Tag: doug burgum
Forced Retreat From Reflecting Pool Case Didn't Make Hero Of Unethical Pirro

Forced Retreat From Reflecting Pool Case Didn't Make Hero Of Unethical Pirro

It’s hard to imagine a more consummate and humiliating debacle than the complete retreat that the Department of Justice was forced to execute in the Reflecting Pool case.

It would loom even larger if the Department’s reputation were not already in tatters. Having staked a large portion of its remaining credibility on the charges against David Hearn, the 67-year-old former Olympic canoeist whom her office had accused of vandalizing the Reflecting Pool, U.S. Attorney Jeanine Pirro was reduced on Friday evening to confessing, in a twenty-page filing, that its whole theory was false: the Lincoln Memorial Reflecting Pool had been ruined not by vandals but by the administration’s own botched, rushed renovation.

Some observers gave the DOJ credit for belatedly doing the right thing, taking Pirro at her word: diligent prosecutors misled by a careless sister agency, who moved to dismiss the moment they learned the truth. In fact, Pirro had zero choice. A grenade had been hurled into her office, and she was forced to fall on it. No points here for virtue.

Pirro’s motion did not just fold quietly. It took the Interior Department to task for withholding what it knew, insisting that had the agency “been forthcoming with the information clearly in its possession, the government would not have sought a grand jury indictment.” And it repudiated the prosecution’s own theory, conceding that the damage “was the result of a botched installation and not vandalism,” and that “it is difficult to attribute the widespread damage to the Reflecting Pool to vandalism, let alone to establish that fact beyond a reasonable doubt.”

Pirro even put herself crosswise with the president, a friend and ally since the 1980s, who to this hour insists the pool was slashed with knives and box cutters and wants the case pressed. “I disagree 100% with Jeanine Pirro,” Trump fumed on Truth Social. “I don’t know what she was thinking?” For a prosecutor who has spent this administration as one of Donald Trump’s most reliable instruments, dismissing his pet case and blaming his renovation looks like a rare act of conscience.

The move that forced Pirro’s hand was the receipt of documents from the Department of the Interior demonstrating that the pool’s lining was peeling because of a rushed, failed installation—in other words, not because David Hearn tugged at a flap of it. That revelation is classic Brady material: evidence that supports the defendant’s innocence. Such material has to be turned over to the defense right away. Pirro’s own motion piously recites the point, reminding the court that “prosecutors have an affirmative obligation pursuant to Brady v. Maryland“ to produce such evidence to the defense—which takes some nerve, given that the reason she was writing was that the Brady bomb had just gone off in her hands.

So once those documents surfaced, Pirro found herself, like Odysseus, between Scylla and Charybdis. She could dismiss on her own terms, spinning the story as diligent prosecutors misled by a careless agency. Or she could turn the material over to Hearn’s lawyers and let them present it to Judge Todd Edelman—a former career public defender who, a week earlier, had already warned the government it was “operating at its own peril” in the case. Handed the Interior documents, he would have blown his top and dismissed the indictment himself, and potentially referred Pirro for disciplinary proceedings to her state bar.

Pirro’s hand was forced. The dismissal was not an unlikely visitation of virtue. It was damage control and cutting her losses. Her motion nonetheless drapes the retreat in principle, reciting that under “the Department of Justice’s Principles of Federal Prosecution, a criminal prosecution should only be maintained if the defendant ‘will more likely than not be found guilty beyond a reasonable doubt by an unbiased trier of fact and that the conviction will be upheld on appeal.’” She invokes the Department’s high charging standard as though walking away were an act of conscience rather than the only move left on the board.

Pirro’s immediate surrender served other, self-interested purposes. The prosecution was already so slapdash and improper that it raised the prospect of two looming train wrecks. The hasty dismissal is designed to avoid them both. We should hope some reckoning is still ahead.

The first is the distinct prospect of yet another gross impropriety in the grand jury. Hearn filed a motion on July 27, alleging that the government failed to present the grand jury with any evidence of damages. The administration had elevated what elsewhere were misdemeanor charges to a felony on the strength of a single statutory element: $1,000 or more in damage. Yet it apparently had no proof to offer of that amount of damages, or any amount. It is no different from charging a felon in possession and never introducing evidence of the gun.

And the hole was not incidental; the grand jurors saw it themselves. They questioned the government’s witness about the cost of the damage, and he could not quantify it. He testified, moreover, that the repairs would have been necessary regardless of anything Hearn did—the pool was already leaking more than a million gallons of water a week, its expansion joints past their service life, the liner already torn.

On that record, the grand jury somehow returned a felony indictment. Hearn accordingly moved for the full transcript and the instructions the jurors were given—a motion that, if granted, would have exposed how the prosecution steered a grand jury to a felony it had no evidence to support, and whether DOJ had once again committed misconduct behind those closed doors. Dismissing the case makes the question go away. For now.

