Tag: doj independence
Todd Blanche

The Most Urgent Impeachment Target Is Todd Blanche, Not Pete Hegseth

On Saturday, Donald Trump ordered the Justice Department to investigate members of Congress for the offense of proposing to impeach his attorney general and secretary of defense. He branded the talk “extortion at the highest level” and announced, “I am ordering the Department of Justice to look into this criminal act, immediately!”

We can expect the Department to fall into line dutifully, because Attorney General Todd Blanche has already demonstrated his eagerness to convert federal prosecution into a weapon against the president’s enemies, wielded without regard to the facts, the law, or the commission of any crime. He said as much yet again Sunday in an interview with CNN’s Dana Bash that should live on in infamy.

That practice stands atop the list of Trump 2.0’s manifold abuses of democracy and departures from constitutionalism and the rule of law. It follows that Blanche stands atop the list of Trump officials whom the incoming Democrats must aim to remove from office.

It is high time to impeach Todd Blanche.

With the House gavel in January comes a choice of priorities. This administration has repeatedly subverted the constitutional structure of checks and balances; bungled foreign policy, including through illegal misadventures, in ways that have profoundly undermined the national interest; and enriched the president and his allies at public expense.

These grievous offenses—all departures from the essential Article II command that the president “take Care that the Laws be faithfully executed”—require staunch investigation, oversight, and remedy. But the first order of business is to reaffirm the rule of law and democracy, and to strike back against the most virulent attacks on them.

The essential distinction that should lead Rep. Jamie Raskin (D-MD), the incoming House Judiciary Committee chair, and the new majority to vote out articles of impeachment against Blanche is between abuses of executive power on the one hand and the embrace of authoritarianism and the negation of the constitutional rule of law on the other.

For the last 20 months, the Department of Justice has gone well beyond flirting with authoritarianism. It has become an authoritarian enclave of government, full stop. The practices that Blanche has embraced do not happen in a democracy; they define authoritarian rule. Raskin, who has vowed to investigate Blanche, put it plainly: the Department of Justice has become “an instrument of revenge, political revenge for the president”

Representative Hank Johnson has stated the umbrella case: Blanche’s offenses, he says, “demand that he be impeached and convicted and removed from office.” The menu of possible articles runs long: championing Trump’s $1.776 billion IRS slush fund until senators made him kill it; illegal firings, including Maurene Comey’s, as a federal judge ruled last week; an early push, with his deputy Emil Bove—now, incredibly, a federal appellate judge—to ship immigrants out of the country in violation of Judge Boasberg’s order; a sit-down with Ghislaine Maxwell not long before she landed in a minimum-security camp.

Yet if I were drafting the articles, I’d opt to set aside for the time being all those horrendous abuses in the sycophantic service of Donald Trump and advance a single count: that Blanche has wielded the power of federal prosecution to punish the president’s enemies. The House impeached Trump himself on a single article in 2021.

As Vladimir Putin’s persecution of Alexei Navalny shows, a single instance defines a regime’s tyrannical character, and a single instance would justify impeachment and removal. With Blanche, we have a long and growing list: James Comey, three times over. Letitia James. Cassidy Hutchinson. The Six Democratic lawmakers.

A one-count article of impeachment reduces the overall firepower of the case against Blanche, but it trains Congress’s and the nation’s focus on reprisal prosecutions, the practice of Trump 2.0 that is the singular paradigm of authoritarianism. Four reasons make the reprisal count the right one.

First, reprisal prosecutions don’t merely abuse power; they violate the Constitution in and of themselves. The Supreme Court has called it “a due process violation of the most basic sort” to punish someone for doing what the law allows. When the charges are brought in retaliation for protected speech, as with Comey or the six Democratic lawmakers, the prosecution violates the First Amendment as well.

