How To Punish Trump For Sedition Even If Impeachment Fails
Trying to persuade Republican senators to convict former President Donald Trump in an impeachment trial is like trying to sell tickets for a trip on the Titanic after it sank. There is no more Titanic, and you wouldn't want to be on it anyway. They can't remove Trump from office now, and they wouldn't if they could.
Even Republican senators who are still suffering panic attacks about the Capitol violence must wonder if there is any point to impeaching the president who lit a fire under the mob.
Why vote to evict a president who is already gone? Why spend precious time debating the misdeeds of someone whom the American people have disowned? Why give Trump more time and attention?
On Tuesday, only five Republican senators voted to proceed with an impeachment trial. Given that at least 17 Republicans would have to vote for conviction, even holding a trial seems to be an exercise in futility.
There is a point to impeachment, of course. It doesn't take much imagination to realize that the Jan. 6 insurrection, deadly as it was, could have been far worse. Vice President Mike Pence and members of Congress could have been injured or killed. Congress could have been prevented from carrying out its responsibility to certify the Electoral College results.
Trump not only spurred his followers to disrupt the proceedings but declined to call them off once they stormed the Capitol — even though his own vice president was in danger. He obviously hoped to deploy these extremists to keep himself in office, despite the judgment of mere voters.
If those are not "high crimes and misdemeanors," what would be? Letting Trump go unpunished would encourage future presidents to emulate his criminal behavior.
Republicans have a point. So do Democrats. Fortunately, there is another option that would accomplish the most important purpose of convicting Trump — and would have a very good chance of success. As law professors Bruce Ackerman of Yale and Gerard Magliocca of Indiana University noted in The Washington Post, the 14th Amendment to the Constitution has a provision that fits our current needs.
It says that any "officer of the United States" who has "engaged in insurrection or rebellion" against the Constitution "or given aid or comfort to the enemies thereof" shall not be allowed to hold "any office, civil or military, under the United States." Ratified after the Civil War, this section was meant to prevent former Confederate leaders from gaining positions of power in the government they waged war against.
But it would apply equally to anyone else who actively encourages a violent uprising, as Trump did. Senate Republican leader Mitch McConnell affirmed the obvious when he said: "The mob was fed lies. They were provoked by the president and other powerful people. And they tried to use fear and violence to stop a specific proceeding of the first branch of the federal government, which they did not like." That is sedition, plain and simple.
The main value of convicting Trump is that it would allow the Senate to take a separate vote to forbid him from running for president again. But under the 14th Amendment, Congress could impose a ban even without a conviction. As Ackerman and Magliocca explain, "Congress would simply need to declare that Trump engaged in an act of 'insurrection or rebellion' by encouraging the attack on the Capitol."
This option has several advantages. First, it would take only a simple majority of both houses. Second, it would give Republicans a middle way between convicting Trump in an impeachment trial and impersonating potted plants. For members thinking of running for president in 2024, it would take him out of the race.
What's in it for Democrats? Their chief purpose is making sure that Trump will never be president again. Using the 14th Amendment would be a reasonable alternative, particularly if it would attract a significant amount of Republican support.
It could be done quickly, freeing Democrats to move on to urgent policy matters, instead of delaying President Joe Biden's agenda. And it could not be undone by a future Congress without a two-thirds vote of each house.
It would also affix a unique and permanent mark of infamy on the 45th president, which he has earned in full. If the 14th Amendment ban was good enough for Jefferson Davis, it's good enough for Donald Trump.
Steve Chapman blogs at http://www.chicagotribune.com/news/opinion/chapman. Follow him on Twitter @SteveChapman13 or at https://www.facebook.com/stevechapman13. To find out more about Steve Chapman and read features by other Creators Syndicate writers and cartoonists, visit the Creators Syndicate website at www.creators.com.
- Trump Signals That His Coup Plotting Isn't Really Over - National ... ›
- Nikki Haley Burned Crispy For Urging Senate To 'Give Trump A ... ›
- How Trump Exploited The Legal Infrastructure To Advance Fascism ... ›
- #EndorseThis: 'Sedition!' Is Randy Rainbow's Latest Parody -- By ... ›
- Trump And Attorneys Reportedly Discussed Imposing 'Martial Law ... ›
- Second Trump Impeachment Looms As Democrats Demand Action ... ›
- #EndorseThis: Kimmel Smacks Trump Down Hard On Second ... ›
- With Feb. 9 Trial Looming, Five Lawyers Quit Trump's Impeachment ... ›
- Trump Revives ’Stop The Steal’ Lies In His Impeachment Response - National Memo ›
- Republicans Fear Embarrassment And Worse At Trump’s Senate Trial - National Memo ›
- Rep. Raskin, Impeachment Manager, Explains Succinctly Why Trial Must Proceed - National Memo ›
- Law Prof Cited By Trump Team Says They ‘Flat-Out Misrepresented’ His Work - National Memo ›
- Polls: Most Americans Want Trump Convicted And Barred From Federal Office - National Memo ›
- WATCH Rep. Raskin’s Powerful — And Tearful — Summation At Impeachment Trial - National Memo ›
- VIDEO: Raskin Shows How Trump ‘Praised And Encouraged And Cultivated Violence’ - National Memo ›
- #EndorseThis: Plaskett Proves Trump Was 'Directly Involved' In Instigating Capitol Riot - National Memo ›
- Some Republicans ‘Shaken’ By Horrific Riot Video — But Others Don’t Much Care - National Memo ›
- Republican Senators Joke About Trump’s Deadly Incitement To Rioters - National Memo ›
- They Fear Trump More Than They Love America - National Memo ›
- #EndorseThis: Kimmel Says 'Convict Him!' -- And Hilariously Shows How - National Memo ›
- Dishonor Roll: 22 Republicans Who Voted To Acquit Trump Admit He’s Guilty ›
- White House Slaps Down Texas Governor’s Pandemic Rant - National Memo ›
- Oh Dear: Trump’s Moribund Blog Is Officially Dead ›
- Opinion | Trump couldn't have incited sedition without the help of ... ›
- Opinion | Trump caused the assault on the Capitol. He must be ... ›
- Trump Is Guilty of Sedition and Must Be Brought to Justice | The Nation ›
- Justice Department, sedition charges for violent rioters | wusa9.com ›
- 'Reject sedition': House impeaches Trump in historic second rebuke ... ›
- Trump impeachment ›
- Trump Impeachment - The New York Times ›
- Sarah Longwell: GOP senators at Trump's impeachment trial are ... ›
- Trump's Influence On GOP Endures, Even As New Impeachment ... ›
- Trump Impeachment Trial: Who Are The Lawyers Defending Him ... ›