The second glaring problem Pirro may hope to circumvent is her own flagrantly unethical conduct. When the indictment came down on July 2, Pirro did not let the charging document speak for itself, as DOJ norms require. She called a news conference and went well outside the record. “This is not only a priority for the president, but for myself,” she announced—publicly welding her office to Trump’s political grievance—and vowed, “We will prove beyond a reasonable doubt that Hearn willfully destroyed property at the Lincoln Memorial Reflecting Pool.” For good measure, she added that she had witnesses who saw him pull the lining up and destroy it, and that he faced up to ten years.

Making prejudicial, extrajudicial statements about a defendant is improper in itself, because it can taint the jury pool. It violates both DOJ policy and the state ethics rules that bind prosecutors. But it is far worse when the out-of-school statements are, as these sure now seem to be, whopping lies. A bar complaint over her handling of the Hearn case has already been filed in New York. Pirro can hope the spotlight on her conduct dims now that she has dismissed the case behind a skein of bromides about the Department’s high standards and the diligence of her prosecutors. She should not get that reprieve.

Which brings us to the telling gaps in Pirro’s own motion. Her defense, in essence, is that Interior misled her—that had she known the truth, she never would have charged. The first question that provokes is how the hell she rushed through a felony indictment without first checking with the responsible agency about the actual evidence.

And Interior does not concede that it left her in the dark. Interior Secretary Doug Burgum took to social media to contradict her outright, insisting his department “provided the U.S. Attorney’s office expert and eyewitness testimony to the damage done by vandals and provided every piece of evidence they asked for.” So the two arms of the government are now blaming each other in public—Pirro says Interior stiffed her; Interior says it handed her everything. It hardly matters which is lying: either way, Pirro charged a man with a felony she could not support.

And what about the witnesses she assured the public had seen Hearn tear up the pool? If they existed and were prepared to say he caused the widespread damage, they were prepared to perjure themselves—the government’s own records show that damage predated Hearn by weeks. So is the Department pursuing them? Were they friendly partisans, massaged into saying what the case required? Or did they never exist at all? The dismissal aims to bury those inconvenient, glaring questions.

A pedantic aside that I can’t resist. Pirro’s motion complains that Interior gave her office “less than fulsome” information—using “fulsome” to mean abundant. That usage has become common enough that the dictionaries now grudgingly allow it, but the older and better meaning is nearly the opposite: excessive to the point of being offensive or insincere, as in fulsome praise or fulsome flattery (more on the etymology of the word here). And that sense is almost too perfect here, because it was precisely the fulsome reinforcement of Trump’s false talking point—the swaggering, the boasts of tremendous evidence, the ten years—that produced this injustice in the first place.

All of this bluster and sloppiness gives the episode an element of farce. There is a Keystone Cops quality to the whole affair: Burgum insisting he could “absolutely” prove vandalism from the drained pool’s photographs, a president raving about a 300-foot slit cut with a box cutter, a U.S. Attorney promising tremendous evidence—all of it collapsing into a filing that concedes the pool fell apart due to the administration’s own botched renovation.

But the farce shouldn’t obscure the gravity—perhaps the purest instance of totalitarian abuse of the Trump years: the government cast a private citizen with no quarrel with Trump and no connection to the pool as the villain of a fiction, and moved to put him in prison for years.

The leader tells a lie everyone knows is a lie, and the machinery of the state sets about forcing the rest of us to repeat it, all the way to felony prosecution of a totally innocent bystander. That is what makes it the most perfectly Kafkaesque prosecution I can remember outside of the annals of fiction.

David Hearn went for a bike ride, stopped to touch a flap of coating that was already peeling, and put it back when a park employee asked him to. For that, the government of the United States tried to take ten years of his life. He is owed more than a dismissal. He is owed an apology—and the rest of us are owed an accounting of how the Justice Department came to be a willing and corrupt instrument of the president’s vanity.

Harry Litman is a former United States Attorney and the executive producer and host of the Talking Feds podcast. He has taught law at UCLA, Berkeley, and Georgetown and served as a deputy assistant attorney general in the Clinton Administration. Please consider subscribing to Talking Feds on Substack.

Reprinted with permission from Talking Feds.

Comical Feud Erupts Between Pirro And Burgum Over Reflecting Pool Fiasco

Comical Feud Erupts Between Pirro And Burgum Over Reflecting Pool Fiasco

U.S. Attorney for the District of Columbia Jeanine Pirro, who is now feuding with Interior Secretary Doug Burgum over his role in failed prosecutions for the alleged vandalism of the Lincoln Memorial Reflecting Pool, previously touted Burgum as a “straight shooter” and endorsed him to become Donald Trump’s 2024 running mate in her prior role as a Fox News host.