Second, reprisal prosecutions are designed to cow dissent more broadly. Blanche’s prominent targets—a former FBI director, a witness who testified to Congress about Trump’s actions on January 6, lawmakers who reminded troops of their duty to disobey illegal orders—cast a broad shadow over other political critics. Along with immiserating political adversaries, that is the point. Each case warns every potential critic, witness, and whistleblower to keep quiet or face criminal prosecution. And because a reprisal prosecution does its damage before any judge rules, and prosecutors enjoy absolute immunity from damages, the courts can’t undo it. Impeachment is the one remedy that reaches the responsible official.

Third, Blanche has combined his indulgence of autocracy with misrepresentations to the American people. He assured a national TV audience that the Justice Department would “prosecute without fear or any sort of favor. And that’s what every Department of Justice should do.” Precisely the opposite has been true: the Department has imposed fear on political enemies and favors on political friends. His Orwellian denial of the self-evident facts is itself strong proof that Blanche knows exactly the gravity of the transgressions he has greenlighted.

Fourth, and most important, prosecuting the leader’s enemies on manufactured or nonexistent charges is the bright line between democracy and autocracy. It’s the unmistakable mark of authoritarianism. And take no comfort that the prosecutions have so far failed. Kafka’s Josef K. never receives a verdict either; the process itself is the punishment.

Compare Blanche with Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth, whose impeachment Rep.Thomas Massie (R-KY) may force to a vote as early as this week. Massie’s eight articles charge Hegseth with waging war in Iran in defiance of the War Powers Resolution, with a strike that killed more than 150 people at a girls’ school in Minab, and with boat strikes that have killed at least 221 people and may well have been war crimes.

It’s an odious list that advances a strong case for impeachment. But it consists largely of abuses of democratic rule, not negation of it. Democracies aren’t immune from transgressing the law of war, and there is by now an extended history of military engagements that Congress never authorized. The core case against Hegseth is that he’s a flaming asshole, a terrible, arrogant secretary of defense whose tenure has sharply undermined the national interest. This is the man who boasted of “maximum lethality, not tepid legality.”

The exception proves the rule. Massie’s sixth article charges Hegseth with threatening Senator Mark Kelly with prosecution for telling service members they may refuse illegal orders. Of the eight counts, it’s the only one that smells of Moscow. And Blanche’s Justice Department took the next step: it tried to indict Kelly and five colleagues over that same video.

Now picture a Senate trial of Blanche on a single count of reprisal prosecutions. The charge is clean. There’s no obscuring or evading it.

What might Blanche possibly say in his own defense? That he never undertook reprisal prosecutions? Fat chance: he not only saluted and discharged the orders; he defended them publicly as a legitimate exercise of Trump’s Article II powers.

That Trump told him to? That’s the defense Lt. William Calley offered for My Lai during the Vietnam era, and the military courts rejected it: an order to do something plainly unlawful binds no one. Sorry, but Blanche isn’t a 24-year-old lieutenant in a jungle. He’s the attorney general, who swore to support and defend the Constitution, not to blindly obey the president.

In October 1973, when Richard Nixon ordered Elliot Richardson to fire Archibald Cox, Richardson resigned rather than comply, and William Ruckelshaus followed him out the door. That’s what an attorney general in a democracy does with an illegal order.

That he did it, but it was Trump’s right to order it? Blanche has tried that one before. He famously declined to pledge independence from the White House, saying “no attorney general should ever pledge that.”

In fact, no attorney general should ever pledge to follow a president blindly into the dark corner of reprisal prosecutions. To acquit Blanche on that ground, the Senate would have to ratify an authoritarian detour he engineered.

Nor would resignation save him. In 1876, Secretary of War William Belknap quit hours before the House vote; the House impeached him anyway, and the Senate tried him.

Conviction takes 67 votes. The Democrats will hold at least 54 seats, and up to 56 seats if Mary Peltola and Scott Colom pull it out in Alaska and Mississippi, which, as of this writing, is the way both races are trending. Lisa Murkowski is the only remaining Republican Senator who voted to convict Trump in 2021. Murkowski also voted against Blanche’s confirmation.

