting poorly equipped high schools expanded to farmers and labor unions.

Some of the rioters are dissolute young men who were itching to pick a fight with the police, but the original demonstrators were students complaining about the long-running underfunding of French schools. Others who joined are furious about the price of gasoline and diesel, and the high cost of living in general. So a more likely cause of the unrest in France isn't immigration but Trump's half-baked decision to attack Iran without buy-in from Congress. In fact, the high cost of fuel and associated inflation is causing unrest in other European countries including Italy, Portugal, Belgium and Albania. (The Albanians were already displeased by a corruption scandal linked to a resort development project by Jared Kushner and Ivanka Trump.)

The protests in France do bear a lesson for the United States, but it's not the one the GOP prefers. France has a weakness for a la barricade. Princeton's David A. Bell quotes an old saying: "While the United States has three branches of government, France has four: the executive, the legislative, the judiciary, and the street." In 2018, the country was nearly paralyzed by the gilets jaunes (yellow vests) protests over fuel taxes. But today's protests and riots are different. They have an end-of-an-era feel.

People are demanding better services and lower prices but are unwilling to make the trade-offs those things demand. France's finances are in terrible shape, the effect of low growth and high spending on entitlements. France has been a poor place to start a business for decades. A 2012 "millionaire's tax" failed and was abandoned.

Efforts to deal with the crushing burden of pensions for the elderly — for example, Emmanuel Macron's push to raise the retirement age from 62 to 64 — have been met with fierce resistance. France has been borrowing to cover its costs, but the bond markets are having their say, charging France more to borrow than Italy or Greece. France now spends more to service its debt than it spends on defense or education. And because America is stepping back from global leadership, the demands on France's budget for defense will only increase.

Lenders take account not just of a country's debt to GDP ratio but also its political stability and likelihood to repay its debts. When you look at France, you see rising support for Marine Le Pen, a right-wing extremist who is as soft on Putin as she is tough on immigrants. But on the important matter of France's fiscal health, she makes Trumpian promises of cutting aid to immigrants while promising to reverse Macron's increase in the retirement age. Swell. No hope of economic sanity there.

Over on the left, Jean-Luc Melenchon has made noises about repudiating part of France's debt, a fast road to Venezuelan-style collapse. There are more centrist candidates who offer more realistic reforms, but none seems to have political traction at this moment.

The United States is not, for a variety of reasons, in quite as bad shape economically as France, but the GOP, once supposedly the party that at least paid lip service to the problem of our national debt (are you out there, Paul Ryan?) has become utterly blithe about economic realities under Trump. Not only have his tariff and war policies raised prices, but his irresponsible tax cuts combined with ballooning spending have saddled us with unsustainable debt. Like France, we are now spending more on debt service than on defense.

Lenders, by nature or necessity an unsentimental bunch, don't seem to trust us more than they trust France to make sensible governing choices about taxes and spending. In fact, they trust us less. France is on fire, yet their 10-year bond yield only recently surpassed five percent, while as recently as last month we were being charged 5.2 percent. Potential lenders see a nation beclowned by repeated government shutdowns, threats to default on debt (by not raising the debt ceiling), and now in Trump 2.0, attacks on the integrity and independence of the Federal Reserve. It's impossible to say with specificity how threats to conquer Greenland, Iceland and Canada, the reality of abandoning Ukraine and sucking up to Putin, and wild swings of tariff policy play into perceptions of U.S. stability, but it can't be reassuring.

The lessons from France have nothing to do with immigration and irrepressible civil war. The primary lesson is: Don't spend more than you earn. Don't elect idiots who know little of economic reality and care less. Don't impose inflation-triggering tariffs on your allies. Don't start wars you have no idea how to win. Don't tell yourself fairy tales about immigrants causing all your problems when you fail at the most basic tasks of governing.


At GOP Midterm Fest, JD Vance Echoed Tucker Carlson’s Anti-Immigrant Slurs

At GOP Midterm Fest, JD Vance Echoed Tucker Carlson’s Anti-Immigrant Slurs

Vice President JD Vance used his keynote address to the GOP’s midterm convention to echo one of Tucker Carlson’s most infamous statements, just one week after publicly refusing to distance himself from the right-wing podcaster.

“Two years ago, we have to remember — our nation, ladies and gentlemen, was tired,” Vance told the attendees in Dallas on Thursday night. After citing factory closures and drug overdoses, he continued: “We were tired of seeing the cartels and the criminals given free rein over our great country. And we were tired of being called racist for noticing that our country was becoming dirtier and poorer and less safe and less prosperous.“

Who was “called racist” for suggesting “our country was becoming dirtier and poorer”? That would be Carlson, who declared that immigrants were the cause.

“Our leaders demand that you shut up and accept this,” Carlson told his Fox News audience during a December 2018 monologue. “We have a moral obligation to admit the world's poor, they tell us, even if it makes our own country poorer, and dirtier, and more divided. Immigration is a form of atonement.” He then aired footage of what he described as “an endless chain of migrant caravans” in Mexico.