Pirro said that Trump’s pick would come down to one of JD Vance, Marco Rubio, and Burgum during a discussion of his vice presidential shortlist on the June 6, 2024, edition of Fox panel show The Five.

“Trump actually got more Hispanic votes in Florida than Rubio did,” she said. “And you know, JD Vance is good but I really think it's Burgum. I do.” Noting that she had “met him several times,” she claimed that “there's something about him that he just seems like a straight shooter.”

Two years later, Pirro, who was once described by her own executive producer as “nuts” and a “reckless maniac,” is no longer a Fox host — she’s a top federal prosecutor. And rather than a “straight shooter,” she now reportedly thinks Burgum is “an incompetent liar.”

Pirro slammed the Interior Department in her motion to dismiss charges on Friday against David Hearn — the only person to face a felony charge over damage to the Reflecting Pool — effectively blaming Burgum’s agency for both slow-walking the production of evidence showing the damage “was the result of flawed installation by the contractor … and the rush to complete the project” rather than of vandalism.

Since her decision undermined Trump’s previous claims that the damage had been the work of “Deranged Vandals,” the president publicly claimed Pirro was “100%” wrong, reiterated that it had been a “pure case of VANDALISM,” maligned her for having “choked,” and reportedly considered replacing her. Burgum, meanwhile, dismissed Pirro’s argument, saying on social media, “The evidence is clear, vandals have repeatedly caused damage to the Reflecting Pool.”

The feud came to a head on Monday during what The New York Times described as an “Oval Office showdown” attended by Trump, Pirro, and Burgum.

“During the meeting on Monday, Ms. Pirro, her voice raised at times, directly confronted Mr. Burgum, accusing him of misleading the president,” the Times reported. “She made the case that Mr. Burgum had promoted a self-serving cover story to conceal his own missteps.”

Curiously, Pirro’s former colleagues at Fox seem to be avoiding taking sides in the fracas. The network’s coverage is noticeably muted, with her former “opinion side” stablemates in particular ignoring it (or in the case of Laura Ingraham, mentioning it in passing only to mock unnamed commentators for “obsessing about things like Trump’s Reflecting Pool drama”).

Reprinted with permission from Media Matters

Hey Kids! Meet 'Coalie,' New Mascot For The Trump Team's Climate Deniers

Hey Kids! Meet 'Coalie,' New Mascot For The Trump Team's Climate Deniers

Hey kids, it’s Coalie! He’s a cute and cuddly lump of coal wearing a hardhat, and he’s here to tell you just how great coal mining is and just how great the Trump administration is at mitigating the harms caused by coal mining.

Coalie made his debut Wednesday on the official government webpage for the Office of Surface Mining Reclamation and Enforcement, a division of the Department of the Interior. OSMRE just dropped a listicle with the “10 Things to Know About How OSMRE Supports America’s Energy Legacy and Communities,” with Coalie as your guide.

This list is ostensibly about how OSMRE supports not only coal mining but also the reclamation efforts after coal mines are used up and abandoned. Sure, the amounts charged to coal companies to help pay for reclamation have plummeted over the years, and sure, there’s currently no pushback from this reclamation-loving administration over congressional efforts to strip money from a dedicated fund for mine cleanup and give it to the National Forest Service instead.

But just hear Coalie out, okay? Per the anthropomorphized talking lump of coal, one of the top 10 things OSMRE does is “evaluate potential environmental impacts of federal actions” as required under the National Environmental Policy Act, or NEPA.

Well, Coalie—we have to admit that balancing “responsible stewardship with opportunities for public input” does sound pretty great. But Coalie apparently overlooked that the administration is fast-tracking and minimizing NEPA reviews of proposed mines as part of an overall push to limit public input on environmental issues and drastically restrict environmental review. That sounds much more like no stewardship at all.

Oh Coalie, how could you lie to us?

Coalie also wants you to know that the Trump administration supports coal miners and their families.

“Each year, OSMRE transfers more than $1 billion to the United Mine Workers of America Health and Retirement Funds to support health care and pension benefits for eligible coal miners and their beneficiaries,” the website claims.

“Transfers” is doing a lot of heavy lifting in that sentence. That’s because the federal government does not provide more than $1 billion per year in pensions and benefits to coal miners.

UMWA receives some federal funding, but is largely funded by premiums that coal companies are required by law to pay. The government is also responsible for transferring interest from the Abandoned Mine Reclamation Fund to UMWA, but the AMRF is funded by fees assessed to coal companies for each ton of coal produced. So, what the administration and Coalie are bragging about here is quite literally just transferring the money collected from coal companies to the UMWA funds, as required by law.