A conviction is by no means assured, but neither can it be completely ruled out. There will be 19 Republican Senators in cycle in the next Congress. Standing by Blanche, who after Trump has done more than anyone to corrupt the rule of law, may be bad politics and, if they privately believe Blanche should be removed, a failure of principle. Either way, a trial would lay the record before the country.

The American system has absorbed many abuses of power and strains on the rule of law under Trump 2.0. The criminal prosecution of innocent people because they are the president’s political enemies is something else: not a strain but a break. Justice without fear or favor—the Department’s own maxim—is no mere aspiration. It is the sine qua non of the rule of law. The new Congress’s first responsibility should be to reject Blanche’s crass and corrupt embrace of the rule of tyrants.

Harry Litman is a former United States Attorney and the executive producer and host of the Talking Feds podcast. He has taught law at UCLA, Berkeley, and Georgetown and served as a deputy assistant attorney general in the Clinton Administration. Please consider subscribing to Talking Feds on Substack.

The Only Promise Todd Blanche Can Honestly Make Is More Dishonesty

The Only Promise Todd Blanche Can Honestly Make Is More Dishonesty

Todd Blanche was Donald Trump's personal attorney, so it was natural that when he was elevated to attorney general, a journalist asked whether he would "pledge that the Justice Department will always act independently of the White House?"

The correct answer to such a question is obvious: The Justice Department and I are committed to the impartial administration of justice. We will always make prosecution decisions based solely upon the facts and the law after a fair evaluation of the evidence.

But Blanche said something a little different:

"No, I'm not going to pledge that. And no attorney general should ever pledge that. The president, I mean, if I were to pledge I will be independent of the White House, what that means is that if President Trump says, 'I want the Department of Justice to go after every violent criminal in this country,' which is what he has said, what you're saying to me is I should say, 'No, sir, I'm not going to do it.'"

What jumps out first about Blanche's answer is the blithe refusal even to mouth (however disingenuously) the expected platitude. This is the Trumpian way. They don't just break the rules behind closed doors; they shatter the rules in broad daylight. It's not enough, for example, that the Trump Justice Department is denying resources to the team that investigates and prosecutes foreign corrupt practices; Trump issued an executive order pausing all such prosecutions. So it's not news that Trump's new attorney general will fail to seek impartial justice, but the refusal to even feign regard for impartial justice is new.

The substance of Blanche's justification is also fatuous. Pledging to act independently of the White House doesn't mean acting in every instance in direct opposition to the president. That's absurd and it's not what independence requires. Nor could the president order the attorney general to "go after every violent criminal in this country," since more than 98% of violent crimes are state offenses, not federal ones, and in any case the combined forces of the state and federal governments don't have the resources to go after every violent criminal.

So much for deflection. The coffee-spitting moment came later, when Blanche was asked whether he would carry out an order that "crossed a legal or ethical line" and he proclaimed, "The president will never ask me to do something unethical or legal — or illegal. He never has. He never will."

Let's let the Freudian slip pass, but in fact the president had demanded that the Justice Department do something unethical that very week — namely, reconsider the decision to drop spurious vandalism charges against David Hearn. Jeanine Pirro's own motion to the court acknowledged that the original indictment was based upon false information provided by the Department of the Interior.

Nevertheless, Trump fumed that Pirro had "choked." This week, we learned that she was convening a special grand jury for some unknown purpose. If I were Hearn, I'd keep my lawyer close.

And that perversion of justice is only a ripple in the flood of plainly politicized acts and forbearances by this administration. This is a president who sent a DM to his attorney general demanding the prosecution of his political opponents. It's hard to think of how you could more comprehensively upend the idea of blind justice.

Trump's apologists do have a valid point when they note that the Manhattan district attorney's case against Trump in the Stormy Daniels case was also a form of lawfare. I said at the time that the case was flimsy and almost certainly would never have been brought if Trump were not the target. Trump's flagrant lawbreaking did present a quandary: How do you hold him responsible for his crimes without unintentionally validating the idea in the minds of his supporters that all justice is corruptly motivated?