Carlson’s statement that immigrants make the United States “poorer” is incorrect, and his claim that they make it “dirtier” was widely recognized as bigoted. More than two dozen companies dropped their ads on his show in response.

But Carlson refused to back down, repeatedly offering similar remarks and using his Fox show to mainstream other white nationalist tropes and talking points. And a few years later, an enterprising would-be GOP politician adopted the host’s language in a successful effort to win his favor.

On July 1, 2021 — the same day he announced his campaign for the U.S. Senate — Vance went on Carlson’s Fox program and told the host that he was running to ensure that his kids “live in the same great country that I lived in. And if we don't do something, if we don't fight back against what's going on in our country, they're going to lose it, they're going to grow up in a country that's much poorer, that's much dirtier, that's much uglier, and where they can't even speak their mind as citizens.”

Carlson fawned over Vance throughout the interview. “I probably shouldn't say this, I'm really glad you're doing it,” he said at its conclusion. “I admire you and I wish you luck, very much. Thank you for doing this. Congratulations.”

Vance would continue to mimic Carlson’s rhetoric on the host’s show, and Carlson in turn backed his Senate campaign on-air — and used his personal relationship with Donald Trump to convince Trump to endorse Vance. Two years later, he helped convince Trump to select Vance as his 2024 running mate.

Since then, Carlson has dived even further into the right-wing fever swamps. He became the nation’s most prominent 9/11 conspiracy theorist; declared that “the defining fact of our lives is that whites around the world are being eliminated”; warned frequently of the influence of “demons”; and hosted a notorious white nationalist and a Nazi apologist for friendly interviews. That last point has triggered calls on the right for Vance to disavow or distance himself from the man who helped cement his political career.

But instead, Vance used a September 3 White House press briefing to portray Carlson as merely a “friend” with whom he sometimes has “political disagreements,” and to attack his critics as un-American.

And last night, Vance gave a wink and a nod to Carlson and his audience on the biggest stage available to him.

Reprinted with permission from Media Matters

JD Vance

When JD Vance Calls Abdul El-Sayed 'Evil,' He Should Look In A Mirror

In a year when Democrats have the wind at their backs and a shot at winning even in Texas, primary voters in Michigan have chosen a Senate candidate in Abdul El-Sayed who needlessly alienates many voters. But of all the Republican politicians to criticize El-Sayed, JD Vance may be the least well suited, because when it comes to tolerance for extremism and antisemitism, Vance and El-Sayed are almost equally matched players in a dangerous, illiberal game. It's a mark of how far our guardrails have fallen that leading American political figures are engaging in more or less open race/religion baiting — and each is in high dudgeon that the other is doing it.

El-Sayed has waded into extremist waters a number of times, most prominently when he seemed to downplay the horror of an attempted attack on a Michigan synagogue. On March 12, Ayman Ghazali drove a truck, filled with fireworks and gasoline, into Temple Israel in West Bloomfield. The truck caught fire after it crashed through the doors. At the time, more than 100 students and some 50 staff were inside the religious school. One security guard was struck and injured, and more than 60 police and firemen were treated for smoke inhalation. Ghazali committed suicide by shooting himself.

El-Sayed condemned the attack, but a few days later, noting that relatives of the attacker had died in an Israeli air strike in Lebanon, El-Sayed equivocated, saying, "Hurt people hurt people."

If you think that Israel's actions in Lebanon justify or excuse in any way an attack on Jewish children in Michigan, you are missing something fundamental about liberal values. Would El-Sayed say the same if a Jewish American whose relatives had been killed by Hamas on Oct. 7 attempted to bomb a Muslim school?

In contrast to the MAGA style of politics, El-Sayed has apologized. Speaking to Michigan's Jewish Democratic Caucus, he said, "My comments may have been misconstrued to justify something I did not mean to justify. To anyone who feels like my comments might have been hurtful, I'm really sorry. That was not my intention."

Is he apologizing for the fact that others "misconstrued" his remarks? That is pretty weak tea as apologies go, but it's better than Vance's record, which we'll come to soon.

El-Sayed has a history of associating himself and his campaign with people who clearly cross the line, and has not apologized for doing so. What prompted him to invite Hasan Piker to campaign with him? Piker is an encyclopedia of offenses and idiocies. He thinks communist China and Cuba are great role models, excused Hamas for raping Israeli women, and invited a Vietnamese refugee who recounted her suffering to "Suck my d—k, old lady."

He calls critics "rabid, ultra-Zionist pigs," and lately has lapsed into the more-in-sorrow-than-in-anger mode of warning American Jews that if they "keep putting this idea out there that they are singularly invested in Israel, eventually someone is going to come around and take action — not against the state of Israel, mind you, but against American Jews."

That last one, in addition to holding Jews responsible for how others perceive them, is an invitation to antisemitic violence notionally veiled in concern. How would Piker react if someone were to warn that if Muslim Americans didn't stop supporting the Palestinians, "someone is going to come around and take action"?