Coalie, it sure feels like you’re trying to pull the wool over our eyes here.

Any attempt by this administration to say it prioritizes the health and safety of miners is undercut by its eagerness to make black lung disease great again by thwarting desperately needed regulations, such as one that would have restricted exposure to silica dust.

No one wants coal mining as much as President Donald Trump wants coal mining. Well, except maybe for Coalie.

Even coal companies don’t want coal mining as much as Trump or Coalie want coal mining. The administration has resorted to forcing energy companies to keep their aging coal plants open, even when they were already winding down operations and even though keeping them open would cost consumers more, not less. It also created a $625 million slush fund for coal plant owners to upgrade their aging plants rather than close them.

The Department of the Interior opened up a swath of public land to coal mining, eager to get cash from all those companies thrilled to pay for the privilege—only to find out that companies didn’t really want to do that at all and offered only a pittance for the land.

Apparently it is very hard to convince people—even coal industry people—that coal is super great. But hey, that’s just because they haven’t met Coalie yet. That cute little lump of coal is bound to turn things right around.

Reprinted with permission from Daily Kos

Russian oil

Did America's Enemies Write Trump's Backward Energy Policy?

President Donald Trump's energy policy is utterly screwed up — if you assume that advancing America's interests, and not pleasing his fossil fuel friends, is the objective.

This came to the fore when trade adviser Peter Navarro hollered at India for buying Russian oil. Navarro called the purchases "opportunistic and deeply corrosive" of efforts to isolate Russia and curb Vladimir Putin's war machine. Oh, is Trump isolating Putin? Could fool us.

Navarro is right that Russia's oil wealth is funding Putin's savage attacks on Ukraine. If so, then wouldn't it be in our interests to speed the move away from fossil fuels? That's the path Western Europe took shortly after the Russian tanks rolled into Ukraine.

On the contrary, Interior Secretary Doug Burgum is now demanding that projects "related to wind and solar energy facilities" go through new layers of political review. In other words, slow or kill them.

Energy Secretary Chris Wright has canceled a federal loan guarantee to build an $11 billion transmission line through the Heartland. The Grain Belt Express was to send electricity generated by Kansas wind farms across four states. The states involved — Kansas, Missouri, Illinois and Indiana — had all approved the project. For reasons easy to guess, Missouri Republican Sen. Josh Hawley sided with Trump against the venture.

Invenergy, the Grain Belt Express developer, called Hawley's opposition "bizarre." Writing on X, the company accused Hawley of being against an infrastructure project "aligned with the President's energy dominance agenda."

As though Trump has an energy dominance agenda, as opposed to a slogan. Does even Trump believe that, well into the 21st century, fossil fuels are the golden-brick road to energy dominance? If he does, that would be most concerning of all.

Trump clearly hasn't read China's plan for "energy dominance."

China now dominates in electric vehicles, solar, wind and batteries. Electricity now accounts for 30 percent of its energy consumption versus only 20 percent in the U.S. The Financial Times reports that China is on its way to becoming the first "electrostate."

Electric vehicles represent both the present and future of transport. Trump is actively handing the EV market to China. He started by pushing Republicans to kill federal tax credits incentivizing Americans to buy or lease electric vehicles. (They end on October 1.)

Ford CEO Jim Farley recently called China's rise in the EV market the "most humbling experience" of his career. "Their cost, their quality of their vehicles is far superior to what I see in the West."

Also gone are tax credits for wind and solar power. As a result, dozens of EV or clean energy projects — investments totaling $27 billion — have been canceled.

Over half of Iowa's electricity now comes from wind power. And on sunny and windy days in Texas, wind and solar power can supply over 60 percent of the ERCOT grid's fuel mix. (ERCOT manages about 90 percent of the electricity flow in Texas.)

Trump's tariff mania, meanwhile, has thrown wrenches in the ability of both green and fossil fuel energy producers to plan their investments. Interestingly, it is hurting oil more than clean energy. Since April 2, when Trump launched his trade war "Liberation Day," S&P's main index for oil stocks has fallen four percent. By contrast, the S&P index tracking clean energy companies is up about 18 percent.

Trump continues to bellow about the "energy dominance" thing, by which he's clearly shown he means helping fossil fuels and hurting the green alternatives. He also goes on about cheaper gas, which is not what the oil business wants for obvious reasons.

Want to defang Putin and save the heating planet from environmental collapse? Trump is totally off that case. Only America's enemies could craft a more damaging energy policy.

Froma Harrop is an award winning journalist who covers politics, economics and culture. She has worked on the Reuters business desk, edited economics reports for The New York Times News Service and served on the Providence Journal editorial board.

Reprinted with permission from Creators.

Shop our Store

Headlines

Editor's Blog

Trending

World