There are no easy answers. Still, the Bragg prosecution was a local case, not the federal government seeking to punish a political foe. Ditto for the civil case Letitia James brought. At the federal level, Attorney General Merrick Garland was actually extremely reluctant to pursue federal charges against Trump despite the gravity of his conduct before and on January 6. It was only after Trump announced his reelection bid that Garland felt compelled to appoint a special prosecutor (precisely to avoid the appearance of a conflict of interest).

Nor is it the case that President Joe Biden's administration used the Justice Department to settle political scores. To repeat, Garland was widely criticized for moving slowly against Trump's obvious lawbreaking in the Mar-a-Lago documents case as well as the January 6 insurrection. One can understand his hesitation.

One administration prosecuting another opens the possibility of a dangerous tit-for-tat, but whatever your view about the wisdom of going slow against Trump, it's preposterous to "whatabout" this. Under Garland's leadership, the department brought indictments against Rep. Henry Cuellar, Sen. Bob Menendez, Rep. T.J. Cox, Illinois Speaker Michael Madigan, Mayor Eric Adams (and we know how that turned out when Trump returned), Mayor Andrew Gillum, and Hunter Biden — all Democrats.

Trump's second-term Department of Justice, by contrast, has been a nonstop cavalcade of corruption, featuring blatantly political prosecutions, attempted prosecutions or investigations of Jerome Powell, Lisa Cook, Mark Kelly, Miles Taylor, Christopher Krebs, James Comey, "sandwich guy," Adam Schiff, Letitia James, Kilmar Abrego Garcia, Alex Padilla, John Brennan, John Bolton, Sean Dunn, Ras Baraka, Jacob Frey, anti-ICE protesters in Minnesota including the widow of Renee Good, and many more.

Biden made poor decisions in pardoning his family at the end, but that was trivial compared with the mass pardons for the January 6 criminals, the pardons for cronies, donors, other corrupt public figures, the firings of any official who participated in the January 6 or Mar-a-Lago investigations, the kid-glove treatment for Ghislaine Maxwell, and of course, the putrid attempt to create a $1.7 billion slush fund for so-called victims of lawfare along with a get-out-of-jail-free card for Trump and his insatiable family regarding past tax evasion.

The aptly named Blanche (because he should, but doesn't, blush) was along for all of it. He personally visited Maxwell in prison and has yet to provide an explanation for that highly unusual visit, nor for her promotion to a more comfortable prison. He was at the Department of Justice as 3,400 lawyers resigned in protest rather than engage in the kinds of unethical and unprofessional conduct Pam Bondi and Blanche were demanding. He has defended with a straight face James Comey's indictment for threatening the president with an Instagram photo of seashells.

This ethical flexibility was enough to make even some Republican senators hesitate about confirming him. But in the end, all but Collins and Murkowski voted yes, presumably because they fear that if it's not Blanche it will be someone even worse. Thus does Trump extort his party — by threatening to get even dirtier.

But this tactic only succeeds because of learned helplessness by Republican office holders. In fact, when Trump gets pushback, he backs down. Ask Iran. Or consider the first utterly horrific attorney general candidate he proposed, Matt Gaetz. Enough Republicans balked that Trump withdrew his name. He didn't nominate someone even worse after that (admittedly a tall order). He went with Pam Bondi, a smidge less awful.

It seems the tactic of standing up to Trump is just crazy enough to work. But, no, the GOP has not learned that lesson. They've chosen spinelessness instead, and even after a decade of this, I still cannot understand why.

Mona Charen is policy editor of The Bulwark and host of the "Beg to Differ" podcast. Her new book, Hard Right: The GOP's Drift Toward Extremism, is available now.

Reprinted with permission from Creators


Shop our Store

Headlines

Editor's Blog

Trending

World