El-Sayed isn't responsible for everything his supporters say, but Piker is a hateful extremist whose support El-Sayed sought — and he isn't the only one. El-Sayed also campaigned with Amir Makled, a progressive who has a history of pro-Hezbollah posts, and who has recirculated antisemitic memes — ironically, from right-wing figures Marjorie Taylor Greene and Candace Owens. Makled reposted a message from Owens calling Israelis "demons" who "lie, cheat, murder, and blackmail." There's nothing to unite extremists of the left and right quite like some undiluted antisemitism.

People often ask whether all criticism of Israel can be tarred as antisemitism. The answer is: Of course not. Israel merits condemnation for its unjust actions, as any nation does, and anyone who attempts to paint all criticism as antisemitism is doing no favors to Jews or to the truth. But when someone seems obsessed about Israel's sins but unbothered by those of China, Sudan, Hamas, Russia, or countless others, or when someone invites or excuses violence against American Jews, that clearly crosses the line.

Would that there were a responsible opposition to the Michigan Democrats who could, with integrity, rebuke El-Sayed. Alas, we have JD Vance. "I realize that there's something about Abdul El-Sayed that is very, very evil and on the rise in the United States of America today," Vance said last week. He's one to talk.

The company Vance keeps includes Tucker Carlson, whose obsession with Israel and Jews has become pathological. Even after Carlson's softball interviews with white nationalist antisemite Nick Fuentes (who also feuds with Vance, but that's a topic for another day) and Holocaust denier Darryl Cooper, whom Carlson praised as "the best and most honest popular historian in the United States," Vance refused to distance himself from Carlson.

Given the opportunity to do so at a White House press briefing Thursday, he demurred: "I'm not going to play the game where I throw friends under the bus because I have political disagreements with them. I think that is a terrible place for the U.S. to go."

Vance sees "pas d'ennemis a droite." So in October, when a bunch of Republican operatives were discovered to have exchanged texts calling black people "monkeys" and "watermelon people" and pronouncing "I love Hitler!" Vance was forgiveness itself. Appearing on the Charlie Kirk podcast, Vance explained that:

"The reality is that kids do stupid things, especially young boys. They tell edgy, offensive jokes. That's what kids do. And I really don't want us to grow up in a country where a kid telling a stupid joke, telling a very offensive, stupid joke, is cause to ruin their lives."

These "young boys" were in their 20s and 30s. Speaking of Kirk, after his assassination, Vance was unwilling to overlook youthful mistakes: "The First Amendment protects a lot of very ugly speech but if you celebrate ... Charlie Kirk's death, you should not be protected from being fired for being a disgusting person."

Some of the people whom the Trump/Vance administration targeted for punishment did not "celebrate" Kirk's murder but merely recalled that Kirk himself had offered to pay the lawyer who represented Paul Pelosi's attacker.

Even some on the right have pleaded with JD Vance to denounce the groypers and antisemites now proliferating in congressional offices and think tanks. Rod Dreher pinned his hopes on Vance to staunch the flow. Vance gave his answer at a Turning Point USA conference, when he denounced not antisemitism or bigotry but "endless, self-defeating purity tests."

Recall that among Vance's first official acts as vice president was a speech to the Munich Security Conference, where he lectured Germany. The mainstream parties had an informal "brandmauer" (firewall) agreement not to enter into coalition with the Alternative fur Deutschland, a party that is pro-Putin, anti-Ukraine, anti-Muslim, and had roots in the Nazi Party. It was quite a moment. The United States has long taken pride in having defeated the twin totalitarian menaces of the 20th century: fascism and communism. Yet here was an American vice president lecturing the Germans about freezing out the ideological descendants of the Nazis.

That endorsement of extremism and betrayal of our values was at least open and direct, but Vance is capable of more insidious incitement of hatred. It was Vance who circulated the atrocious lie about Haitian immigrants barbecuing people's pets. He has trafficked in false statistics about immigrants and crime, suggested that the high cost of housing was attributable to immigrants, and alleged recently that immigrants were responsible for the recent surge in antisemitism.

When he was criticized for the failed Memorandum of Understanding with Iran, which he had taken the lead in negotiating, Vance responded by alleging that "certain elements within the Israeli government" were running a "discreet, extremely well-funded" campaign to manipulate American public opinion against the agreement. He cited a Time magazine article as proof, but the article didn't support his contention at all; it was about an Israeli effort to push back against antisemitism among young, right-wing men. In any case, the charge of Jews secretly manipulating anything — the media, the banks, Hollywood, foreign policy — is classic antisemitism.

Vance's contribution to American politics is to leave a trail of suspicion and hatred in his wake like snail slime. He is the logical inheritor of the MAGA mantle.

The best that can be said about El-Sayed is that an unsatisfying apology is better than none at all and that he belongs to a party that still enforces some moral red lines. The fear is that if his style comes to dominate, that will cease to be true.

Mona Charen is policy editor of The Bulwark and host of the "Beg to Differ" podcast. Her new book, Hard Right: The GOP's Drift Toward Extremism, is available now.

Reprinted with permission from Creators

Shop our Store

Headlines

Editor's Blog

Trending

World